• 347-746-6001
  • contact@beynensonlaw.com
Beynenson Law
Beynenson Law
  • Services
    • Search Case Law & Regulations
    • New Decisions
    • Decisions by Court
    • Legal Questions
    • No-Fault Regulations
    • Claim Process & Deadlines
    • Ask No-Fault AI
    • Arbitrator Scorecard
    • Award Volume
    • Arbitrator / Carrier Data
    • Provider / Carrier Data
    • Provider / Attorney Data
    • Arbitration Pro Extension
  • About Us
  • Contact
  • East Hampton, New York

  • 347-746-6001
  • contact@beynensonlaw.com
  • Services
    • Search Case Law & Regulations
    • New Decisions
    • Decisions by Court
    • Legal Questions
    • No-Fault Regulations
    • Claim Process & Deadlines
    • Ask No-Fault AI
    • Arbitrator Scorecard
    • Award Volume
    • Arbitrator / Carrier Data
    • Provider / Carrier Data
    • Provider / Attorney Data
    • Arbitration Pro Extension
  • About Us
  • Contact
October 25, 2006

Devonshire Surgical Facility v Prudential Prop. & Cas. Co. (2006 NY Slip Op 52057(U))

https://www.beynensonlaw.com/case-law/devonshire-surgical-facility-v-prudential-prop-cas-co-2006-ny-slip-op-52057u/

Court
Civil Court of the City of New York, New York County
Judge
Mendez, J.
Decided
October 25, 2006
Citation
2006 NY Slip Op 52057(U) · 13 Misc 3d 1229(A)
Posture
Summary judgment
Outcome
Insurer prevailed
Issues
Fraudulent incorporation (Mallela) Discovery and procedure
Legal questions
Fraudulent incorporation (Mallela) · Mallela defense: preclusion and discovery (see the maps)
Cite as
Devonshire Surgical Facility v Prudential Prop. & Cas. Co., 13 Misc 3d 1229(A), 2006 NY Slip Op 52057(U) (Civ Ct, New York County 2006)

Posture, outcome, issues and treatment by other decisions are Beynenson Law’s classification. Treatment labels are assigned by a language model reading the citing decision; negative and appeal-history labels are checked by a second reader.

Summary

Editorial summary by Beynenson Law, not part of the court’s decision.

The surgical facility failed to rebut certified evidence that it was not properly licensed or incorporated to receive no-fault reimbursement. The Civil Court, New York County, granted the insurer leave under CPLR 3025 (b) to add a fraud defense and partial summary judgment dismissing the surgical facility's claims. State agency certifications established noncompliance with Business Corporation Law §§ 1507 and 1508 and Education Law § 6507 (4) (c), as required by 11 NYCRR 65-3.16 (a) (12) and Insurance Law § 5102. An unsupported assertion of general-partnership status and a later conversion certificate did not rebut that showing. Under Mallela, the eligibility defense also applied to claims predating the regulation. The orthopedic provider's claims remained because the insurer supplied no basis to deny them.

Reported in New York Official Reports at Devonshire Surgical Facility v Prudential Prop. & Cas. Co. (2006 NY Slip Op 52057(U))

[*1]
Devonshire Surgical Facility v Prudential Prop. & Cas. Co.
2006 NY Slip Op 52057(U) [13 Misc 3d 1229(A)]
Decided on October 25, 2006
Civil Court Of The City Of New York, New York County
Mendez, J.
Published by New York State Law Reporting Bureau pursuant to Judiciary Law § 431.
This opinion is uncorrected and will not be published in the printed Official Reports.


Decided on October 25, 2006
Civil Court of the City of New York, New York County


Devonshire Surgical Facility and Carnegie Hill Orthopedic Services, P.C., a/a/o Irma Evangelista, Plaintiff(s)/, Petitioner(s),

against

Prudential Property & Casualty Company, Defendant(s)/, Respondent(s).




24429 CVN 2005



Attorneys for plaintiffs:

Law Offices of Christopher McCollum

Attorneys for defendant:

Robin, Harris, King, Yuhas, Fodera & Richman

Manuel J. Mendez, J.

The defendant moves to serve an amended answer pursuant to CPLR §3025 to assert a claim alleging that Devonshire Surgical Facility is not a legally authorized provider entitled to reimbursement under the no-fault regulations and for summary judgment pursuant to CPLR §3212.Plaintiff opposes said motion and argues there is no need for a license or permit for an office based facility, the provider has been a general partnership since 1999 and as of July 13, 2006 has been converted into a Limited Liability Corporation.

