February 17, 2010
Advanced Tempromandibular Disorder & Dental Surgery v Progressive Northeastern Ins. Co. (2010 NY Slip Op 20047)
https://www.beynensonlaw.com/case-law/advanced-tempromandibular-disorder-dental-surgery-v-progressive-northeastern-ins-co-2010-ny-slip-op-20047/
- Judge
- Hackeling, J.
- Decided
- February 17, 2010
- Citation
- 2010 NY Slip Op 20047 · 27 Misc 3d 436
- Posture
- Trial
- Outcome
- Provider prevailed
- Later treatment
- Followed in 1 later decision (see Cited by)
- Legal questions
- Claimant's prima facie case at trial (see the maps)
Posture, outcome, issues and treatment by other decisions are Beynenson Law’s classification. Treatment labels are assigned by a language model reading the citing decision; negative and appeal-history labels are checked by a second reader.
Summary
Editorial summary by Beynenson Law, not part of the court’s decision.
Reported in New York Official Reports at Advanced Tempromandibular Disorder & Dental Surgery v Progressive Northeastern Ins. Co. (2010 NY Slip Op 20047)
| Advanced Tempromandibular Disorder & Dental Surgery v Progressive Northeastern Ins. Co. |
| 2010 NY Slip Op 20047 [27 Misc 3d 436] |
| February 17, 2010 |
| Hackeling, J. |
| District Court Of Suffolk County, Third District |
| Published by New York State Law Reporting Bureau pursuant to Judiciary Law § 431. |
| As corrected through Wednesday, May 12, 2010 |
[*1]
| Advanced Tempromandibular Disorder & Dental Surgery, as Assignee of Kira Lanskaya, Plaintiff, v Progressive Northeastern Ins. Co., Defendant. |
District Court of Suffolk County, Third District, February 17, 2010
APPEARANCES OF COUNSEL
Rapuzzi, Palumbo & Rosenberger, P.C., Wantagh (Jason A. Moroff of counsel), for plaintiff. Carman, Callahan & Ingham, LLP, Farmingdale (Evelina K. Popijakowska of counsel), for defendant.
{**27 Misc 3d at 437} OPINION OF THE COURT
C. Stephen Hackeling, J.
At a trial of the above-captioned “medical service provider no-fault” action conducted December 17, 2009, neither side presented witnesses. Instead, the plaintiff offered into evidence a notice to admit dated November 13, 2009 which asked the defendant to admit it received the attached claim and assignment for no-fault medical provider services for $1,184.66, that the defendant denied the claim and that payment was not made thereon. Thereafter, the plaintiff rested asserting the establishment of a prima facie cause of action pursuant to Insurance Law § 5106 (a). The defendant conceded it did not respond to the notice to admit and presented no testimony or alternative evidence. It is the defendant’s contention that it need not establish its affirmative defense of lack of medical necessity as the plaintiff has not carried its burden of establishing a prima facie cause of action.
The issue presented to the court for disposition is whether a no-fault medical service provider can establish its section 5106 (a) prima facie cause of action through a notice to admit. It is the court’s opinion that it can.
The court concurs with the plaintiff’s assertion that New York’s courts have consistently [*2]held that a plaintiff in a medical service provider no-fault matter establishes its prima facie entitlement to relief by demonstrating: (1) the prescribed statutory billing forms were mailed to and received by the defendant; and (2) payment of no-fault benefits is overdue. (See Insurance Law § 5106 [a]; Kipor Medicine P.C. v MVAIC, 23 Misc 3d 948 [Civ Ct, Kings County 2009], citing Fair Price Med. Supply Corp. v Travelers Indem. Co., 10 NY3d 556 [2008]; Presbyterian Hosp. in City of N.Y. v Maryland Cas. Co., 90 NY2d 274 [1997]; see generally Nyack Hosp. v Metropolitan Prop. & Cas. Ins. Co., 16 AD3d 564 [2d Dept 2005]; Mary Immaculate Hosp. v Allstate Ins. Co., 5 AD3d 742 [2d Dept 2004].)
