New York No-Fault Regulations 11 NYCRR Subpart 65-4: Arbitration
11 NYCRR 65-4.11: Mandatory
Text of 11 NYCRR 65-4.11 (Insurance Regulation 68-D) as published by the New York State Department of Financial Services, checked against the Department's list of amendments through October 4, 2026.
This is an unofficial copy. The official text is in the New York Codes, Rules and Regulations. Decisions apply the version in force at the time of the claim, which may differ from the current text.
Decisions citing this section · Plain-text version (Markdown)
arbitration for insurers, self-insurers and compensation providers under section 5105 of the Insurance Law.
(a) Applicability.
(1) This section shall apply to mandatory arbitration of controversies between insurers, pursuant to the provisions of sections 5105 and 5106(d) of the Insurance Law, and shall apply to insurers, self-insurers and compensation providers. The term insurer as used in this section (except as specified in paragraphs [c][2] and [f][1] of this section) shall include both insurers and self-insurers as those terms are defined in this Part and article 51 of the Insurance Law; the Motor Vehicle Accident Indemnification Corporation (MVAIC); any company providing insurance pursuant to section 5103(g) of the Insurance Law; and compensation providers as defined in section 5102(l) of the Insurance Law.
(2) Except as provided in section 65-3.12(b)(3) and (4) of this Part, all insurers shall submit controversies arising out of accidents, insured events or occurrences within the jurisdiction of section 5105, 5106(d), or 5221(b) of the Insurance Law to mandatory arbitration, as prescribed in this section. Controversies arising from accidents, insured events or occurrences outside the jurisdiction of section 5105, 5106(d), or 5221(b) of the Insurance Law may be submitted with the consent of the controverting insurers.
(3) Any determination as to whether an insurer is legally entitled to recovery from another insurer shall be made by an arbitration panel (see paragraph [c][2] of this section) appointed pursuant to this section. The decision of a majority of an arbitration panel shall be final and binding upon the insurers to the controversy. There shall be no right of rehearing or appeal. However, this provision does not preclude correction of clerical or typographical errors.
(4) Where arbitrating insurers are signators to any insurer arbitration program under which a claim or companion claims would be otherwise subject to the compulsory jurisdiction of such agreements, the jurisdiction of this section shall be primary. Insurers shall waive their rights to proceed separately under such other arbitration programs and include all claims arising out of the same accident or insured event for disposition by an arbitration panel appointed pursuant to this section.
(5) This section is applicable only to controversies involving insurers.
(6) Other than claims asserted by MVAIC against an insurer, this section shall not apply to any claim for recovery rights to which an insurer in good faith asserts a defense of lack of coverage of an alleged covered person on any grounds, unless specific written consent of mandatory arbitration is obtained from the insurer asserting such defense. Where an insurer asserts a defense of lack of coverage of an alleged covered person on any grounds relating to claims asserted by MVAIC for recovery rights, same shall be subject to mandatory arbitration. However, any controversy between insurers involving the responsibility or the obligation to pay first-party benefits (i.e., priority or payment or sources of payment as provided in section 65-3.12 of this Part) is not considered a coverage question and must be submitted to mandatory arbitration under this section.
(7) This section shall not be construed to create any causes of action or liabilities not existing in law or equity, nor shall this section be construed to abolish any causes of action or liabilities existing in law or equity.
(b) Administration of arbitration.
(1) The arbitration prescribed in this section shall be administered by an inter-company arbitration administrator “administrator” designated by the superintendent. The administrator may:
(i) make appropriate administrative rules for arbitrations;
(ii) select places where arbitration facilities are to be available, and adopt a policy for the selection and appointment of arbitration panels; and
(iii) make appropriate recommendations for equitable apportionment among arbitrating insurers of the operating expenses of this program.
(2) Local arbitration panels.
(i) Members of local arbitration panels shall be appointed by the administrator from full-time salaried representative of insurers, on the basis of their experience and qualifications, and shall serve without compensation.
(ii) The administrator shall be responsible for the selection of arbitration panels to hear the particular cases.
(c) Selection of arbitrators.
(1) Insurers shall furnish the administrator with a list of names, titles and local addresses of all employees who are qualified to act as arbitrators.
(2) The administrator shall designate one disinterested member of such panel to serve as an arbitrator in each case. However, an insurer may request a three-member arbitration panel in a specific case. If one or more of the controverting parties is a self-insurer which has requested a three-member panel, then the self-insurer may also request that at least one member of the panel be a disinterested representative of a self-insurer, where such representative is available to serve on the panel.
