October 22, 2007
Bajaj v General Assur. (2007 NY Slip Op 27487)
https://www.beynensonlaw.com/case-law/bajaj-v-general-assur-2007-ny-slip-op-27487/
- Decided
- October 22, 2007
- Citation
- 2007 NY Slip Op 27487 · 18 Misc 3d 25
- Posture
- Trial
- Outcome
- Insurer prevailed
- Later treatment
- Declined to follow in 2, distinguished in 2 and followed in 15 later decisions (see Cited by)
- Legal questions
- Claimant's prima facie case at trial (see the maps)
Posture, outcome, issues and treatment by other decisions are Beynenson Law’s classification. Treatment labels are assigned by a language model reading the citing decision; negative and appeal-history labels are checked by a second reader.
Summary
Editorial summary by Beynenson Law, not part of the court’s decision.
Reported in New York Official Reports at Bajaj v General Assur. (2007 NY Slip Op 27487)
| Bajaj v General Assur. |
| 2007 NY Slip Op 27487 [18 Misc 3d 25] |
| Accepted for Miscellaneous Reports Publication |
| AT2 |
| Published by New York State Law Reporting Bureau pursuant to Judiciary Law § 431. |
| As corrected through Wednesday, January 30, 2008 |
[*1]
| Deepika Bajaj, as Assignee of Chivan Truong, Respondent, v General Assurance, Appellant. |
Supreme Court, Appellate Term, Second Department, October 22, 2007
APPEARANCES OF COUNSEL
Jeena R. Belil, Melville (Tina B. Davidson of counsel), for appellant. Harold Solomon, Rockville Centre (Bernard G. Chambers of counsel), for respondent.
Memorandum.
Judgment reversed without costs and judgment directed to be entered in favor of defendant dismissing the complaint.
In this action by a provider to recover assigned first-party no-fault benefits, plaintiff’s counsel offered, at the outset of trial, a notice to admit to which defendant had not responded, in order to prove plaintiff’s prima facie case, and then rested without calling any witnesses. Of particular relevance to the instant appeal was item 6 of the notice to admit which stated: “Annexed hereto is a true and accurate copy of a Notice of Denial issued by [defendant] dated June 23, 2003.” Annexed to the notice to admit was defendant’s denial of claim form which acknowledged receipt of a claim form and denied the claim pursuant to a peer review report finding a lack of medical necessity. Based upon defendant’s failure to respond to the notice to admit, the court deemed the matters sought therein to have been admitted (see CPLR 3123 [a]). The court also took judicial notice of plaintiff’s responses to defendant’s demand for written interrogatories, and the claim form and assignment of benefits form annexed thereto. Based upon the foregoing, the court found that plaintiff made a prima facie case, leaving defendant’s assertion of lack of medical necessity as the only remaining triable issue. Since defendant did not call any witnesses, the court held that defendant did not establish that the treatment rendered lacked medical necessity, and awarded judgment to plaintiff. This appeal by defendant ensued.
The use of a notice to admit in no-fault insurance litigation has become increasingly [*2]popular of late, and has been addressed with varying results in the lower courts (compare RJ Med., P.C.{**18 Misc 3d at 27} v All-State Ins. Co., 15 Misc 3d 1140[A], 2007 NY Slip Op 51061[U] [Civ Ct, Bronx County 2007], PDG Psychological, P.C. v State Farm Ins. Co., 12 Misc 3d 1183[A], 2006 NY Slip Op 51398[U] [Civ Ct, Kings County 2006], and Marigliano v State Farm Mut. Auto Ins. Co., 12 Misc 3d 1180[A], 2006 NY Slip Op 51349[U] [Civ Ct, Richmond County 2006], with Seaside Med., P.C. v General Assur. Co., 16 Misc 3d 758 [Dist Ct, Suffolk County 2007], and New York Massage Therapy P.C. v State Farm Mut. Ins. Co., 14 Misc 3d 1231[A], 2006 NY Slip Op 52573[U] [Civ Ct, Kings County 2006]).
Through the use of a notice to admit, a party can request another party to admit stated facts or the genuineness of a document, where the party requesting the admission “reasonably believes there can be no substantial dispute at the trial and . . . [where the matters] are within the knowledge of such other party or can be ascertained by him upon reasonable inquiry” (CPLR 3123 [a]; see also Taylor v Blair, 116 AD2d 204 [1986]). Copies of the documents must accompany the notice to admit unless they have already been furnished. The notice to admit may not be used to seek information which would not reasonably be expected to be within the personal knowledge of the party served (id.; see also Vasquez v Vengroff, 295 AD2d 421 [2002]). If a party fails to respond to a notice to admit within 20 days after service, the matters therein are deemed admitted for the purpose of the litigation (CPLR 3123 [a]; Marine Midland Bank v Custer, 97 AD2d 974 [1983], affd 62 NY2d 732 [1984]). A matter deemed admitted pursuant to a notice to admit, however, is still “subject to all pertinent objections to admissibility which may be interposed at the trial” (CPLR 3123 [b]), and it is not necessarily of such probative value as to relieve a party of the necessity of establishing its right to ultimate relief upon the trial (see 44A NY Jur 2d, Disclosure § 295, at 189 [1994]).
