August 18, 2021
Park Ave. Chiropractic & Health Care PC v Maya Assur. Co. (2021 NY Slip Op 50804(U))
https://www.beynensonlaw.com/case-law/park-ave-chiropractic-health-care-pc-v-maya-assur-co-2021-ny-slip-op-50804u/
- Judge
- Howard-Algarin, J.
- Decided
- August 18, 2021
- Citation
- 2021 NY Slip Op 50804(U) · 72 Misc 3d 1219(A)
- Posture
- Summary judgment
- Outcome
- Insurer prevailed
- Issues
- EUO no-show
Posture, outcome, issues and treatment by other decisions are Beynenson Law’s classification. Treatment labels are assigned by a language model reading the citing decision; negative and appeal-history labels are checked by a second reader.
Summary
Editorial summary by Beynenson Law, not part of the court’s decision.
Reported in New York Official Reports at Park Ave. Chiropractic & Health Care PC v Maya Assur. Co. (2021 NY Slip Op 50804(U))
[*1]| Park Ave. Chiropractic & Health Care PC v Maya Assur. Co. |
| 2021 NY Slip Op 50804(U) [72 Misc 3d 1219(A)] |
| Decided on August 18, 2021 |
| Civil Court Of The City Of New York, Bronx County |
| Howard-Algarin, J. |
| Published by New York State Law Reporting Bureau pursuant to Judiciary Law § 431. |
| As corrected in part through August 30, 2021; it will not be published in the printed Official Reports. |
Decided on August 18, 2021
Park Avenue
Chiropractic & Health Care PC AAO Stecy Antoine, Plaintiff,
against Maya Assurance Company, Defendant. |
Index No. CV-713853-19/BX
Counsel for Plaintiff: Park Avenue Chiropractic & Health Care PC AAO Stacey Antione by Sander Barshay Grossman, LLC
Counsel for Defendant: Maya Assurance Company by Di Martini & Yi, LLP
John A. Howard-Algarin, J.
Recitation as Required by CPLR §2219(a): The following papers were read on this Motion for Summary Judgment
Papers NumberedDefendant’s Notice of Motion, Affirmation in Support, and Exhibits 1
Plaintiff’s Cross Motion, Affirmation in Opposition 2
Defendant’s Affirmation in Opposition and Reply Affirmation 3
Upon the foregoing cited papers, the Decision and Order of this Court is as follows:
In this action to recover assigned no-fault benefits, Petitioner seeks payment of eleven claims in the sum of $1,867.65 for medical services rendered to Assignor between July 23, 2018 and April 9, 2019, for injuries sustained in a motor vehicle accident. Defendant now moves, pursuant to CPLR § 3212, for summary judgment asserting that Plaintiff failed to appear for two scheduled examinations under oath (EUO), which failures, it is argued, entitle Defendant to deny the claims. Alternatively, Defendant seeks partial summary judgment on five of the eleven claims for services rendered by Plaintiff between November 26, 2018 and March 14, 2019, for want of medical necessity. Defendant relies on an Independent Medical Examination (IME) report from Dr. Robert Costello, D.C., as grounds for the alternative relief requested.
Plaintiff opposes the instant motion asserting that it provided Defendant with a written objection to the first scheduled EUO, and therefore, did not have to appear at either examination. Additionally, Plaintiff seeks to justify the medical necessity of the services provided by reliance on a medical report from Dr. Samuel Park, D.C. Because, as more fully explained below, this Court finds that Plaintiff was required to participate in the duly scheduled EUOs, notwithstanding its written objection to same to Defendant, it hereby grants Defendant’s motion and dismisses the Complaint with prejudice.
On a motion for summary judgment, the moving party must present sufficient evidence in admissible form to show the absence of any material issue of fact and the right to entitlement to judgment as a matter of law (Alvarez v Prospect Hospital, 68 NY2d 320, 326 [1986]; Winegrad v New York Univ. Med. Ctr., 64 NY2d 851 [1985]). If the moving party has [*2]established sufficient proof to warrant summary judgment, the burden shifts to the party opposing the motion to produce evidentiary proof in admissible form sufficient to establish the existence of material facts which require a trial (Zuckerman v City of New York, 49 NY2d 557 [1980]). If there are no material, triable issues of fact, summary judgment must be granted (Sillman v Twentieth Century-Fox Film Corp., 3 NY2d 395 [1957]). Issue finding, not issue determination, is the key to summary judgment (Rose v Da Ecib USA, 259 AD2d 258 [1st Dept 1999]). A mere conclusory assertion devoid of evidentiary facts is insufficient to defeat a well-supported summary judgment motion, as is reliance upon surmise, conjecture, or speculation (Grullon v City of New York, 297 AD2d 261 [1st Dept 2002]).