At first blush it would appear that two such noncomplex elements could appropriately be established via a CPLR 3123 formal judicial admission. However, the Appellate Term, Second Department, for the 2d, 11th and 13th Judicial Districts has determined that a notice to admit, by itself, is not evidentiary proof sufficient to establish a prima facie case, and that witness{**27 Misc 3d at 438} testimony is necessary to lay a foundation to establish the admissibility of a claim in the form of a business record. (Bajaj v General Assur., 18 Misc 3d 25 [App Term, 2d Dept, 2d, 11th & 13th Jud Dists 2007].) In stark contrast several Appellate Term courts in the First Department have determined that judicial admissions constitute evidence sufficient to prove mailing and receipt of no-fault medical provider claims. (See P.L.P. Acupuncture, P.C. v Travelers Indem. Co., 19 Misc 3d 126[A], 2008 NY Slip Op 50484[U] [App Term, 1st Dept 2008], citing Fair Price Med. Supply, Inc. v St. Paul Travelers Ins. Co., 16 Misc 3d 8 [App Term, 1st Dept 2007].) This position is further buttressed by an Appellate Division, First Department, holding that informal judicial admissions established via answers to interrogatories in a personal injury action can establish a prima facie case. (Bigelow v Acands, Inc., 196 AD2d 436 [1st Dept 1993].)
The doctrine of stare decisis binds this court to follow the rulings of its Appellate Term (9th & 10th Jud Dists), the Appellate Division, Second Department, and the New York Court of Appeals. The plaintiff advances the argument that stare decisis requires it to adopt the Appellate Division/Appellate Term, First Department, decisions in the absence of a Second Department or Court of Appeals decision. (See Mountain View Coach Lines v Storms, 102 AD2d 663 [2d Dept 1984].) While generally true, the novel complicating factor in this case is that an Appellate Term court in a different district in this court’s Appellate Division has contemporaneously taken a contrary position. In such a circumstance, when presented with conflicting appellate decisions from outside its jurisdictional chain, this court determines that stare decisis does not bind it and that it is free to make its own decision.
The court notes that a sister Suffolk County District Court has already addressed the issue and rendered a treatise decision citing to a plethora of case law and to Professor David Siegel, New York Practice, Prince, Richardson on Evidence and Wigmore, Evidence, which allowed the use of notices to admit as prima facie evidence. (Seaside Med., P.C. v General Assur. Co., 16 Misc 3d 758 [Suffolk Dist Ct 2007].) This holding appears correct, especially in light of the simplified expedited payment process that the legislature has established for no-fault claims. “Notices to admit” are more than simply a discovery device, such as an interrogatory. The fundamental purpose of a notice to admit is to expedite the trial by eliminating the need to call a witness to prove an undisputed fact; matter which is easily{**27 Misc 3d at 439} provable or the genuineness of a document. (See Brilliant, Outside Counsel, Courts Differ on Notice to Admit Use in No-Fault Insurance Cases, NYLJ, Mar. 26, 2009, at 4, col 3; see generally Taylor v Blair, 116 AD2d 204 [1st Dept 1986].) The distinction between informal judicial [*3]admissions which are adduced in sworn deposition transcripts and interrogatory answers, and those established via formal judicial admissions established in a notice to admit, is that the informal admissions must be proved at trial via witness testimony. The absence of an affirmative denial waives the need to prove the requested admission as effectively as if admitted in the answer.
Accordingly, the court finds that the plaintiff has established an unrebutted prima facie cause of action pursuant to Insurance Law § 5106 (a) and enters judgment for it in the sum of $1,184.66 plus statutory interest from 30 days after its claim date, statutory attorneys fees and costs.