Accordingly, while it is true that a plaintiff provider establishes a prima facie entitlement to judgment as a matter of law “by submitting evidentiary proof that the prescribed statutory billing form had been mailed and received, and that payment of no-fault benefits was overdue” (Mary Immaculate Hosp. v Allstate Ins. Co., 5 AD3d 742, 742-743 [2004]), this language should not be interpreted as dispensing with the requirement that the provider tender said evidentiary proof of the transaction sued upon “in admissible form” (Zuckerman v City of New York, 49 NY2d 557, 558 [1980]). In Dan Med., P.C. v New York Cent. Mut.{**18 Misc 3d at 28} Fire Ins. Co. (14 Misc 3d 44 [App Term, 2d & 11th Jud Dists 2006]), this court held that the plaintiff provider was required to lay a proper foundation for the admissibility, under the business records exception to the hearsay rule (CPLR 4518), of the claim forms annexed to its motion for summary judgment in order to establish a prima facie case. Further, to the extent defendant insurer issued denial of claim forms or admitted receipt of plaintiff’s claim forms, we held that said admissions were not concessions of the facts asserted in plaintiff’s claim forms, and it was plaintiff’s burden to proffer such evidence in admissible form (Midborough Acupuncture, P.C. v New York Cent. Mut. Fire Ins. Co., 13 Misc 3d 132[A], 2006 NY Slip Op 51879[U] [App Term, 2d & 11th Jud Dists 2006]). Indeed, absent a foundation to establish the admissibility of the provider’s claim forms as business records, said claim forms do not constitute proof of the “act, transaction, occurrence or event” set forth therein for which plaintiff seeks to recover (CPLR 4518).
In the instant case, the admissions sought by plaintiff in the notice to admit were proper [*3]and, in the absence of a response, the court below correctly deemed the genuineness of the claim denial form to have been admitted. However, to the extent that defendant may have admitted, pursuant to CPLR 3123, the genuineness of the claim denial form, it did not thereby concede the admissibility of the provider’s claim form as a business record, pursuant to CPLR 4518, so as to constitute proof of the “act, transaction, occurrence or event” set forth therein, including, but not limited to, the dates of service, the services rendered and the charges therefor (see Midborough Acupuncture, P.C. v New York Cent. Mut. Fire Ins. Co., 13 Misc 3d 132[A], 2006 NY Slip Op 51879[U] [2006], supra). Similarly, even had defendant admitted, pursuant to CPLR 3123, the genuineness of the provider’s claim form which it received, this would not concede the facts set forth on the claim form with respect to the dates of service, the services rendered and the charges therefor. The admission would serve only to acknowledge that this was the claim form that it received.
Thus, it remained plaintiff’s burden to proffer evidence in admissible form, i.e., by introducing into evidence the claim form in question by, inter alia, calling a witness to lay a foundation for the admissibility of the claim form as a business record, which plaintiff failed to do (see Dan Med., P.C. v New York Cent. Mut. Fire Ins. Co., 14 Misc 3d 44 [2006], supra). Accordingly, in light of plaintiff’s failure to establish the admissibility of its{**18 Misc 3d at 29} claim form as a business record, plaintiff did not establish a prima facie case and defendant was entitled to judgment dismissing the complaint.
We note that an analogous scenario was presented in the case of Empire State Psychological Servs., P.C. v Travelers Ins. Co. (13 Misc 3d 131[A], 2006 NY Slip Op 51869[U] [App Term, 2d & 11th Jud Dists 2006]), where plaintiff’s sole proof at trial consisted of defendant’s response to written interrogatories in which defendant admitted that it received plaintiff’s claim form and that it denied said claim based upon lack of medical necessity. We held that said response did not establish plaintiff’s prima facie case. Defendant’s admission of receipt of a document denominated a claim form did not concede that plaintiff’s claim form was admissible as a business record so as to constitute proof of the transactions set forth therein (CPLR 4518) and, thus, defendant was entitled to judgment dismissing the complaint (cf. Fair Price Med. Supply, Inc. v St. Paul Travelers Ins. Co., 16 Misc 3d 8 [App Term, 1st Dept 2007]).
