• 347-746-6001
  • contact@beynensonlaw.com
Beynenson Law
Beynenson Law
  • Services
    • Search Case Law & Regulations
    • New Decisions
    • Decisions by Court
    • Legal Questions
    • No-Fault Regulations
    • Claim Process & Deadlines
    • Ask No-Fault AI
    • Arbitrator Scorecard
    • Award Volume
    • Arbitrator / Carrier Data
    • Provider / Carrier Data
    • Provider / Attorney Data
    • Arbitration Pro Extension
  • About Us
  • Contact
  • East Hampton, New York

  • 347-746-6001
  • contact@beynensonlaw.com
  • Services
    • Search Case Law & Regulations
    • New Decisions
    • Decisions by Court
    • Legal Questions
    • No-Fault Regulations
    • Claim Process & Deadlines
    • Ask No-Fault AI
    • Arbitrator Scorecard
    • Award Volume
    • Arbitrator / Carrier Data
    • Provider / Carrier Data
    • Provider / Attorney Data
    • Arbitration Pro Extension
  • About Us
  • Contact
April 10, 2009

Andrew Carothers, M.D., P.C. v GEICO Indem. Co. (2009 NY Slip Op 29155)

https://www.beynensonlaw.com/case-law/andrew-carothers-m-d-p-c-v-geico-indem-co-2009-ny-slip-op-29155/

Court
Appellate Term, Second Department
Decided
April 10, 2009
Citation
2009 NY Slip Op 29155 · 24 Misc 3d 19
Posture
Trial
Outcome
Insurer prevailed
Later treatment
Followed in 8 later decisions (see Cited by)
Issues
Provider's prima facie case Trial and evidence
Legal questions
Claimant's prima facie case at trial (see the maps)
Cite as
Andrew Carothers, M.D., P.C. v GEICO Indem. Co., 24 Misc 3d 19 (App Term, 2d Dept 2009)

Posture, outcome, issues and treatment by other decisions are Beynenson Law’s classification. Treatment labels are assigned by a language model reading the citing decision; negative and appeal-history labels are checked by a second reader.

Summary

Editorial summary by Beynenson Law, not part of the court’s decision.

The provider's billing witness failed to lay a business records foundation, leaving the provider without a prima facie case at trial. The witness worked for an outside billing company that received, printed, and mailed the provider's records without incorporating them into its own records. Even assuming familiarity with the provider's practices and competence to testify about them, the witness did not supply the foundation required by CPLR 4518 (a). Without admissible evidence, including claim forms, the provider failed to establish entitlement to payment under Insurance Law § 5106 (a). The Appellate Term, Second Department, reversed the provider's judgment and dismissed the complaint, stating that Pine Hollow Med., P.C. v Progressive Cas. Ins. Co. should no longer be followed to the extent inconsistent.

Reported in New York Official Reports at Andrew Carothers, M.D., P.C. v GEICO Indem. Co. (2009 NY Slip Op 29155)

Andrew Carothers, M.D., P.C. v GEICO Indem. Co.
2009 NY Slip Op 29155 [24 Misc 3d 19]
Accepted for Miscellaneous Reports Publication
AT2
Published by New York State Law Reporting Bureau pursuant to Judiciary Law § 431.
As corrected through Wednesday, July 22, 2009


[*1]
Andrew Carothers, M.D., P.C., as Assignee of Tatyana Matevich and Others, Respondent,
v
GEICO Indemnity Company, Appellant.

Supreme Court, Appellate Term, Second Department, April 10, 2009

APPEARANCES OF COUNSEL

Law Office of Teresa M. Spina, Woodbury (P. Stephanie Estevez of counsel), for appellant. Subin Associates, LLP, New York City (Gregory T. Cerchione of counsel), for respondent.

{**24 Misc 3d at 20} OPINION OF THE COURT

Memorandum.

Judgment reversed without costs and complaint dismissed.

