July 3, 2006
Marigliano v State Farm Mut. Auto Ins. Co. (2006 NY Slip Op 51349(U))
https://www.beynensonlaw.com/case-law/marigliano-v-state-farm-mut-auto-ins-co-2006-ny-slip-op-51349u/
- Judge
- Sweeney, J.
- Decided
- July 3, 2006
- Citation
- 2006 NY Slip Op 51349(U) · 12 Misc 3d 1180(A)
- Posture
- Trial
- Outcome
- Insurer prevailed
- Later treatment
- Contrasted (cf., but see) in 1 later decision (see Cited by)
- Legal questions
- Claimant's prima facie case at trial (see the maps)
Posture, outcome, issues and treatment by other decisions are Beynenson Law’s classification. Treatment labels are assigned by a language model reading the citing decision; negative and appeal-history labels are checked by a second reader.
Summary
Editorial summary by Beynenson Law, not part of the court’s decision.
Reported in New York Official Reports at Marigliano v State Farm Mut. Auto Ins. Co. (2006 NY Slip Op 51349(U))
| Marigliano v State Farm Mut. Auto Ins. Co. |
| 2006 NY Slip Op 51349(U) [12 Misc 3d 1180(A)] |
| Decided on July 3, 2006 |
| Civil Court, Richmond County |
| Sweeney, J. |
| Published by New York State Law Reporting Bureau pursuant to Judiciary Law § 431. |
| This opinion is uncorrected and will not be published in the printed Official Reports. |
Civil Court, Richmond County
Adam Marigliano, LMT, as Assignee of Guillermo Rios and Criselda Rodriquez, Plaintiff,
against State Farm Mut. Auto Ins. Co., Defendant. |
005741/05
Peter P. Sweeney, J.
The plaintiff commenced this action pursuant to Insurance Law § 5101 et seq to recover assigned first-party no-fault benefits for medical service provided to its Assignors, Guillermo Rios and Criselda Rodriquez.
The trial of the action took place on April 12, 2006. Neither party called a witness. To establish a prima facie case, plaintiff relied solely upon defendant’s failure to respond to a notice to admit it was served on November 30, 2005 pursuant to CPLR 3123(a).
The notice to admit requested admissions of the following facts:
1.The defendant received the claim(s) for No-Fault benefits that are the subject of this action.
2.The defendant received the N-F-3 Verification of Treatment Form(s) that are the subject of this action.
3.The defendant received the bill(s) that are the subject of this action.
4. The defendant has not paid the bill(s), claim(s), and/or N-F-3 referenced in 1 through 3 above.
5.The defendant received an Assignment of Benefits Forms(s) for the claims that are the subject of this action.
7.The defendant did not mail requests for verification to the plaintiff for the claims that are the subject of this action.
8.The defendant issued a policy of insurance covering the vehicle plaintiff’s assignor was in at the time of the motor vehicle accident.
Plaintiff did not annex to the notice to admit copies of the bills, claims, and/or N-F-3s and requested and admissions as to their genuineness as CPLR 3123(a) permits. Further, the bills, [*2]claims, and/or N-F-3s were not received in evidence during the trial.
Plaintiff maintained that by failing to respond to the notice to admit, defendant admitted to the truth of all the facts alleged therein and that these facts were sufficient to make out a prima facie case.
Defendant maintained that it was not obligated to respond to the notice to admit since it was vague and ambiguous and sought admissions of ultimate issues of fact. Defendant further maintained that plaintiff was required to introduce the bills, claims, and/or N-F-3s into evidence to make out a prima facie case.
Discussion:
Defendant’s contention that it did not have to respond to the notice to admit is without merit. Plaintiff properly used the notice to admit to dispose of what it believed to be uncontroverted questions of facts which would have been easily provable at trial (The Hawthorne Group, LLC v. RRE Ventures, 7 AD3d 320, 324 [1st Dep’t 2004]; see also Meadowbrook-Richman, Inc. v. Cicchiello, 273 AD2d 6 [1st Dep’t 2000]; Samsung America, Inc. v. Yugoslav Korean Consulting & Trading Co.,199 AD2d 48 [1st Dep’t 1993] ). The notice to admit removed “from the case those uncontested matters which would [have] merely present[ed] a time-consuming burden at trial” (Villa v. New York City Housing Authority, 107 AD2d 619-620 [1st Dep’t 1985] ).
