October 8, 2013
American Tr. Ins. Co. v Curry (2013 NY Slip Op 23470)
https://www.beynensonlaw.com/case-law/american-tr-ins-co-v-curry-2013-ny-slip-op-23470/
- Judge
- Billings, J.
- Decided
- October 8, 2013
- Citation
- 2013 NY Slip Op 23470 · 45 Misc 3d 171
- Posture
- Summary judgment
- Outcome
- Provider prevailed
- Later treatment
- Followed in 2 later decisions (see Cited by)
- Issues
- EUO no-show
- Legal questions
- No-show defense: insurer's proof (see the maps)
Posture, outcome, issues and treatment by other decisions are Beynenson Law’s classification. Treatment labels are assigned by a language model reading the citing decision; negative and appeal-history labels are checked by a second reader.
Summary
Editorial summary by Beynenson Law, not part of the court’s decision.
Reported in New York Official Reports at American Tr. Ins. Co. v Curry (2013 NY Slip Op 23470)
| American Tr. Ins. Co. v Curry |
| 2013 NY Slip Op 23470 [45 Misc 3d 171] |
| October 8, 2013 |
| Billings, J. |
| Published by New York State Law Reporting Bureau pursuant to Judiciary Law § 431. |
| As corrected through Wednesday, October 15, 2014 |
[*1]
| American Transit Insurance Company, Plaintiff, v Christina Curry et al., Defendants. |
Supreme Court, New York County, October 8, 2013
APPEARANCES OF COUNSEL
Law Offices of James F. Sullivan, P.C., New York City (Giovanna Tuttolomondo of counsel), for plaintiff.
Law Offices of Robert E. Dash, P.C., Melville (Melissa R. Abraham-Lofurno of counsel), for Stand-Up MRI of the Bronx, P.C., defendant.
{**45 Misc 3d at 172} OPINION OF THE COURT
I. Background
Plaintiff moves for a default judgment against all defendants except Five Boro Psychological and Licensed Master Social Work{**45 Misc 3d at 173} Services, PLLC, Lincoln Medical and Mental Health Center, New York City Health and Hospitals Corporation, Stand-Up MRI of the Bronx, P.C., and Transcare Ambulance Services. (CPLR 3215.) Plaintiff moves for summary judgment against Stand-Up MRI. (CPLR 3212 [b].) On each ground, against both Stand-Up MRI and the remaining nine defendants, plaintiff’s motion seeks a judgment declaring that plaintiff owes no duty to compensate them pursuant to Insurance Law § 5103 for expenses incurred from a collision November 15, 2009, involving defendant Curry and a motor [*2]vehicle for which plaintiff issued an insurance policy. (CPLR 3001, 3212 [b]; 3215 [e].) For the reasons explained below, the court denies all the relief sought by plaintiff’s motion.
Plaintiff bases both prongs of its motion on Curry’s nonappearance for an examination under oath (EUO), to which plaintiff is entitled under the policy. (See 11 NYCRR 65-1.1 [d].) The policy’s mandatory personal injury protection provisions condition the insurer’s payment of a claim on “full compliance with the terms of this coverage.” (Id.) Upon the insurer’s request, “the eligible injured person or that person’s assignee or representative shall . . . as may reasonably be required submit to examinations under oath . . . .” (Id.)
II. Plaintiff Scheduled the EUO at Reasonably Convenient Times
[1] 11 NYCRR 65-3.5 (e) requires that an EUO be “held at a place and time reasonably convenient to the applicant” for insurance coverage. Plaintiff scheduled Curry’s EUO at two different times on different days of the week, both during business hours. Although business hours may be inconvenient for applicants who work during those hours, section 65-3.5 (e) also required plaintiff to notify Curry, as it did, that she would be reimbursed for any earnings lost by complying with the EUO request. Plaintiff notified her further that, if she advised plaintiff that the scheduled time was in fact inconvenient, plaintiff would reschedule the EUO. In light of these available accommodations, and absent any notice from Curry that the scheduled time was inconvenient, the scheduling during business hours was reasonable.