The failure of a person eligible for no-fault benefits or its assignee to appear for properly noticed EUOs constitutes a breach of a condition precedent to coverage (New York Presbyterian Hospital v Country—Wide Insurance, 17 NY3d 586 [2011]; Unitrin Advantage Ins Co v Dowd 194 AD3d 507 [1st Dept 2021]; Mapfre Ins. Co. of New York v Manoo, 140 AD3d 468, 470 [1st Dept 2016]; Allstate Ins. Co. v Pierre, 123 AD3d 618 [1st Dept 2014]). Such failure permits a carrier to deny, retroactively, all claims going back to the date of loss regardless of whether the denials were timely issued or whether the initial denials were based a different reason (Unitrin Advantage Ins. Co. v Bayshore Physical Therapy PPLC et al, 82 AD3d 559, 560 [1st Dept 2016]; Stephen Fogel Psychological PC v Progressive Casualty Ins. Co., 35 AD3d 720, 721-22 [2d Dept 2006]). To succeed on a summary judgment motion based on the failure of an assignee to appear at EOUs, an insurance carrier first must establish that it properly mailed notices for the EUOs (American Transit Ins. Co. v Lucas, 111 AD3d 423 [1st Dept 2013]). The presumption of receipt of mail may be established by either proof of actual mailing or proof of a standard office practice or procedure designed to ensure that items are properly addressed and mailed (Nassau Ins. Co. v Murray, 46 NY2d 828 [1978]; Residential Holding Corp. v Scottsdale Ins. Co., 286 AD2d [2d Dept 2001]; Matter of Francis v Wing, 263 AD2d 432 [1st Dept 1999]). In addition, the carrier must establish that the assignee failed to appear at said examinations (American Transit Ins. Co. v Lucas, 111 AD3d 423).
Relevant here, in support of its motion, Defendant submitted an affirmation from attorney Arthur J. DeMartini, whose firm conducts examinations under oath on Defendant’s behalf and received Defendant’s request to schedule Plaintiff’s two EUOs (Exh. G, DeMartini Aff. In Supp.). In the affirmation, DeMartini stated that before each EUO notice was mailed to Plaintiff and its counsel, he personally: (i) reviewed the EUO notice letters; (ii) verified the mailing addresses for Plaintiff and its counsel; and then, (iii) mailed the notices at the post office. Copies of the notices scheduling the EUOs for August 22, 2018 and September 14, 2019 were attached to his affirmation. Also attached to Defendant’s motion were certified transcripts of the two EUOs Plaintiff failed to attend. The transcripts reflect that on each EUO date, the assigned attorney, Helen Cohen of DeMartini & Yi, L.L.P., waited approximately 45 minutes prior to making a statement on the record cancelling the event upon Plaintiff’s failure to appear. Based on this evidence, Defendant has established that it properly notified Plaintiff and its attorney of both examinations, and that Plaintiff failed to appear on both occasions. Thus, Defendant has demonstrated its prima facia entitlement to summary judgment herein (Metro Psychological Services P.C. v Mercury Cas. Co., 49 Misc 3d 143 [A] [App Term, 1st Dept 2015]). Having done so, the burden now shifts to Plaintiff to raise a question of fact requiring a trial.