(3) No one shall serve as an arbitrator on a panel hearing a case in which the insurer represented by the arbitrator is directly or indirectly interested.
(d) All arbitrations under this Subpart shall be conducted in accordance with procedures established by the administrator and approved by the superintendent.
(e) Filing assessments.
(1) The administrator, by resolution, will recommend the filing assessment for the use of local arbitration facilities. The expenses of the program shall be periodically reviewed by the loss transfer advisory committee (see subdivision [f] of this section), which shall consider the recommendations of the administrator and prescribe from time to time arbitration assessments.
(2) The obligation for the prescribed filing assessment is incurred upon filing by the applicant, by a respondent filing a counterclaim or by a party filing a deferment. There are no exceptions to an insurer’s obligation to pay the filing assessment.
(3) The secretary of the administrator is the custodian of the assessment charges collected and shall make expenditures therefrom to defray such arbitration expenses as may be authorized by the administrator.
(4) The secretary of the administrator will submit reports on assessments collected and disbursed during such period as may be considered desirable by the administrator.
(f) Loss transfer advisory committee.
(1) The superintendent shall select a loss transfer advisory committee composed of 14 members, of which eight shall represent motor vehicle insurers, three shall represent motor vehicle self-insurers, two shall represent compensation providers and one shall represent the Motor Vehicle Accident Indemnification Corporation.
(2) The loss transfer advisory committee shall:
(i) regularly review the operations, procedures, rules, expenditures, assessments and all other relevant matters involving settlements between insurers in accordance with the requirements of section 5105 or 5221(b) of the Insurance Law;
(ii) review the operations of the administrator insofar as they relate to the arbitration prescribed in this section; and
(iii) report its findings, conclusions and recommendations directly to the superintendent annually and at such other intervals as it deems appropriate.
Amendment included
This text includes the amendment effective February 8, 2023 (Fourth Amendment to Regulation 68-A, Tenth Amendment to Regulation 68-C, Eighth Amendment to Regulation 68-D), which the Department’s compiled text does not yet reflect. Paragraph (a)(2) amended.
Historical note
Sec. filed Aug. 2, 2001; amds. filed: June 6, 2017 as emergency measure; Sept. 1, 2017 as emergency measure; Oct. 10, 2017 eff. Oct. 25, 2017. Amended (a).
Decisions citing this section (17)
Every decision in our case-law database that cites 11 NYCRR 65-4.11, grouped by the subdivision cited. Within each group, decisions that turn on the provision come first, then those that rely on it, then passing citations; within each of these the highest court comes first. The lists are compiled automatically, and the one-sentence descriptions were written by a language model from the text of each decision: read the decision before relying on one.
Subdivision (a) (12 decisions)
- Matter of Fiduciary Ins. Co. v American Bankers Ins. Co. of Florida (2015 NY Slip Op 06343) Appellate Division, Second DepartmentApplies (a) (1) and (a) (5) to hold that a commercial liability carrier insuring only the stables where a horse was boarded was not an insurer subject to mandatory loss-transfer arbitration, affirming confirmation of the award denying the no-fault insurer's reimbursement claim.
- M.N. Dental Diagnostics, P.C. v Government Empls. Ins. Co. (2011 NY Slip Op 01333) Appellate Division, First DepartmentApplies (a) (6) to reject the insurer's characterization of a payment-responsibility dispute as a coverage question, requiring interinsurer arbitration while leaving the first insurer notified responsible for paying the provider's claim.
- Matter of Infinity Indem. Ins. Co. v Hereford Ins. Co. (2017 NY Slip Op 03177) Appellate Division, Second DepartmentRejects the insurer's argument under (a) (6) that a good-faith retroactive coverage denial divested the arbitrator of jurisdiction, explaining that arbitration is the exclusive forum for a loss-transfer claim.
- Matter of Country-Wide Ins. Co. v National Indem. Co. (2026 NY Slip Op 02035) Appellate Division, First DepartmentApplies (a) (6) to hold that the insurer's post-decision submission of its coverage disclaimer defeated loss-transfer arbitration jurisdiction, because it asserted a good-faith lack-of-coverage defense and had not specifically consented in writing to mandatory arbitration.
- M.N. Dental Diagnostics, P.C. v Government Empls. Ins. Co. (2009 NY Slip Op 29266) Appellate Term, First DepartmentApplies (a) (6) to treat competing coverage under rental-car and personal policies as a priority-of-payment dispute requiring arbitration, rejecting the insurer's coverage defense because its own policy expressly covered rental and substitute vehicles.