III. The Missing Evidence
[2] Yet 11 NYCRR 65-3.5 (e) requires further that plaintiff’s request for the EUO, to establish Curry’s or her assignee’s{**45 Misc 3d at 174} claim, “must be based upon the application of objective standards so that there is specific objective justification supporting the use of such examination.” Nowhere do plaintiff’s admissible documents or its witnesses, including the claims representative assigned to defendants’ claims for coverage and a supervisor of plaintiff’s legal department, responsible for EUO requests, indicate any justification, need, or explanation for Curry’s EUO. The director of plaintiff’s special investigations unit (SIU) attests simply that it “was requested to conduct an investigation” of the motor vehicle collision in which Curry was involved. (Aff in support of Giovanna Tuttolomondo, exhibit J, ¶ 6.) “As part of SIU’s investigation,” an SIU investigator “attempted to examine the claimant, CHRISTINA CURRY, under oath.” (Id.)
Moreover, even though only four months elapsed between when Curry provided her address on her application for insurance coverage and plaintiff mailed its EUO requests to that address, no witness attests that Curry did not notify plaintiff of an address change in the interim. Nor does plaintiff present any evidence that the applicant was notified of any obligation to inform the insurer of her change in address, particularly when she has assigned her rights to insurance benefits to her medical care providers and retains no more interest in obtaining benefits paid to her. This incomplete record leaves a question whether plaintiff mailed its EUO requests to Curry’s current address and whether she ever received them.
More importantly, no witness attests to Curry’s nonappearance at either of the scheduled EUOs. The director of plaintiff’s SIU just lays the foundation for the admissibility of business records that he claims show her nonappearances. While these records may be admissible, plaintiff does not present them. The SIU director’s recitation of their contents is hearsay. (E.g. People v Joseph, 86 NY2d 565, 570 [1995]; Lapin v Atlantic Realty Apts. Co., LLC, 48 AD3d 337, 338 [1st Dept 2008]; Kane v Triborough Bridge & Tunnel Auth., 8 AD3d 239, 241 [2d Dept 2004]; Wagman v Bradshaw, 292 AD2d 84, 87-88 [2d Dept 2002]; see Giordano v Berisha, 45 AD3d 416, 417 [1st Dept 2007]; Washington v Montefiore Med. Ctr., 9 AD3d 271, 272 [1st Dept 2004]; Marina Towers Assoc. v National States Elec. Corp., 203 AD2d 49, 50 [1st Dept 1994].)
IV. Conclusion
The absence of justification for the EUO as required by 11 NYCRR 65-3.5 (e) and of admissible evidence that the eligible injured person Curry actually failed to appear for the EUOs{**45 Misc 3d at 175} requested by plaintiff (see 11 NYCRR 65-1.1 [d]), precludes a summary declaratory judgment to plaintiff at this stage. (Ahead Realty LLC v India House, Inc., 92 AD3d 424, 425 [1st Dept [*3]2012]; Thome v Alexander & Louisa Calder Found., 70 AD3d 88, 100-101 [1st Dept 2009]; Long Is. Light. Co. v Allianz Underwriters Ins. Co., 35 AD3d 253, 254 [1st Dept 2006]; see United States Fire Ins. Co. v American Home Assur. Co., 19 AD3d 191, 192 [1st Dept 2005]; 319 McKibben St. Corp. v General Star Natl. Ins. Co., 245 AD2d 26, 29-30 [1st Dept 1997].) Absent a showing of plaintiff’s compliance with the governing regulation (11 NYCRR 65-3.5 [e]), and Curry’s noncompliance with the regulations and policy (11 NYCRR. 65-1.1 [d]; 65-3.5 [e]), plaintiff has failed to present facts establishing its prima facie claim and thus a basis for summary judgment as sought against Stand-Up MRI (CPLR 3212 [b]; JMD Holding Corp. v Congress Fin. Corp., 4 NY3d 373, 384 [2005]; Chubb Natl. Ins. Co. v Platinum Customcraft Corp., 38 AD3d 244, 245 [1st Dept 2007]; Atlantic Mut. Ins. Co. v Joyce Intl., Inc., 31 AD3d 352 [1st Dept 2006]), or a default judgment as sought against the nine other defendants. (CPLR 3215 [f]; Manhattan Telecom. Corp. v H & A Locksmith, Inc., 21 NY3d 200, 203 [2013]; Martinez v Reiner, 104 AD3d 477, 478 [1st Dept 2013]; Utak v Commerce Bank Inc., 88 AD3d 522, 523 [1st Dept 2011]; Mejia-Ortiz v Inoa, 71 AD3d 517 [1st Dept 2010].)