While a party is not obligated to furnish admissions in response to a notice to admit that improperly demands admissions of ultimate and fundamental issues that can only be resolved after a full trial or matters that are in actual dispute (see, Meadowbrook-Richman, Inc. v. Cicchiello 273 AD2d 6, 6; [1st Dep’t 2000]; Orellana v. City of New York, 203 AD2d 542, 543 [2nd Dep’t 1994]; Miller v. Hilman Kelly Co.,177 AD2d 1036, 1037 [4th Dep’t 1991] ), “[a]ll of the items in the notice to admit involve[d] clear-cut factual matters about which one would reasonably anticipate no dispute, and the immediate disposition of which would not unfairly prejudice the defendant and would help to expedite the trial” (Risucci v. Homayoon, 122 AD2d 260, 261 [2nd Dep’t 1986], citing , CPLR 3123[a]; Villa v. New York City Housing Auth., 107 AD2d 619, 620 [1st Dep’t 1985] ). That fact that a notice to admit will establish plaintiff’s prima facie case on paper does not bar its use (id.).
Simply because defendant denied many of the facts alleged in the notice to admit in its answer to plaintiff’s complaint did not establish that those facts were in actual dispute. To hold otherwise would preclude a plaintiff from requesting admissions of any fact initially denied by a defendant in its answer. If defendant actually disputed any of the facts alleged in the notice to admit, it should have submitted a timely response denying them.
The court rejects defendant’s contention that the notice to admit was vague and/or ambiguous.
Inasmuch as defendant did not respond to the notice to admit within 20 days, defendant is deemed to have admitted all of the facts alleged therein (CPLR 3123[a] ).
Notwithstanding the above, the court agrees with defendant that plaintiff did not make out a prima facie case. In A.B. Med. Servs. PLLC v. State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co., 2005 NY Slip Op 50432[U] [App Term, 2d & 11th Jud Dists], the court held that “[b]y failing to append the necessary claim forms to their motion papers, plaintiffs did not establish their prima facie case” (see, also, Patil v. Countrywide Ins. Co., 2006 NY Slip Op. 50306(U) [App Term, 9th & 10th [*3]Jud Dists]; Maldonado v. Steiner, 2005 NY Slip Op. 51905(U) [App Term, 9th & 10th Jud Dists] ). It necessarily follows that to make out a prima facie case at trial, copies of the NF-3 claim forms or their functional equivalent must be received in evidence for the purpose of demonstrating exactly what was sent to and received by the defendant. In the instant case, neither the N-F-3s nor their functional equivalent were received in evidence nor did plaintiff annex them to the notice to admit and request an admissions as to their genuineness.
Accordingly, it is hereby
ORDERED that judgment be entered in favor of the defendant dismissing the action.
Dated: July 3, 2006_____________________________
PETER P. SWEENEY
Civil Court Judge
Legal questions
A question of no-fault law this decision rules on, from our Legal Questions pages. Bars count the decisions on the question by year and court, coloured by category; circles are this decision and the decisions on the question it cites or that cite it. Point at a bar or circle for details. The categories and summaries are Beynenson Law’s classification, made by a language model and checked by a second reading.
What must a no-fault claimant prove at trial to make out its prima facie case for overdue benefits?
This decision: Insufficient: claimant did not prove at trial that the claim was submitted (mailed to and received by the insurer)
Held the provider failed to make out its case at trial because the claim forms were never received in evidence or annexed to the notice to admit, so what was sent to and received by the insurer was not shown.
Of the 103 decisions on this question in the Second Department courts and the Court of Appeals, 4 (this one included) are in the same category.
Cited in this decision
A label shows how this decision treated the case it cites.
- A.B. Med. Servs. PLLC v State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co. (2005 NYSlipOp 50432(U)) FollowedThe providers failed to establish prima facie entitlement to partial summary judgment because they omitted the necessary claim forms.
Cited by
A label shows how the later decision treated this one.
- Bajaj v General Assur. (2007 NY Slip Op 27487) Contrasted (cf., but see)An insurer's admission that a denial form is genuine does not establish the provider's claim form as an admissible business record.
Similar decisions
- RJ Med., P.C. v All-State Ins. Co. (2007 NY Slip Op 51061(U))The provider failed to prove its no-fault claim at trial by relying solely on an unanswered notice to admit addressing material issues.
- Prime Psychological Servs., P.C. v Auto One Ins. Co. (2008 NY Slip Op 50162(U))The provider failed to establish its trial prima facie case because it omitted the documents identified as attached to its notice to admit.
- Custom Orthotics of NY, Inc. v State Farm Mut. Auto Ins. Co. (2007 NY Slip Op 27549)The provider failed to establish its prima facie case at trial through the insurer's qualified admissions and unauthenticated documents.
- Meridan Health Acupuncture, P.C. v Auto One Ins. Co. (2010 NY Slip Op 51263(U))An insurer's blanket objections to a notice to admit constituted admissions establishing the provider's prima facie case at trial.
- Advanced Tempromandibular Disorder & Dental Surgery v Progressive Northeastern Ins. Co. (2010 NY Slip Op 20047)A provider may establish its prima facie no-fault case at trial through an unanswered notice to admit without witness testimony.