At the trial of this action by a provider to recover assigned first-party no-fault benefits, the court admitted a series of documents into evidence, over defendant’s objection, upon the testimony of plaintiff’s sole witness, the billing manager for Advanced Health Care Solutions (AHCS), a company that was hired by plaintiff to handle its no-fault billing. Defendant appeals from the judgment entered in plaintiff’s favor, arguing that the witness failed to lay a business records foundation for the documents, that he was incompetent to do so, and that without said documents plaintiff failed to establish its entitlement to be paid (see Insurance Law § 5106 [a]; Mary Immaculate Hosp. v Allstate Ins. Co., 5 AD3d 742 [2004]; Dan Med., P.C. v New York Cent. Mut. Fire Ins. Co., 14 Misc 3d 44 [App Term, 2d & 11th Jud Dists 2006]). We agree.

The witness testified that plaintiff’s no-fault claim forms were prepared by plaintiff and transmitted electronically to AHCS to be printed and mailed to defendant. He further testified [*2]that the remaining subject documents were forwarded by plaintiff to AHCS. Even assuming that the witness was familiar with plaintiff’s business practices and procedures (see{**24 Misc 3d at 21} People v Surdis, 275 AD2d 553 [2000]), and that, as an employee of plaintiff’s billing company, the witness would be competent to testify about such practices and procedures (see Hochhauser v Electric Ins. Co., 46 AD3d 174, 182 [2007]), he still failed to establish, by laying the requisite foundation (see CPLR 4518 [a]), that the documents were plaintiff’s business records and, therefore, admissible in court pursuant to the business records exception to the rule against hearsay (see id.; People v DiSalvo, 284 AD2d 547 [2001]; Plymouth Rock Fuel Corp. v Leucadia, Inc., 117 AD2d 727 [1986]; Bajaj v General Assur., 18 Misc 3d 25, 28 [App Term, 2d & 11th Jud Dists 2007]; Second Med., P.C. v Auto One Ins. Co., 20 Misc 3d 291 [Civ Ct, Kings County 2008, Peter Paul Sweeney, J.]). Upon reconsideration of this court’s decision in Pine Hollow Med., P.C. v Progressive Cas. Ins. Co. (13 Misc 3d 131[A], 2006 NY Slip Op 51870[U] [App Term, 2d & 11th Jud Dists 2006]), we conclude that the law was misapplied to the facts presented in that case. Accordingly, to the extent that it is not in accord with this decision, it should no longer be followed.

In light of plaintiff’s failure to establish the admissibility of its evidence, including its claim forms, plaintiff did not establish a prima facie case (see Bajaj, 18 Misc 3d at 29). Even under the standard set forth in Pine Hollow Med., P.C. (13 Misc 3d 131[A], 2006 NY Slip Op 51870[U] [2006]), the witness’ testimony was not sufficient to lay the proper foundation for the records plaintiff sought to introduce into evidence because AHCS did not incorporate plaintiff’s records into its own records, but merely received, printed and mailed them. Accordingly, defendant was entitled to judgment dismissing the complaint.

Pesce, P.J., Weston and Golia, JJ., concur.

Legal questions

A question of no-fault law this decision rules on, from our Legal Questions pages. Bars count the decisions on the question by year and court, coloured by category; circles are this decision and the decisions on the question it cites or that cite it. Point at a bar or circle for details. The categories and summaries are Beynenson Law’s classification, made by a language model and checked by a second reading.

Claimant's prima facie case at trial

Open the full map

What must a no-fault claimant prove at trial to make out its prima facie case for overdue benefits?

This decision: Insufficient: claim forms not admitted as business records / insurer's admissions held not to prove the claim

Held at trial the provider did not establish a prima facie case because its billing company's witness could not lay a CPLR 4518 foundation for the claim forms, the company having merely printed and mailed the provider's records.

