August 12, 2015
Alleviation Med. Servs., PC v Hertz Co. (2015 NY Slip Op 25285)
https://www.beynensonlaw.com/case-law/alleviation-med-servs-pc-v-hertz-co-2015-ny-slip-op-25285/
- Judge
- Mostofsky, J.
- Decided
- August 12, 2015
- Citation
- 2015 NY Slip Op 25285 · 49 Misc 3d 819
- Posture
- Summary judgment
- Outcome
- Provider prevailed
Posture, outcome, issues and treatment by other decisions are Beynenson Law’s classification. Treatment labels are assigned by a language model reading the citing decision; negative and appeal-history labels are checked by a second reader.
Summary
Editorial summary by Beynenson Law, not part of the court’s decision.
Reported in New York Official Reports at Alleviation Med. Servs., PC v Hertz Co. (2015 NY Slip Op 25285)
| Alleviation Med. Servs., PC v Hertz Co. |
| 2015 NY Slip Op 25285 [49 Misc 3d 819] |
| August 12, 2015 |
| Mostofsky, J. |
| Published by New York State Law Reporting Bureau pursuant to Judiciary Law § 431. |
| As corrected through Wednesday, November 25, 2015 |
[*1]
| Alleviation Medical Services, PC, as Assignee of Nadia Innocent, Plaintiff, v Hertz Co., Defendant. |
Civil Court of the City of New York, Kings County, August 12, 2015
Gary Tsirelman, PC, Brooklyn, for plaintiff.
Robyn M. Brilliant, New York City, for defendant.
{**49 Misc 3d at 820}Before trial, plaintiff sought summary judgment based on documentary evidence. The defendant appeared without witnesses. The parties submitted memoranda of law and the court heard oral argument on July 27, 2015.
Plaintiff claimed it served notices to admit on the defendant. Since the defendant never contested the admissions, the plaintiff moved for summary judgment. The court denies that portion of plaintiff’s motion since it never submitted the notices to admit.
Plaintiff also submitted defendant’s response to interrogatories with attached denials. One denial listed the claim’s date and the date defendant received it. The plaintiff moved for summary judgment because the denials are admissible under the admission exception to the hearsay rule and prove plaintiff mailed the claim to the defendant and it was received. The court grants summary judgment based on the admissions in the denials annexed to the interrogatory response.
In a matter of apparent first impression, the court must analyze the Court of Appeals decision in Viviane Etienne Med. Care, P.C. v Country-Wide Ins. Co. (25 NY3d 498 [2015]) to determine whether the plaintiff may prove a prima facie case based on defendant’s [*2]admissions.
Here, plaintiff submitted the defendant’s interrogatory response, and annexed three denials. Three independent medical examination (IME) letters scheduled examinations for June 29, 2011, July 6, 2011, and July 20, 2011. The first two do not state when the claim was made or received. The third denial, dated October 26, 2011, is based on the claimant’s failure to appear for IMEs on the scheduled dates. The denial lists the claim’s date and the date the defendant received the claim. Since the last missed IME was on July 20, 2011, the denial issued on October 26, 2011 was not issued within the 30-day time limit. (Insurance Law § 5106 [a]; 11 NYCRR 65-3.8 [c].)
The Appellate Term, First Department holds that any admissible evidence that shows plaintiff filed a no-fault claim proves its prima facie case, absent payment or a timely denial. Responses to notices to admit and interrogatories with admissions are admissible as admissions against interest and sufficiently prove plaintiff’s prima facie case. (Fair Price Med. Supply, Inc. v St. Paul Travelers Ins. Co., 16 Misc 3d 8 [App Term, 1st Dept 2007]; Central Nassau Diagnostic Imaging, P.C. v GEICO, 28 Misc 3d 34 [App Term, 1st Dept 2010].)
The Appellate Term, Second Department held that defendant’s responses to notices to admit could not establish plaintiff’s{**49 Misc 3d at 821} prima facie case, since the responses did not concede their admissibility. (Bath Med. Supply, Inc. v Utica Mut. Ins. Co., 23 Misc 3d 141[A], 2009 NY Slip Op 51030[U] [App Term, 2d Dept, 2d, 11th & 13th Jud Dists 2009]; Bajaj v General Assur., 18 Misc 3d 25, 28-29 [App Term, 2d Dept, 2d & 11th Jud Dists 2007].) Here, the plaintiff asks the court to grant its motion based on the admissions contained in the denials.
In Art of Healing Medicine, P.C. v Travelers Home & Mar. Ins. Co. (55 AD3d 644, 644 [2d Dept 2008]) the Second Department held medical service providers must prove the “admissibility of their billing records under the business records exception to the hearsay rule.”