We further note, in any event, that with exceptions not applicable herein, a plaintiff’s responses to interrogatories may not be used as proof of plaintiff’s prima facie case (see CPLR 3131, 3117).
Pesce, P.J., Rios and Belen, JJ., concur.
Legal questions
A question of no-fault law this decision rules on, from our Legal Questions pages. Bars count the decisions on the question by year and court, coloured by category; circles are this decision and the decisions on the question it cites or that cite it. Point at a bar or circle for details. The categories and summaries are Beynenson Law’s classification, made by a language model and checked by a second reading.
What must a no-fault claimant prove at trial to make out its prima facie case for overdue benefits?
This decision: Insufficient: claim forms not admitted as business records / insurer's admissions held not to prove the claim
Held the claimant failed its prima facie case at trial because the deemed admission of the insurer's denial form did not make the claim form admissible as a business record, and no witness laid that foundation.
Of the 103 decisions on this question in the Second Department courts and the Court of Appeals, 21 (this one included) are in the same category. 4 decisions in other departments that cite or are cited by this one are on the full map.
Cited in this decision
A label shows how this decision treated the case it cites.
- RJ Med., P.C. v All-State Ins. Co. (2007 NY Slip Op 51061(U)) Contrasted (cf., but see)The provider failed to prove its no-fault claim at trial by relying solely on an unanswered notice to admit addressing material issues.
- PDG Psychological, P.C. v State Farm Ins. Co. (2006 NY Slip Op 51398(U)) Contrasted (cf., but see)A notice to admit cannot establish a provider's prima facie case by admitting the contents of bills and an assignment.
- Marigliano v State Farm Mut. Auto Ins. Co. (2006 NY Slip Op 51349(U)) Contrasted (cf., but see)A provider must introduce its NF-3 claim forms or their functional equivalent at trial to establish exactly what the insurer received.
- Seaside Med., P.C. v General Assur. Co. (2007 NY Slip Op 27258) Contrasted (cf., but see)Admissions under CPLR 3123 may collectively establish a provider's prima facie case when the individual requests are proper.
- New York Massage Therapy P.C. v State Farm Mut. Ins. Co. (2006 NY Slip Op 52573(U)) Contrasted (cf., but see)The insurer failed at trial to support its staged-accident defense with admissible evidence establishing a founded belief of no coverage.
- Mary Immaculate Hosp. v Allstate Ins. Co. (2004 NY Slip Op 02359)The hospitals established entitlement to summary judgment by proving that statutory billing forms were mailed and received and payment was overdue.
- Dan Med., P.C. v New York Cent. Mut. Fire Ins. Co. (2006 NY Slip Op 26483) FollowedThe provider failed to establish its prima facie case because its corporate officer did not lay a business-records foundation for the claim documents.
- Midborough Acupuncture, P.C. v New York Cent. Mut. Fire Ins. Co. (2006 NY Slip Op 51879(U)) FollowedThe provider's attorney affirmation failed to establish the admissibility of its claim forms or a prima facie entitlement to judgment.
- Empire State Psychological Servs., P.C. v Travelers Ins. Co. (2006 NY Slip Op 51869(U)) FollowedThe provider failed to prove its prima facie case at trial by offering only the insurer's interrogatory response acknowledging bills.
- Fair Price Med. Supply, Inc. v St. Paul Travelers Ins. Co. (2007 NY Slip Op 27173) Contrasted (cf., but see)The insurer's verified interrogatory answers established receipt and partial payment of the claims and defeated its proof-of-billing objection.
Cited by (31)
A label shows how the later decision treated this one.
- Central Nassau Diagnostic Imaging, P.C. v GEICO (2010 NY Slip Op 20244) Declined to followA provider may establish entitlement to overdue no-fault benefits through an insurer's admissions resulting from an unanswered notice to admit.
- Advanced Tempromandibular Disorder & Dental Surgery v Progressive Northeastern Ins. Co. (2010 NY Slip Op 20047) Declined to followA provider may establish its prima facie no-fault case at trial through an unanswered notice to admit without witness testimony.
- Alleviation Med. Servs., PC v Hertz Co. (2015 NY Slip Op 25285) DistinguishedA provider may establish claim submission and receipt through admissions in denials annexed to the defendant's interrogatory response.
- Elmont Open MRI & Diagnostic Radiology, PC v New York Cent. Mut. Fire Ins. Co. (2010 NY Slip Op 51588(U)) DistinguishedThe provider proved timely claim submission through admitted receipt dates, and the insurer failed to prove the MRIs were unnecessary.