BACKGROUND

This is an action to recover first party no-fault benefits for medical services rendered to the assignor, Irma Evangelista, by plaintiff, Devon Surgical Facility and Carnegie Hill Orthopedic Services. The defendant has denied claims for services rendered by Devon Surgical Facility, and now seeks to amend it’s Answer to add as a fourteenth affirmative defense a claim that plaintiff Devon Surgical Facility is not a, ” licensed, incorporated, or otherwise legally authorized as a provider entitled to reimbursement under the no-fault regulations.” The defendant is also seeking summary judgment on the grounds that a medical provider requires [*2]proper licensing as a condition precedent to payment and that plaintiff is not such an entity. In support of this motion the defendant annexes as “Exhibits C and F,” certifications from the New York Department of State, dated March 16, 2006 that neither Devonshire Surgical Facility or Devonshire Surgical Facility, L.L.P. existed as of that date as either and Incorporated

entity or a Limited Partnership. Defendant annexed to the motion papers as “Exhibit G”

certification from the New York State Education Department, that as of April 10, 2006 neither Devonshire Surgical Facility or Devonshire Surgical Facility, L.L.P. were registered professional agencies. Plaintiff in opposition alleges the provider has been a general partnership since 1999, but only annexes as “Exhibit B” to it’s opposition papers, a certified copy, dated July 14, 2006, of the certificate of conversion indicating the date of the filing of the articles of organization is May 4, 2006. No other records or copies of records or affidavits by any of the partners or Allen Chamberlin, M.D., were provided in support of plaintiff’s position that Devonshire Surgical Facility was organized as a general partnership in 1999.



LEGAL ANALYSIS

Upon a review of all the papers on this motion, the Court finds that defendant has provided a sufficient basis to amend the answer to include a fourteenth affirmative defense. CPLR§3025(b) states that leave to amend pleadings “shall be freely given upon such terms as may be just…”(See CPLR§3025(b) ). ” In the absence of undue prejudice and unfair advantage,” the Court will be permit pleadings to be amended (See Leutloff vs. Leutloff, 47 Misc 2d 458, 262 NYS2d 736 [1965]). A defense of the nature requested herein is effective if the party can demonstrate a well founded belief that there was fraud involved in the corporation and therefore, no reimbursement is mandated See State Farm Mutual Auto. Ins. Co. v. Mallela, 4 NY3d 313, 827 NE2d 758, 794 NYS2d 700 [2005] and Metroscan Imaging P.C. v. GEICO Ins. Co., 8 Misc 3d 829, 797 NYS2d 737 [2005]. In this instance, the defendant has provided proof in the form of certifications from both the Department of State and the New York State Department of Education that Devonshire Surgical Facility was not registered prior to March 16 2006 and April 10, 2006, as proof of it’s belief that Allen Chamberlin, M.D. had a management agreement with non-licensed professionals and has violated the business corporation law and the education law, the Court finds that is a basis to allow the answer to be amended for purposes of asserting a claim of fraud.

In order to prevail on a motion for summary judgment, the proponent must make a prima facie showing of entitlement to judgment as a matter of law, through admissible evidence, eliminating all material issues of fact. Id.; Klein v. City of New York, 89 NY2d 833, 834-35 [1996]; Ayotte v. Gervasio, 81 NY2d 1062, 1062 (1993), Alvarez v. Prospect Hospital, 68 NY2d 320, 324 [1986]. Once the moving party has satisfied these standards, the burden shifts to the opponent to rebut that prima facie showing, by producing contrary evidence, in admissible form, sufficient to require a trial of material factual issues. Kaufman v Silver, 90 NY2d 204, 208 [*1997]; Amatulli v Delhi Constr. Corp., 77 NY2d 525, 533-34 [1999]; Iselin & Co. v Mann Judd Landau, 71 NY2d 420, 427 [1988]. In determining the motion, the court must construe the evidence in the light most favorable to the non-moving party. (SSBS Realty Corp. v. Public [*3]Service Mut. Ins. Co., 253 AD2d 583, 584-85 [1st Dept. 1998]; Martin v. Briggs, 235 AD2d 192, 196 [1st Dept. 1997]).