Legal questions
A question of no-fault law this decision rules on, from our Legal Questions pages. Bars count the decisions on the question by year and court, coloured by category; circles are this decision and the decisions on the question it cites or that cite it. Point at a bar or circle for details. The categories and summaries are Beynenson Law’s classification, made by a language model and checked by a second reading.
What must a no-fault claimant prove at trial to make out its prima facie case for overdue benefits?
This decision: Claimant's trial proof held to make out its prima facie case
Held at trial that the insurer's failure to respond to a notice to admit receipt of the claim, its denial and nonpayment established the provider's prima facie case without witness testimony, so judgment was entered for the provider.
Of the 103 decisions on this question in the Second Department courts and the Court of Appeals, 40 (this one included) are in the same category. 2 decisions in other departments that cite or are cited by this one are on the full map.
Cited in this decision
A label shows how this decision treated the case it cites.
- Kipor Medicine P.C. v MVAIC (2009 NY Slip Op 29085)A provider need not prove its assignor's New York residency as part of its prima facie case for no-fault benefits against MVAIC. At trial on stipulated facts, MVAIC conceded receipt of the claim and failure to pay or deny it timely; the provider offered no residency proof.
- Fair Price Med. Supply Corp. v Travelers Indem. Co. (2008 NY Slip Op 04946)An insurer's defense that billed supplies were never delivered is subject to preclusion for an untimely denial.
- Nyack Hosp. v Metropolitan Prop. & Cas. Ins. Co. (2005 NY Slip Op 02235)The insurer failed to prove mailing of its denial, and the denial was incomplete even if timely.
- Mary Immaculate Hosp. v Allstate Ins. Co. (2004 NY Slip Op 02359)The hospitals established entitlement to summary judgment by proving that statutory billing forms were mailed and received and payment was overdue.
- Bajaj v General Assur. (2007 NY Slip Op 27487) Declined to followAn insurer's admission that a denial form is genuine does not establish the provider's claim form as an admissible business record.
- P.L.P. Acupuncture, P.C. v Travelers Indem. Co. (2008 NY Slip Op 50484(U))The insurers' admission of receipt defeated their challenge to the provider's proof that its no-fault claims were mailed and received.
- Fair Price Med. Supply, Inc. v St. Paul Travelers Ins. Co. (2007 NY Slip Op 27173)The insurer's verified interrogatory answers established receipt and partial payment of the claims and defeated its proof-of-billing objection.
- Seaside Med., P.C. v General Assur. Co. (2007 NY Slip Op 27258) FollowedAdmissions under CPLR 3123 may collectively establish a provider's prima facie case when the individual requests are proper.
Cited by
A label shows how the later decision treated this one.
- Meridan Health Acupuncture, P.C. v Auto One Ins. Co. (2010 NY Slip Op 51263(U)) FollowedAn insurer's blanket objections to a notice to admit constituted admissions establishing the provider's prima facie case at trial.
Similar decisions
- RJ Med., P.C. v All-State Ins. Co. (2007 NY Slip Op 51061(U))The provider failed to prove its no-fault claim at trial by relying solely on an unanswered notice to admit addressing material issues.
- Central Nassau Diagnostic Imaging, P.C. v GEICO (2010 NY Slip Op 20244)A provider may establish entitlement to overdue no-fault benefits through an insurer's admissions resulting from an unanswered notice to admit.
- Prime Psychological Servs., P.C. v Auto One Ins. Co. (2008 NY Slip Op 50162(U))The provider failed to establish its trial prima facie case because it omitted the documents identified as attached to its notice to admit.
- Alleviation Med. Servs., PC v Hertz Co. (2015 NY Slip Op 25285)A provider may establish claim submission and receipt through admissions in denials annexed to the defendant's interrogatory response.
- NY First Acupuncture, P.C. v General Assur. Co. (2008 NY Slip Op 50750(U))A notice to admit establishing genuineness does not supply the business-record foundation for a provider's claim forms.