The Appellate Term, Second Department, determined Art of Healing Medicine, P.C. required
“a plaintiff medical provider, as part of its prima facie burden, to establish that the claim forms annexed to the summary judgment motion are admissible as proof of the acts, transactions, occurrences, or events recorded therein pursuant to CPLR 4518 (a). Thus, in essence, [the Appellate Term, Second Department] required proof of the merits of the claim, in addition to proof of the billing.” (Viviane Etienne Med. Care, P.C. v Country-Wide Ins. Co., 114 AD3d 33, 43-44 [2d Dept 2013].)
But, in Viviane Etienne Med. Care, P.C. the Second Department overruled Art of Healing. The Court held plaintiff’s affidavits had to demonstrate proof of billing, its receipt and not the case’s merits. (Id. at 44-45.)
The Court of Appeals affirmed. (Viviane Etienne Med. Care, P.C. v Country-Wide Ins. Co., 25 NY3d 498 [2015].) The Court cited the no-fault claim procedures:
“The[ ] regulations require an accident victim to submit a notice of claim to the insurer as soon as [*3]practicable and no later than 30 days after an accident (see 11 NYCRR 65-1.1, 65-2.4 [b]). Next, the injured party or the assignee . . . must submit proof of claim for medical treatment no later than 45 days after services are rendered (see 11 NYCRR 65-1.1, 65-2.4 [c]). Upon receipt of one or more of the prescribed verification forms used to establish proof of claim, . . . an insurer has 15 business days within which to request ‘any additional verification required by the insurer to establish proof of claim’ (11 NYCRR 65-3.5 [b]). An insurer may also request{**49 Misc 3d at 822} ‘the original assignment or authorization to pay benefits form to establish proof of claim’ within this time frame (11 NYCRR 65-3.11 [c]). Significantly, an insurance company must pay or deny the claim within 30 calendar days after receipt of the proof of claim (see Insurance Law § 5106 [a]; 11 NYCRR 65-3.8 [c]). If an insurer seeks additional verification, however, the 30-day window is tolled until it receives the relevant information requested (see 11 NYCRR 65-3.8 [a] [1]) (Fair Price Med. Supply Corp. v Travelers Indem. Co., 10 NY3d 556, 562-563 [2008], quoting Hospital for Joint Diseases v Travelers Prop. Cas. Ins. Co., 9 NY3d 312, 317 [2007]; see Insurance Law § 5106 [a])” (id. at 505 [internal quotation marks omitted]).
Thus, to meet its burden on a summary judgment motion based on an overdue payment, the Court required that plaintiff prove, in admissible form, that a verification of treatment form was mailed to the defendant. (Id. at 507.) “Such proof may include the verification of treatment form and/or an affidavit from a person or entity (1) with knowledge of the claim and how it was sent to the insurer or (2) who has relied upon the forms in the performance of their business.” (Id. [emphasis added].) And “[a]dmissible evidence may include affidavits by persons having knowledge of the facts [and] reciting the material facts.” (Id. at 508 [emphasis added and internal quotation marks omitted].)
This court finds that when the Court of Appeals used the word “may” it was expansive. It envisioned that plaintiff could submit any admissible evidence to establish proper mailing and that defendant received the claim. And absent a timely denial regarding the claim forms themselves, a defendant cannot challenge the submission. (Id. at 506.)
The Court of Appeals held in a non-no-fault context that if “the party who served the interrogatories is the proponent, the hearsay problem is eliminated because the answers are admissible under the admissions exception to the hearsay rule.” (United Bank v Cambridge Sporting Goods Corp., 41 NY2d 254, 264 [1976].)
Defendant’s denial included an admission by defendant that proves exactly when the defendant received the claim. If an affidavit or testimony creates a presumption of mailing then an admission by defendant that it received the claim on a date certain, absent a denial, should create a rebuttable presumption that the mail was received.{**49 Misc 3d at 823}
This accords with the Court’s rulings that no-fault was enacted to ensure prompt payment of first-party insurance benefits “but within a . . . short-leashed contestable period” in which to deny “ill-founded, illegitimate and fraudulent claims” (Viviane Etienne, 25 NY3d at 507). The statute was created to “provide a tightly timed process of claim, disputation and payment.” (Presbyterian Hosp. in City of N.Y. v Maryland Cas. Co., 90 NY2d 274, 281 [1997].)
The defendant’s denial admitted when it received the claim, and defendant never challenged the claim [*4]forms or the timeliness of the denial, and had no trial witness. Thus the court holds and finds that the plaintiff met its prima facie burden of proof and is entitled to judgment.
Judgment for plaintiff for $5,036.94, plus statutory costs, interest and attorney fees.