In this instance the defendant has provided proof in the form of certifications that

the plaintiff provider Devonshire Surgical Facility was not properly licensed or

incorporated pursuant to Business Corporation Law §1507 and 1508, and Education Law §6507(4) (c) as required by 11NYCRR 65-3.16(a)(12) and Insurance Law § 5102, by providing certifications from both the New York State Education Department, as of April 10, 2006 and from the New York Department of State, dated March 16, 2006, that indicated as of those date, neither Devonshire Surgical Facility or Devonshire Surgical Facility, L.L.P. existed as either an Incorporated entity or a Limited Partnership. Although plaintiff has asserted in it’s opposition papers that Devonshire Surgical Facility was organized as a general partnership in 1999 and bore Tax ID number 13-4016045, no proof was provided of this assertion, and there was no affidavit provided in support of the opposition papers by either Dr. Allen Chamberlin or any of the other alleged general partners. The provision of certified documents and not just computer printouts by the defendant, distinguishes this application from that previously before Hon. Barbara Jaffe in Devonshire Surgical Facility a/a/o Ivory West v. NYCTA, Index No. 22728/05. In addition, an otherwise valid cause of action should not be defeated where it may be impossible to provide a detailed statement of the circumstances surrounding the fraud because that information may be within the possession of or peculiarly the knowledge of the plaintiff provider, in this instance, Devonshire Surgical Facility. See, Oxford Health Plans, Inc. v. BetterCare Health Care Pain Mgt. & Rehab, P.C., 305 AD2d 223, 762 NYS2d 344 [2003], citing to Houbigant, Inc. v. Deloitte & Touche, 303 AD2d 92, 98 [2003] . Finally, as for plaintiff’s contention that the date of the regulation postdates the instant claims, the Court of Appeals in, State Farm Mutual Auto. Ins. Co. v. Mallela, 4 NY3d 313, supra , issued a ruling that involved pre-April 4 , 2002 claims, therefore, it would not be logical to read that case as applying only to claims submitted on or after that date. See Allstate Ins. Co. v. Belt Parkway Imaging, P.C., 2006 NY Slip Op. 07279, [App. Div., 1st Dept., 10/12/06] , citing to Metroscan Imaging, P.C. v. GEICO Ins. Co., 8 Misc 3d 829, supra aff’d 2006 WL 2333130 [App Term]. In this instance absent a more sufficient showing by plaintiff, that the provider was properly licensed pursuant to the regulations, the defendants have met their burden.

Accordingly the defendant’s motion to amend it’s answer to include a fourteenth affirmative defense of fraud and for partial summary judgment as to Devonshire Surgical Facility is granted, those causes of actions pertaining to Carnegie Hill Orthopedic Services a/a/o Irma Evangelista will remain as the defendant has provided no basis to deny those claims.

Movant shall serve a copy of this Order with Notice of Entry upon all sides and the appropriate court clerk within twenty (20) days of entry of this Order.

The foregoing shall constitute the Decision and Order of the Court.

Dated:October 25, 2006 [*4]

Legal questions (2)

Questions of no-fault law this decision rules on, from our Legal Questions pages. Bars count the decisions on the question by year and court, coloured by category; circles are this decision and the decisions on the question it cites or that cite it. Point at a bar or circle for details. The categories and summaries are Beynenson Law’s classification, made by a language model and checked by a second reading.

Fraudulent incorporation (Mallela)

Open the full map

On the merits, when may a no-fault insurer withhold payment because unlicensed persons own or control the provider (Mallela)?

This decision: Provider held ineligible: unlicensed ownership/control or improper formation proved

Granted the insurer leave to amend and partial summary judgment as to the surgical facility, because certified state records showed it was not incorporated or registered as required and it offered no proof of lawful formation; the regulation's 2002 effective date did not bar the defense.

  • Court of AppealsCt App 3
  • Appellate DivisionApp Div 5
  • Appellate TermApp Term 5
  • Trial courtsTrial 4
2019, Court of Appeals: 1 decision (1 Defense established)2005, Court of Appeals: 1 decision (1 Defense established)2025, Court of Appeals: 1 decision (1 Not a Mallela ground)2021, Appellate Division: 1 decision (1 Defense not established)2018, Appellate Division: 2 decisions (1 Defense not established, 1 Not a Mallela ground)2017, Appellate Division: 1 decision (1 Defense not established)2015, Appellate Division: 1 decision (1 Not a Mallela ground)2013, Appellate Term: 1 decision (1 Defense established)2008, Appellate Term: 1 decision (1 Defense not established)2006, Appellate Term: 2 decisions (1 Triable issue, 1 Not a Mallela ground)2007, Appellate Term: 1 decision (1 Triable issue)2020, Trial courts: 1 decision (1 Triable issue)2007, Trial courts: 1 decision (1 Not a Mallela ground)2006, Trial courts: 2 decisions (2 Defense established)This decision
20052010201520202025
Defense establishedTriable issueDefense not establishedNot a Mallela groundThis decisionCites it or cited by itCited or followed

Of the 17 decisions on this question in the First Department courts and the Court of Appeals, 5 (this one included) are in the same category.

Mallela defense: preclusion and discovery

Open the full map

May the insurer raise and investigate a Mallela (fraudulent incorporation) defense, or is it precluded, waived or denied discovery?