In opposition, Plaintiff does not dispute Defendant’s representation that it failed to appear [*3]at the EUOs. Rather, Plaintiff submits a letter dated August 23, 2018, in which Plaintiff’s counsel acknowledged receipt of Defendant’s notice for the August 22, 2018 EUO and requested that Defendant justify the need for same. Plaintiff’s letter also advised Defendant that the time and location of the August 22, 2018 EUO was not convenient for Plaintiff or its counsel. At the threshold, this Court finds that Plaintiff’s August 23, 2018 objection to the August 22, 2018 EUO was untimely insofar as the objecting document — written a day after the scheduled event — could not afford Defendant an opportunity either to reschedule the event to a new more convenient date or time, or to make the location of the examination more convenient (Accord, American Chiropractic, PC, v GEICO, 57 Misc 3d 529, 531 [Kings Cty Civ Ct 2017][construing as timely a request (or objection) by assignee to insurer when made “sufficiently prior to the date on which an EUO is scheduled to allow for a response”]). To be sure, by objecting to the EUO after the examination date has passed, Plaintiff, in addition to precluding any meaningful response by Defendant, would unnecessarily cause Defendant to incur otherwise avoidable expenses in the form of counsel and court reporter fees. Such a waste of time, effort and resources cannot be justified by this Court. Viewed this way, this Court finds that an objection to an EUO written after the scheduled examination date is, in effect, a nullity and of no effect. Further, to the extent Plaintiff received a second EUO notice and failed altogether to object to same, its objection will not now be heard (Flow Chiropractic, P.C. v Travelers Home and Mar. Ins. Co., 44 Misc 3d 132[A]).
Moreover, while courts have varied respecting whether an insurer must, in response to an objection or a demand for justification of an EUO, respond to same as a precondition to an assignor or assignee’s participation therein (compare, Amer. Transit Ins. Co. v Jaga Med. Svcs, P.C., 128 AD3d 441 [1st Dept 2015][unanimously reversing trial court’s grant of summary judgment upon finding that “the reason for an EUO is a fact essential” to granting summary relief]; with Bronx Chiropractic Care, P.C. v State Farm Ins. Co., 63 Misc 3d 132[A] [App Term, 2nd Dept 2019][ no requirement that insurance carrier provide reason for its demand for EUO]; Flow Chiropractic, P.C. v Travelers Home and Mar. Ins Co., 44 Misc 3d 132[A] [App Term, 2d Dept 2014]), we need not wrestle with that issue here. As noted above, the Court deems Plaintiff’s late objection letter a nullity requiring no response. Hence, Plaintiff’s late objection letter did not excuse its failure to appear at either of the duly noticed EUOs scheduled by Defendant. Thus, Plaintiff has failed to raise a triable question of fact to defeat Defendant’s well-supported summary judgment motion.
Finally, because Plaintiff’s failure to appear at the scheduled EUOs permits Defendant to deny, retroactively, all claims going back to the date of loss (Unitrin Advantage Ins. Co. v Bayshore Physical Therapy PPLC et al, 82 AD3d at 560; Stephen Fogel Psychological PC v Progressive Casualty Ins. Co., 35 AD3d at 721-22), this Court need not reach the medical necessity arguments raised by the parties in their respective submissions.
Based on the foregoing, Defendant’s summary judgment motion is GRANTED in its entirety, and the Clerk is directed to enter judgment granting the motion and dismissing the Complaint with prejudice.
Defendant is directed to serve a copy of this order, with notice of entry, upon Plaintiff within thirty (30) days of the entry date hereof.
This constitutes the decision and order of the Court.
Dated: August 18, 2021Bronx, New York
/S/
John A. Howard-Algarin, J.C.C.
Legal questions (3)
Questions of no-fault law this decision rules on, from our Legal Questions pages. Bars count the decisions on the question by year and court, coloured by category; circles are this decision and the decisions on the question it cites or that cite it. Point at a bar or circle for details. The categories and summaries are Beynenson Law’s classification, made by a language model and checked by a second reading.
Did the insurer prove its IME/EUO no-show defense: mailed, compliant scheduling requests and the claimant’s nonappearance?
This decision: Insurer proved mailed, compliant requests and the nonappearance; claimant's answers rejected
Held the insurer proved mailed EUO notices and two nonappearances, and the provider's objection, written after the first EUO date and absent for the second, was a nullity that did not excuse the nonappearance.
Of the 165 decisions on this question in the First Department courts and the Court of Appeals, 94 (this one included) are in the same category. 4 decisions in other departments that cite or are cited by this one are on the full map.
Is an IME/EUO no-show defense precluded if the insurer did not timely deny the claim on that ground?
This decision: No-show voids coverage; insurer need not show a timely denial (rules on the question, but another ground decided the case)
Held the EUO no-show breached a condition precedent to coverage, letting the insurer deny all claims retroactively regardless of the timeliness of its denials, so medical necessity was not reached.
Of the 36 decisions on this question in the First Department courts and the Court of Appeals, 29 (this one included) are in the same category.
Did a party’s evidence establish that it mailed a no-fault claim, denial, verification request or examination notice?
