November 8, 2024
AVK RX Inc v Progressive Advanced Ins. Co. (2024 NY Slip Op 51521(U))
https://www.beynensonlaw.com/case-law/avk-rx-inc-v-progressive-advanced-ins-co-2024-ny-slip-op-51521u/
- Decided
- November 8, 2024
- Citation
- 2024 NY Slip Op 51521(U)
- Posture
- Summary judgment
- Outcome
- Provider prevailed
- Legal questions
- Proof of mailing · No-show defense: insurer's proof (see the maps)
Posture, outcome, issues and treatment by other decisions are Beynenson Law’s classification. Treatment labels are assigned by a language model reading the citing decision; negative and appeal-history labels are checked by a second reader.
Summary
Editorial summary by Beynenson Law, not part of the court’s decision.
Reported in New York Official Reports at AVK RX Inc v Progressive Advanced Ins. Co. (2024 NY Slip Op 51521(U))
AVK RX Inc As Assignee of Hassan Shuaib, Plaintiff,
against Progressive Advanced Insurance Co., Defendant. |
Index No. CV-750150-23/RI
Robert J. Helbock, Jr., J.
Recitation, as required by CPLR 2219 (a), of the papers considered in the review of this application:
Papers Numbered
Notice of Motion and Affirmation/Affidavit NYSCEF Doc#: 4-12
Affirmation in Opposition NYSCEF Doc#: 14
Affirmation in Reply NYSCEF Doc#: 15-16
Upon the foregoing cited papers, the decision on Defendant’s Motion for Summary Judgment is as follows:
Plaintiff, AVK RX Inc. (hereinafter “Plaintiff”) as assignee of Hassan Shauib (hereinafter “Assignor”) commenced this action against the defendant, Progressive Advanced Insurance Co. (hereinafter “Defendant”), to recover assigned first-party No-Fault insurance benefits for medical treatment provided to the Assignor pursuant to an automobile insurance policy issued by the Defendant.
Currently before the Court is Defendant’s motion seeking an order pursuant to CPLR §3212 granting summary judgment on the grounds that the Assignor violated a condition precedent to coverage upon the failure to attend scheduled medical examinations. The Plaintiff filed timely opposition to the motion and the matter was argued before the Court.
In this instance, the summons and complaint allege the Defendant breached the automobile insurance contract by failing to pay for medical treatment rendered to the Assignor arising from injuries that occurred due to a motor vehicle accident. The defense to the claim is the Assignor allegedly did not attend two duly scheduled independent medical exams (hereafter referred to as IME), which is a condition precedent to paying the claims. For the Defendant to [*2]prevail with the defense, it must demonstrate the policyholder/assignor was properly notified of the examinations and failed to attend.
The Plaintiff opposes the Defendant’s summary judgment motion alleging, inter alia, the Defendant has failed to meet its burden of proof to receive summary judgment by failing to demonstrate the IME notices were properly and timely mailed. In particular, the Plaintiff contends the affidavit of Ms. Tracy Simpson is not sufficient to meet the Defendant’s burden of proof of mailing.
The issue of what constitutes a party’s burden of proof of mailing for a summary judgment motion has been addressed by the Court in numerous cases. The Supreme Court, Appellate Division ruled in the matter of Progressive Cas. Ins. Co. v. Metro Psychological Services, P.C.:
“Generally, ‘Proof that an item was properly mailed gives rise to a rebuttable presumption that the item was received by the addressee’ (Viviane Etienne Med. Care, P.C. v. Country-Wide Ins. Co., 114 AD3d 33, at P. 46, 977 N.Y.S.2d 292, affd. 25 NY3d 498). ‘The presumption may be created by either proof of actual mailing or proof of a standard office practice or procedure designed to ensure that items are properly addressed and mailed.’ (Citing New York & Presbyt. Hosp. v. Allstate Inc. Co., 29 AD3d 547, quoting Residential Holding Corp. v. Scottsdale Ins. Co., 286 AD2d 679, 680.) ‘However, for the presumption to arise the office practice must be geared so as to ensure the likelihood that the item is always properly addressed and mailed. See Nassau Ins. Co. v. Murray, 46 N.Y.S.2d 828 (Court of Appeals, 1978).’ Progressive Cas. Ins. Co. v. Metro Psychological Services, P.C., 139 AD3d 693 (Sup. Ct, App. Div., 2nd Dept., May 4, 2016).