  • Appellate DivisionApp Div 3
  • Appellate TermApp Term 64
  • Trial courtsTrial 36
2008, Appellate Division: 1 decision (1 Other element missing)2006, Appellate Division: 1 decision (1 Other element missing)2010, Appellate Division: 1 decision (1 Business-record foundation lacking)2019, Appellate Term: 12 decisions (1 Proof sufficient, 11 Other element missing)2016, Appellate Term: 6 decisions (2 Proof sufficient, 4 Other element missing)2015, Appellate Term: 3 decisions (2 Proof sufficient, 1 Other element missing)2014, Appellate Term: 3 decisions (2 Proof sufficient, 1 Other element missing)2013, Appellate Term: 8 decisions (4 Proof sufficient, 1 Mailing/receipt not shown, 1 Business-record foundation lacking, 2 Other element missing)2012, Appellate Term: 1 decision (1 Mailing/receipt not shown)2011, Appellate Term: 2 decisions (1 Overdue not shown, 1 Other element missing)2010, Appellate Term: 3 decisions (2 Proof sufficient, 1 Business-record foundation lacking)2009, Appellate Term: 11 decisions (1 Proof sufficient, 1 Overdue not shown, 9 Business-record foundation lacking)2008, Appellate Term: 1 decision (1 Business-record foundation lacking)2006, Appellate Term: 3 decisions (2 Proof sufficient, 1 Business-record foundation lacking)2007, Appellate Term: 1 decision (1 Business-record foundation lacking)2017, Appellate Term: 3 decisions (3 Other element missing)2018, Appellate Term: 3 decisions (3 Other element missing)2020, Appellate Term: 2 decisions (1 Proof sufficient, 1 Other element missing)2022, Appellate Term: 1 decision (1 Other element missing)2025, Appellate Term: 1 decision (1 Other element missing)2017, Trial courts: 1 decision (1 Proof sufficient)2015, Trial courts: 3 decisions (2 Proof sufficient, 1 Other element missing)2013, Trial courts: 2 decisions (1 Business-record foundation lacking, 1 Other element missing)2011, Trial courts: 1 decision (1 Mailing/receipt not shown)2010, Trial courts: 4 decisions (4 Proof sufficient)2008, Trial courts: 5 decisions (2 Proof sufficient, 1 Overdue not shown, 2 Business-record foundation lacking)2007, Trial courts: 2 decisions (1 Proof sufficient, 1 Business-record foundation lacking)2006, Trial courts: 9 decisions (6 Proof sufficient, 1 Mailing/receipt not shown, 1 Business-record foundation lacking, 1 Other element missing)2004, Trial courts: 5 decisions (4 Proof sufficient, 1 Business-record foundation lacking)2005, Trial courts: 1 decision (1 Proof sufficient)2009, Trial courts: 1 decision (1 Proof sufficient)2021, Trial courts: 1 decision (1 Proof sufficient)2022, Trial courts: 1 decision (1 Other element missing)This decision
20052010201520202025
Proof sufficientMailing/receipt not shownOverdue not shownBusiness-record foundation lackingOther element missingThis decisionCites it or cited by itCited or followedDeclined to follow, questioned, overruled or reversed

Of the 103 decisions on this question in the Second Department courts and the Court of Appeals, 21 (this one included) are in the same category.

Cited in this decision

A label shows how this decision treated the case it cites.

  • Mary Immaculate Hosp. v Allstate Ins. Co. (2004 NY Slip Op 02359)The hospitals established entitlement to summary judgment by proving that statutory billing forms were mailed and received and payment was overdue.
  • Dan Med., P.C. v New York Cent. Mut. Fire Ins. Co. (2006 NY Slip Op 26483)The provider failed to establish its prima facie case because its corporate officer did not lay a business-records foundation for the claim documents.
  • Bajaj v General Assur. (2007 NY Slip Op 27487) FollowedAn insurer's admission that a denial form is genuine does not establish the provider's claim form as an admissible business record.
  • Second Med., P.C. v Auto One Ins. Co. (2008 NY Slip Op 28169)A billing company's incorporation of a provider's records into a claim form does not cure hearsay in the underlying records.
  • Pine Hollow Med., P.C. v Progressive Cas. Ins. Co. (2006 NY Slip Op 51870(U)) OverruledA billing company's records may incorporate provider information without the preparer having personal knowledge of its accuracy.

Cited by (11)

A label shows how the later decision treated this one.