Legal questions (3)
Questions of no-fault law this decision rules on, from our Legal Questions pages. Bars count the decisions on the question by year and court, coloured by category; circles are this decision and the decisions on the question it cites or that cite it. Point at a bar or circle for details. The categories and summaries are Beynenson Law’s classification, made by a language model and checked by a second reading.
On summary judgment or another pretrial motion, what must a no-fault claimant show to establish its prima facie case?
This decision: Claimant's proof held to make out its prima facie case
Held the provider made its prima facie case through the insurer's interrogatory answers annexing a denial that admitted the date the claim was received, absent a timely denial.
Of the 1,065 decisions on this question in the Second Department courts and the Court of Appeals, 513 (this one included) are in the same category.
Did a party’s evidence establish that it mailed a no-fault claim, denial, verification request or examination notice?
This decision: The provider's or claimant's proof established mailing of its claim form, NF-2 or verification response
Held the insurer's denial stating the date it received the claim, an admission against interest, created a presumption that the provider's claim was mailed and received.
Of the 1,400 decisions on this question in the Second Department courts and the Court of Appeals, 106 (this one included) are in the same category.
Is an IME/EUO no-show defense precluded if the insurer did not timely deny the claim on that ground?
This decision: No-show defense is subject to preclusion and fails for want of a timely, proper denial (rules on the question, but another ground decided the case)
Held the IME no-show denial untimely because it issued more than 30 days after the last missed IME, so it did not defeat the provider's claim.
Of the 508 decisions on this question in the Second Department courts and the Court of Appeals, 166 (this one included) are in the same category.
Cited in this decision
A label shows how this decision treated the case it cites.
- Viviane Etienne Med. Care, P.C. v Country-Wide Ins. Co. (2015 NY Slip Op 04787) FollowedA provider establishes entitlement to summary judgment on overdue no-fault claims with admissible proof of mailing and receipt of statutory claim forms.
- Fair Price Med. Supply, Inc. v St. Paul Travelers Ins. Co. (2007 NY Slip Op 27173) FollowedThe insurer's verified interrogatory answers established receipt and partial payment of the claims and defeated its proof-of-billing objection.
- Central Nassau Diagnostic Imaging, P.C. v GEICO (2010 NY Slip Op 20244) FollowedA provider may establish entitlement to overdue no-fault benefits through an insurer's admissions resulting from an unanswered notice to admit.
- Bath Med. Supply, Inc. v Utica Mut. Ins. Co. (2009 NY Slip Op 51030(U)) DistinguishedThe provider failed to prove its trial prima facie case because it did not establish admissibility of its claim forms as business records.
- Bajaj v General Assur. (2007 NY Slip Op 27487) DistinguishedAn insurer's admission that a denial form is genuine does not establish the provider's claim form as an admissible business record.
- Art of Healing Medicine, P.C. v Travelers Home & Mar. Ins. Co. (2008 NY Slip Op 07846)The providers failed to establish a prima facie case because they did not demonstrate the admissibility of their billing records.
- Viviane Etienne Med. Care, P.C. v Country-Wide Ins. Co. (2013 NY Slip Op 08430)A provider need not prove a claim's merits for summary judgment where the insurer failed to timely and properly deny the claim.
- Fair Price Med. Supply Corp. v Travelers Indem. Co. (2008 NY Slip Op 04946)An insurer's defense that billed supplies were never delivered is subject to preclusion for an untimely denial.
- Hospital for Joint Diseases v Travelers Prop. Cas. Ins. Co. (2007 NY Slip Op 09067)An insurer that fails to timely seek verification of an assignment cannot later contest its validity when the underlying claim is covered.
Similar decisions
- AR Med. Rehabilitation v State-Wide Ins. Co. (2015 NY Slip Op 25287)A provider may use the insurer's NF-10 denial as an admission of claim receipt without a business-record foundation.
- Advanced Tempromandibular Disorder & Dental Surgery v Progressive Northeastern Ins. Co. (2010 NY Slip Op 20047)A provider may establish its prima facie no-fault case at trial through an unanswered notice to admit without witness testimony.
- Health E. Ambulatory Surgical Ctr. v Country-Wide Ins. Co. (2025 NY Slip Op 06648)An insurer's admission in its motion papers that it received the claim may establish a provider's prima facie case at trial.
- A.B. Med. Servs. PLLC v Farm Family Cas. Ins. Co. (2004 NY Slip Op 24346)A denial's timeliness is measured by its mailing date, not the date printed on the denial form.
- Sea Side Med., P.C. v State Farm Mut. Auto Ins. Co. (2006 NY Slip Op 26246)A verification follow-up sent only 28 days after the initial request does not preserve the insurer's time to pay or deny a claim.