This decision: The insurer's (or its agent's) proof established mailing of its denial, verification request or IME/EUO notice (rules on the question, but another ground decided the case)
Held the affirmation of the EUO attorney, who personally verified addresses and mailed the notices, established that the provider and its counsel were properly notified of both EUOs.
Of the 161 decisions on this question in the First Department courts and the Court of Appeals, 110 (this one included) are in the same category. One decision in other departments that cites or is cited by this one is on the full map.
Cited in this decision
A label shows how this decision treated the case it cites.
- New York & Presbyt. Hosp. v Country-Wide Ins. Co. (2011 NY Slip Op 07149)A timely proof of claim does not satisfy the 30-day accident-notice requirement when submitted after that period expires.
- Unitrin Advantage Ins. Co. v Dowd (2021 NY Slip Op 03012)A provider's failure to attend a timely requested EUO voids coverage for all claims, rather than only the bill prompting the request.
- Mapfre Ins. Co. of N.Y. v Manoo (2016 NY Slip Op 04446)EUO requests made before receipt of a claim form are not subject to the verification notice requirements of 11 NYCRR 65-3.5 and 65-3.6.
- Allstate Ins. Co. v Pierre (2014 NY Slip Op 08921)Failure to attend requested EUOs breaches a no-fault coverage condition, regardless of denial timeliness or willfulness.
- Unitrin Advantage Ins. Co. v Bayshore Physical Therapy, PLLC (2011 NY Slip Op 01948) FollowedAn assignor's failure to attend required IMEs permits retroactive denial of no-fault claims regardless of denial timeliness.
- Stephen Fogel Psychological, P.C. v Progressive Cas. Ins. Co. (2006 NY Slip Op 09604) FollowedAn insurer may deny benefits retroactively to the date of loss for failure to attend reasonably required IMEs under 11 NYCRR 65-1.1.
- American Tr. Ins. Co. v Lucas (2013 NY Slip Op 07273) FollowedFailure to attend duly scheduled IMEs voids the policy ab initio and permits retroactive denial of claims regardless of denial timeliness.
- Metro Psychological Servs., P.C. v Mercury Cas. Co. (2015 NY Slip Op 51644(U)) FollowedAn EUO request issued after an assignor misses a rescheduled EUO constitutes a follow-up request under 11 NYCRR 65-3.6 (b).
- American Chiropractic Care, P.C. v GEICO Ins. (2017 NY Slip Op 27272)An insurer must provide a good-faith basis for a provider EUO when the provider timely requests an explanation before the scheduled date.
- Flow Chiropractic, P.C. v Travelers Home & Mar. Ins. Co. (2014 NY Slip Op 51142(U)) FollowedAn insurer's EUO scheduling notice need not specify why the EUO is required.
- American Tr. Ins. Co. v Jaga Med. Servs., P.C. (2015 NY Slip Op 03925) Contrasted (cf., but see)The insurer's summary judgment motion based on the claimant's EUO nonappearance was denied because essential discovery remained outstanding.
- Bronx Chiropractic Care, P.C. v State Farm Ins. (2019 NY Slip Op 50423(U))An insurer need not disclose the reasons or objective standards for its EUO demands in scheduling letters or in response to a provider's objection.
Similar decisions
- New York Core Chiropractic, P.C. v Ameriprise Ins. Co. (2021 NY Slip Op 50599(U))An EUO request sent after 15 business days but within 30 calendar days tolls the time to pay or deny, with a reduction for lateness.
- GBI Acupuncture, P.C. v Esurance Ins. Co. (2012 NY Slip Op 52423(U))The insurer established timely mailing of EUO notices and denials and the assignor's failure to appear for EUOs. The Civil Court, Kings County, granted the insurer summary judgment dismissing the complaint with prejudice and denied the providers' cross motion.
- Sloan v Nationwide Mut. Ins. Co. (2022 NY Slip Op 50997(U))The insurer's EUO defense failed because its initial request and its denial following the second nonappearance were untimely.
- Natural Therapy Acupuncture, P.C. v State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co. (2013 NYSlip Op 51935(U))The provider's EUO objections were unpreserved, and the insurer established timely notices and denials and the provider's nonappearance.
- Neuro Rehab Med. Servs. of S.I., P.C. v State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co. (2018 NY Slip Op 50671(U))The insurer established proper EUO notices, two unexcused nonappearances, and timely denials of the provider's claims.