In this matter, the Defendant offers the affidavit of Ms. Tracy Simpson, a Manager at ExamWorks, Inc., as evidence that the notice of the IME was properly addressed and mailed to the assignor/examinee. ExamWorks Inc. is a third-party vendor that schedules the IME’s, notifies the examinee, and provides the resulting doctor’s report on behalf of the Defendant. In her affidavit, Ms. Simpson does describe actual knowledge of the mailing of the notices for the IME to the Assignor. The Defendant offers Ms. Simpson’s affidavit to show the standard office practice or procedure to address and mail the vendor’s notices. The affidavit states that in the vendor’s regular course of business the Defendant requests a medical examination (although she does not state who receives the request), the vendor’s set up department enters the information provided by the Defendant, the scheduling department schedules the IME appointment, the data entry department enters the assignor/examinee’s address and prints the letter notifying the examinee of the appointment information, then transmits the document to the mailing department, which puts postage on the envelope and delivers the envelope to the U.S. Postal Service daily. Ms. Simpson also acknowledges it is her duty to ensure compliance with that process.
The Defendant alleges that this affidavit sufficiently proves the process or procedure used to properly address and mail the notice of the IME.
However, Ms. Simpson’s affidavit does not make any statement that she satisfied her duty to ensure compliance with the process, nor does she describe any steps taken to ensure the notice was addressed and mailed properly. For example, Ms. Simpson does not describe any audit, inventory, supervision, or investigation of the mail for that day to determine the process and [*3]procedures were compliant. Without any actual notice of the addressing and mailing of the notice of IME, this affidavit falls short of the “ensuring the likelihood that the item is always properly addressed and mailed.” (Nassau Ins. Co. v. Murray, 46 N.Y.S.2d 828 [Court of Appeals, 1978]).
If the affidavit of Ms. Simpson does not prove the procedure or process is designed to ensure the items are properly addressed or mailed, then the Defendant can still prove the mailing of the IME notice by providing a business record to meet its burden of proof.
Attached to Ms. Simpson’s affidavit as exhibits, the Defendant offers the copies of the letters addressed to the Assignor evidencing the notice of the IME. Since the Plaintiff did not raise any issue of admissibility of the records in their opposition to the motion, the Court will not examine their admissibility. (Rosenblatt v. St. George Health & Racquetball Assoc., LLC, 119 AD3d 45 [2d Dept 2014]).
However, the Defendant did not offer any business record evidencing the mailing of the documents, such as a U.S. Postal Service receipt or an inventory of the outgoing mail. Therefore, Ms. Simpson’s affidavit is unsatisfactory for that purpose. “It is the business record itself, not the foundational affidavit, that serves as proof of the matter asserted.” (Bank of NY Mellon v. Gordon, 171 AD3d 197 [2d Dept 2019]).
Without proving a standard office practice or procedure designed to ensure that items are properly addressed and mailed or providing a business record evidencing the mailing of the document, the Defendant has failed to meet its burden of proof for summary judgment. Therefore, the Court finds there is an issue of fact for trial regarding whether the notices for the IME were properly addressed and mailed by the Defendant.
The Plaintiff also opposed the Defendant’s motion on the grounds that the affidavit of the Defendant’s claims examiner, Cynthia Morges, failed to prove the denial of the claim (NF-10) was timely issued, that the Defendant failed to act diligently, the Defendant failed to attach a copy of the policy at issue, and failed to demonstrate the IME was necessary. Given the Defendant’s failure to meet its first burden of proof, the Court does not address the Plaintiff’s other opposing arguments and leaves them to the Plaintiff to raise at trial if it shall so choose.