This decision: Insurer may raise or investigate the Mallela defense here (rules on the question, but another ground decided the case)

Granted the insurer leave to amend its answer to add the unlicensed-provider defense, finding state certifications supported a well-founded belief of a management arrangement with nonlicensed persons, and rejected the argument that the regulation postdated the claims.

  • Court of AppealsCt App 1
  • Appellate DivisionApp Div 6
  • Appellate TermApp Term 3
  • Trial courtsTrial 14
2005, Court of Appeals: 1 decision (1 Defense may be pursued)2018, Appellate Division: 1 decision (1 Defense barred)2017, Appellate Division: 1 decision (1 Defense may be pursued)2014, Appellate Division: 1 decision (1 Defense may be pursued)2011, Appellate Division: 1 decision (1 Defense may be pursued)2010, Appellate Division: 1 decision (1 Defense may be pursued)2006, Appellate Division: 1 decision (1 Defense may be pursued)2012, Appellate Term: 1 decision (1 Defense barred)2006, Appellate Term: 2 decisions (1 Defense may be pursued, 1 Defense barred)2021, Trial courts: 2 decisions (2 Defense may be pursued)2020, Trial courts: 1 decision (1 Defense may be pursued)2019, Trial courts: 1 decision (1 Defense may be pursued)2015, Trial courts: 1 decision (1 Defense may be pursued)2009, Trial courts: 1 decision (1 Defense may be pursued)2008, Trial courts: 1 decision (1 Defense may be pursued)2007, Trial courts: 1 decision (1 Defense barred)2006, Trial courts: 4 decisions (3 Defense may be pursued, 1 Defense barred)2005, Trial courts: 1 decision (1 Defense barred)2024, Trial courts: 1 decision (1 Defense barred)This decision
2005201020152020
Defense may be pursuedDefense barredThis decisionCites it or cited by itCited or followed

Of the 24 decisions on this question in the First Department courts and the Court of Appeals, 17 (this one included) are in the same category. One decision in other departments that cites or is cited by this one is on the full map.

Cited in this decision

A label shows how this decision treated the case it cites.

  • State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co. v Mallela (2005 NY Slip Op 02416) FollowedFraudulently incorporated medical providers are ineligible for no-fault reimbursement under 11 NYCRR 65-3.16 (a) (12).
  • Metroscan Imaging P.C. v GEICO Ins. Co. (2005 NY Slip Op 25228)A fraudulent-incorporation defense survives untimely denial and applies to unpaid claims predating 11 NYCRR 65-3.16 (a) (12).

Similar decisions

  • Montgomery Med., P.C. v State Farm Ins. Co. (2006 NY Slip Op 51116(U))The insurer's evidence raised a factual issue of fraudulent incorporation despite denials issued 53 days after the provider's EUO. Under 11 NYCRR 65-3.8 (a) (1), verification was received when the EUO occurred; the late denials precluded medical necessity and concurrent-care defenses.
  • Citywide Social Work & Psychological Servs., P.L.L.C. v State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co. (2006 NY Slip Op 51831(U))An untimely denial does not preclude a defense that a provider is fraudulently licensed and ineligible for no-fault reimbursement.
  • Multiquest PLLC v Allstate Ins. Co. (2005 NY Slip Op 52209(U))A billing provider cannot recover assigned no-fault benefits for services rendered by an independent contractor rather than the provider or its employees.
  • Devonshire Surgical Facility v GEICO (2006 NY Slip Op 52450(U))The insurer's untimely denial precluded its fee-schedule, unbundling and provider-fraud defenses.
  • Devonshire Surgical Facility v AIU Ins. Co. (2007 NY Slip Op 51034(U))The insurer failed to establish grounds to disturb summary judgment or obtain discovery concerning alleged fraudulent incorporation.
Beynenson Law

Tech-driven New York no-fault collections for healthcare providers.

About the firm

Contact

  • East Hampton, New York

  • 347-746-6001
  • contact@beynensonlaw.com
  • Contact form

Research

  • Search Case Law & Regulations
  • New Decisions
  • Decisions by Court
  • Legal Questions
  • No-Fault Regulations
  • Claim Process & Deadlines
  • Ask No-Fault AI

Arbitration Data

  • Arbitrator Scorecard
  • Award Volume
  • Arbitrator / Carrier Data
  • Provider / Carrier Data
  • Provider / Attorney Data
  • Arbitration Pro Extension

©2026 The Beynenson Law Group, PC. Terms of Use Privacy Policy

Site by khrystev.dev

Attorney Advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. This website provides general information, not legal advice, and using it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Do not send confidential information through this site.