- Andrew Carothers, M.D., P.C. v GEICO Indem. Co. (2009 NY Slip Op 29155) FollowedThe provider's billing witness failed to lay a business records foundation, leaving the provider without a prima facie case at trial.
- Second Med., P.C. v Auto One Ins. Co. (2008 NY Slip Op 28169) FollowedA billing company's incorporation of a provider's records into a claim form does not cure hearsay in the underlying records.
- Bath Med. Supply, Inc. v Utica Mut. Ins. Co. (2009 NY Slip Op 51030(U)) FollowedThe provider failed to prove its trial prima facie case because it did not establish admissibility of its claim forms as business records.
- Lenox Hill Radiology v New York Cent. Mut. Fire Ins. Co. (2008 NY Slip Op 28275) FollowedThe insurer failed to prove its MRI fee reduction, and the provider failed to establish a business-record foundation for its claim form.
- H & H Chiropractic Servs., P.C. v Metropolitan Prop. & Cas. Ins. Co. (2015 NY Slip Op 25132) FollowedImpermissible fee-splitting alone does not violate a licensing requirement or furnish a defense to a no-fault claim.
- Elmont Open MRI & Diagnostic Radiology, P.C. v GEICO Ins. Co. (2008 NY Slip Op 50113(U)) FollowedAn insurer denying a health-service claim in full must use the prescribed NF-10 form; approved modified forms are limited to partial denials.
Show all 31 citing decisions
- A.M. Med. Servs., P.C. v Progressive Cas. Ins. Co. (2008 NY Slip Op 51471(U)) Followed
- Psychmetrics Med., P.C. v Travelers Ins. Co. (2008 NY Slip Op 52466(U)) Followed
- All Mental Care Medicine, P.C. v State Farm Mut. Ins. Co. (2009 NY Slip Op 50042(U)) Followed
- V.S. Med. Servs., P.C. v Travelers Ins. Co. (2009 NY Slip Op 50048(U)) Followed
- Dilon Med. Supply Corp. v Travelers Ins. Co. (2009 NY Slip Op 50389(U)) Followed
- PDG Psychological, P.C. v Progressive Cas. Ins. Co. (2009 NY Slip Op 50436(U)) Followed
- PDG Psychological, P.C. v Travelers Ins. Co. (2009 NY Slip Op 50437(U)) Followed
- Open MRI of Tarrytown v GEICO Ins. Co. (2009 NY Slip Op 50874(U)) Followed
- Allstate Social Work & Psychological Servs., PLLC v GEICO Gen. Ins. Co. (2011 NY Slip Op 21234) Followed
- Victory Med. Diagnostics, P.C. v Nationwide Prop. & Cas. Ins. Co. (2012 NY Slip Op 22149)
- Chester Med. Diagnostic, P.C. v Kemper Cas. Ins. Co. (2008 NY Slip Op 52009(U))
- Elmont Open MRI & Diagnostic Radiology, P.C. v New York Cent. Mut. Fire Ins. Co. (2012 NY Slip Op 22242)
- Connely v Progressive Casualty Insurance Co. (2008 NY Slip Op 52589(U))
- Midisland Med., PLLC v Allstate Ins. Co. (2008 NY Slip Op 51760(U))
- Vista Surgical Supplies, Inc. v State Farm Mut. Ins. Co. (2009 NY Slip Op 50047(U))
- Media Neurology, P.C. v Liberty Mut. Ins. Co. (2009 NY Slip Op 51424(U))
- Advanced Neurological Care, P.C. v State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co. (2012 NY Slip Op 52203(U))
- AR Med. Rehabilitation, P.C. v GEICO Gen. Ins. Co. (2013 NY Slip Op 50510(U))
- V.S. Med. Servs., P.C. v Travelers Ins. Co. (2013 NY Slip Op 50973(U))
- Metro Health Prods., Inc. v State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co. (2015 NY Slip Op 51451(U))
- Top Choice Pharm. Corp. v Merchants Mut. Ins. Co. (2022 NY Slip Op 50867(U))
Similar decisions
- Prime Psychological Servs., P.C. v Auto One Ins. Co. (2008 NY Slip Op 50162(U))The provider failed to establish its trial prima facie case because it omitted the documents identified as attached to its notice to admit.
- Custom Orthotics of NY, Inc. v State Farm Mut. Auto Ins. Co. (2007 NY Slip Op 27549)The provider failed to establish its prima facie case at trial through the insurer's qualified admissions and unauthenticated documents.
- Viviane Etienne Med. Care, P.C. v Country-Wide Ins. Co. (2011 NY Slip Op 21039)The provider failed to establish its prima facie case because its third-party biller's affidavit lacked a business-record foundation.