Accordingly, the Defendant’s summary judgment motion is DENIED.
Furthermore, the Plaintiff did not oppose the Defendant’s summary judgment motion on the grounds there was any outstanding discovery. Therefore, the Plaintiff is ordered to file the Notice of Trial within sixty (60) days of the date of this decision.
This is the decision and order of the Court.
Date: November 8, 2024Staten Island, New York
Hon. Robert J. Helbock, Jr.
Judge, NYC Civil Court
Legal questions (2)
Questions of no-fault law this decision rules on, from our Legal Questions pages. Bars count the decisions on the question by year and court, coloured by category; circles are this decision and the decisions on the question it cites or that cite it. Point at a bar or circle for details. The categories and summaries are Beynenson Law’s classification, made by a language model and checked by a second reading.
Did a party’s evidence establish that it mailed a no-fault claim, denial, verification request or examination notice?
This decision: The insurer's proof did not establish mailing of its denial, verification request or IME/EUO notice
Held the IME vendor manager's affidavit insufficient because it did not show compliance with or steps ensuring proper addressing and mailing, and no business record such as a postal receipt evidenced the mailing.
Of the 1,400 decisions on this question in the Second Department courts and the Court of Appeals, 260 (this one included) are in the same category.
Did the insurer prove its IME/EUO no-show defense: mailed, compliant scheduling requests and the claimant’s nonappearance?
This decision: Insurer failed to prove the scheduling letters were mailed or properly addressed
Denied the insurer summary judgment on the IME no-show defense because it failed to prove a standard office practice ensuring proper addressing and mailing of the IME notices or any business record of mailing.
Of the 858 decisions on this question in the Second Department courts and the Court of Appeals, 118 (this one included) are in the same category.
Cited in this decision
A label shows how this decision treated the case it cites.
- Viviane Etienne Med. Care, P.C. v Country-Wide Ins. Co. (2013 NY Slip Op 08430)A provider need not prove a claim's merits for summary judgment where the insurer failed to timely and properly deny the claim.
- Viviane Etienne Med. Care, P.C. v Country-Wide Ins. Co. (2015 NY Slip Op 04787)A provider establishes entitlement to summary judgment on overdue no-fault claims with admissible proof of mailing and receipt of statutory claim forms.
- New York & Presbyt. Hosp. v Allstate Ins. Co. (2006 NY Slip Op 03558)The providers failed to establish mailing and receipt of the hospital bill asserted in their second cause of action.
- Progressive Cas. Ins. Co. v Metro Psychological Servs., P.C. (2016 NY Slip Op 03485) FollowedThe insurers failed to establish timely and proper mailing of the EUO letters through a conclusory description of office procedures.
Similar decisions
- SCOB, LLC v Liberty Mut. Ins. Co. (2026 NY Slip Op 51484(U))The insurer failed to prove proper mailing of IME notices or nonappearance, given an address discrepancy and a defective affirmation.
- Dowd v Allstate Ins. Co. (2019 NY Slip Op 50648(U))The insurer failed to establish proper mailing of IME notices because its proof did not explain how addresses were checked.
- Avamed Supply Inc v GEICO (2024 NY Slip Op 50688(U))The insurer's EUO defense failed because its second scheduling letter was mailed 15 days after the provider's first nonappearance.
- Fyzio PT, PLLC v Ocean Harbor Cas. Ins. Co. (2025 NY Slip Op 50103(U))The insurer failed to prove the assignor's EUO and IME nonappearances through admissible evidence based on personal knowledge.
- Perfect Point Acupuncture, P.C. v Auto One Ins. Co. (2010 NY Slip Op 50010(U))The insurer retained its verification toll despite sending an IME follow-up request 17 days after the first request.