  • Balance Chiropractic, P.C. v Property & Cas. Ins. Co. of Hartford (2010 NY Slip Op 50889(U)) FollowedThe provider's default judgment motion lacked personal-knowledge proof of its claim and an admissible business-records foundation.
  • Raz Acupuncture, P.C. v Travelers Prop. Cas. Ins. Co. (2010 NY Slip Op 50065(U)) FollowedThe provider failed to establish admissible business records through its third-party billing company's employee.
  • Andrew Carothers, M.D., P.C. v GEICO Indem. Co. (2009 NY Slip Op 52596(U)) FollowedThe provider failed to establish a prima facie case because its billing company's witness could not authenticate its business records.
  • Psychology YM, P.C. v Nationwide Mut. Ins. Co. (2009 NY Slip Op 51634(U)) FollowedThe provider failed to establish entitlement to summary judgment because its billing company's affidavit did not comply with CPLR 4518.
  • PMR Physical Therapy v Country-Wide Ins. Co. (2010 NY Slip Op 51729(U)) FollowedThe provider failed to establish admissible billing records because its third-party biller lacked demonstrated knowledge of its business practices.
  • Peace of Mind, Social Work, P.C. v Travelers Prop. Cas. (2013 NY Slip Op 51119(U)) FollowedThe provider failed to establish its claim form's admissibility because its third-party witness did not lay a foundation for the source records.
  • Carothers v GEICO Indem. Co. (2010 NY Slip Op 51718(U)) FollowedThe provider's trial judgment was reversed and its complaint dismissed because its documents were inadmissible and it lacked a prima facie case.
  • 563 Grand Med., P.C. v Kemper Auto & Home Ins. Co. (2010 NY Slip Op 50582(U)) FollowedThe provider failed to establish a business-record foundation through its outside billing company's employee and was denied summary judgment.
  • Viviane Etienne Med. Care, P.C. v Country-Wide Ins. Co. (2013 NY Slip Op 08430)A provider need not prove a claim's merits for summary judgment where the insurer failed to timely and properly deny the claim.
  • Axis Chiropractic, PLLC v GEICO Gen. Ins. Co. (2010 NY Slip Op 51339(U))The provider's billing-company affiant failed to show personal knowledge needed to establish a business-record foundation.
Show all 11 citing decisions
  • Axis Chiropractic, PLLC v Geico Gen. Ins. Co. (2010 NY Slip Op 51963(U))

Similar decisions

  • Matter of Carothers v GEICO Indem. Co. (2010 NY Slip Op 09256)The provider's billing witness failed to establish a business-records foundation for claim forms merely printed and mailed by the billing company.
  • PDG Psychological, P.C. v Progressive Cas. Ins. Co. (2009 NY Slip Op 50436(U))The provider's trial witnesses failed to establish a business-record foundation for its bill under CPLR 4518.
  • Andrew Carothers, M.D., P.C. v Travelers Ins. Co. (2006 NY Slip Op 52328(U))The insurer failed to prove lack of medical necessity through a peer-review report admitted only to establish claim receipt and timely denial.
  • Second Med., P.C. v GEICO (2012 NY Slip Op 50236(U))The provider failed to prove that the billed treatment was rendered because its claim forms lacked a business records foundation.
  • All Borough Group Med. Supply, Inc. v GEICO Ins. Co. (2013 NY Slip Op 23262)A witness familiar with a provider's office routine may lay a business-records foundation without having made the records.
Beynenson Law

Tech-driven New York no-fault collections for healthcare providers.

About the firm

Contact

  • East Hampton, New York

  • 347-746-6001
  • contact@beynensonlaw.com
  • Contact form

Research

  • Search Case Law & Regulations
  • New Decisions
  • Decisions by Court
  • Legal Questions
  • No-Fault Regulations
  • Claim Process & Deadlines
  • Ask No-Fault AI

Arbitration Data

  • Arbitrator Scorecard
  • Award Volume
  • Arbitrator / Carrier Data
  • Provider / Carrier Data
  • Provider / Attorney Data
  • Arbitration Pro Extension

©2026 The Beynenson Law Group, PC. Terms of Use Privacy Policy

Site by khrystev.dev

Attorney Advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. This website provides general information, not legal advice, and using it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Do not send confidential information through this site.