Consequently, the court denies plaintiff’s motion for a default declaratory judgment and for a summary declaratory judgment. (CPLR 3001, 3212 [b]; 3215 [f].) This decision constitutes the court’s order.
Legal questions
A question of no-fault law this decision rules on, from our Legal Questions pages. Bars count the decisions on the question by year and court, coloured by category; circles are this decision and the decisions on the question it cites or that cite it. Point at a bar or circle for details. The categories and summaries are Beynenson Law’s classification, made by a language model and checked by a second reading.
Did the insurer prove its IME/EUO no-show defense: mailed, compliant scheduling requests and the claimant’s nonappearance?
This decision: Insurer failed to prove the nonappearance by someone with personal knowledge
Denied default and summary declaratory judgment because no witness attested to the claimant's EUO nonappearances, the SIU director's recital of unproduced records being hearsay, and the insurer showed no specific objective justification for the EUO.
Of the 165 decisions on this question in the First Department courts and the Court of Appeals, 14 (this one included) are in the same category. One decision in other departments that cites or is cited by this one is on the full map.
Cited by
A label shows how the later decision treated this one.
- American Tr. Ins. Co. v Jaga Med. Servs., P.C. (2015 NY Slip Op 03925) FollowedThe insurer's summary judgment motion based on the claimant's EUO nonappearance was denied because essential discovery remained outstanding.
- Avalon Radiology, P.C. v Ameriprise Ins. Co. (2016 NY Slip Op 26182) FollowedAn insurer must supply specific objective justification for a provider's EUO when the provider timely requests that justification.
- Country-Wide Ins. Co. v Delacruz (2022 NY Slip Op 03068)The insurer's EUO nonappearance motion was premature because it withheld the specific objective justification for requesting the EUO. The Appellate Division, First Department, affirmed denial of summary judgment against the providers under CPLR 3212 (f).
Similar decisions
- Natural Therapy Acupuncture, P.C. v State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co. (2013 NYSlip Op 51935(U))The provider's EUO objections were unpreserved, and the insurer established timely notices and denials and the provider's nonappearance.
- Neuro Rehab Med. Servs. of S.I., P.C. v State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co. (2018 NY Slip Op 50671(U))The insurer established proper EUO notices, two unexcused nonappearances, and timely denials of the provider's claims.
- Fyzio PT, PLLC v Ocean Harbor Cas. Ins. Co. (2025 NY Slip Op 50103(U))The insurer failed to prove the assignor's EUO and IME nonappearances through admissible evidence based on personal knowledge.
- Pavlova v Allstate Ins. Co. (2019 NY Slip Op 50016(U))The insurer's EUO nonappearance defense was precluded by a denial issued more than 30 days after the last scheduled EUO. The Civil Court, Kings County, denied summary judgment to the insurer and granted summary judgment to the provider.
- Country-Wide Ins. Co. v Gotham Med., P.C. (2015 NY Slip Op25387)A provider's refusal to answer relevant EUO questions is a material breach of the policy's cooperation condition and precludes recovery.