- SZ Med., P.C. v Lancer Ins. Co. (2005 NY Slip Op 25112) Appellate Term, Second DepartmentApplies (a) (6) to hold that the insurer's assertion that another insurer is primary provides no defense to the providers' action, because priority of payment requires interinsurer arbitration and lies outside the court's jurisdiction.
- Yumi Acupuncture, P.C. v 21st Century Ins. Co. (2026 NY Slip Op 50433(U)) Trial courtApplies (a) (6) to require arbitration of payment-priority disputes, holding that the first-notified insurer's requests for a declaration of no other insurance did not toll the 30-day pay-or-deny period or render the provider's action premature.
- Parisien v Farmers Ins. (2022 NY Slip Op 22309) Trial courtApplies (a) (6) to exclude mandatory arbitration where the insurer establishes that commercial ride sharing falls outside its personal-use coverage, rejecting the provider's argument that the first-billed insurer must pay and arbitrate with another insurer.
Show all 12 decisions
- Matter of MTA Bus Co. v ACE USA (2012 NY Slip Op 51190(U)) Trial courtRelies on the finality and prohibition on rehearing or appeal under (a) (3) to reject the petitioning self-insurer's reliance on its attempted administrative appeal; the rejection letter was not an award and did not restart the 90-day period for seeking vacatur.
- Repwest Ins. Co. v Hanif (2019 NY Slip Op 09047) Appellate Division, Second DepartmentCites (a) (6) in rejecting the contention that an insurer's declaratory action and coverage disclaimer remove a loss-transfer counterclaim from mandatory arbitration, requiring dismissal of the counterclaim for lack of subject matter jurisdiction.
- RX Warehouse Pharmarcy Inc. v Erie Ins. Exch. (2019 NY Slip Op 50905(U)) Trial courtRejects the provider's argument that (a) (6) sends the insurer's defense to mandatory arbitration, finding its priority-of-payment rule not triggered absent evidence that the assignor was an eligible injured person under the insurer's policy.
- Eagle Ins. Co. v Republic W. Ins. Co. (2008 NY Slip Op 52116(U)) Trial courtNotes the insurer's argument under (a) (6) that the arbitrator exceeded his authority by deciding coverage, following the insurer's request that the arbitration administrator reconsider jurisdiction over the loss-transfer dispute.
Subdivision (d) (1 decision)
- Matter of MTA Bus Co. v ACE USA (2012 NY Slip Op 51190(U)) Trial courtQuotes the administrator's PIP rules identifying (d) as their authority, distinguishing the governing PIP procedures from the Property and Special Forums appeal provisions invoked by the petitioner to excuse its untimely petition to vacate the intercompany award.
Subdivision (f) (1 decision)
- Allstate Ins. Co. v Fiduciary Ins. Co. of Am. (2014 NY Slip Op 51021(U)) Trial courtNotes in a footnote that (f) charges the loss transfer advisory committee with reviewing interinsurer settlement rules and related matters and reporting findings and recommendations to the superintendent.
Section cited without a subdivision (4 decisions)
- Matter of Unitrin Direct/Warner Ins. Co. v Brand (2014 NY Slip Op 05887) Appellate Division, Second DepartmentCites the section to explain that any dispute over priority of first-party benefits must be resolved between insurers, in rejecting the claimant's argument that initial payment established an agreement to apply Florida law.
- Mendoza v Farmers Ins. Co. (2014 NY Slip Op 00613) Appellate Division, First DepartmentRelies on the section to identify mandatory arbitration as the sole remedy for coverage disputes between an insurer and MVAIC, in addressing the insurer's opportunity to contest policy cancellation in the prior arbitration.
- Matter of Progressive N. Ins. Co. v Sentry Ins. A Mut. Co. (2008 NY Slip Op 04524) Appellate Division, Second DepartmentCites the section as authority for the earlier priority-of-payment arbitration in which the insurer unsuccessfully sought reimbursement, before seeking the same reimbursement through a loss-transfer claim.
- Matter of American Tr. Ins. Co. v Nationwide Mut. Ins. Co. (2008 NY Slip Op 50295(U)) Appellate Term, Second DepartmentCites the section as authority for compulsory interinsurer arbitration seeking reimbursement of no-fault benefits, describing the proceedings that produced the awards submitted for confirmation.