September 22, 2023
Parisien v Esurance (2023 NY Slip Op 51235(U))
https://www.beynensonlaw.com/case-law/parisien-v-esurance-2023-ny-slip-op-51235u/
- Decided
- September 22, 2023
- Citation
- 2023 NY Slip Op 51235(U) · 81 Misc 3d 127(A)
- Posture
- Summary judgment
- Outcome
- Split result
- Later treatment
- Followed in 1 later decision (see Cited by)
Posture, outcome, issues and treatment by other decisions are Beynenson Law’s classification. Treatment labels are assigned by a language model reading the citing decision; negative and appeal-history labels are checked by a second reader.
Summary
Editorial summary by Beynenson Law, not part of the court’s decision.
Reported in New York Official Reports at Parisien v Esurance (2023 NY Slip Op 51235(U))
[*1]| Parisien v Esurance |
| 2023 NY Slip Op 51235(U) [81 Misc 3d 127(A)] |
| Decided on September 22, 2023 |
| Appellate Term, Second Department |
| Published by New York State Law Reporting Bureau pursuant to Judiciary Law § 431. |
| This opinion is uncorrected and will not be published in the printed Official Reports. |
Decided on September 22, 2023
PRESENT: : WAVNY TOUSSAINT, P.J., CHEREÉ A. BUGGS, LISA S. OTTLEY, JJ
2023-75 K C
against
Esurance, Respondent.
The Rybak Firm, PLLC (Damin J. Toell and Richard Rozhik of counsel), for appellant. Abrams, Cohen & Associates, P.C. (Frank Piccininni and Barry Cohen of counsel), for respondent.
Appeal from an order of the Civil Court of the City of New York, Kings County (Betty Lugo, J.), dated June 21, 2022. The order denied plaintiff’s motion for summary judgment and granted defendant’s cross-motion for summary judgment dismissing the complaint.
ORDERED that the order is modified by providing that defendant’s cross-motion for summary judgment dismissing the complaint is denied; as so modified, the order is affirmed, without costs.
In this action by a provider to recover assigned first-party no-fault benefits, plaintiff moved for summary judgment, and defendant cross-moved for summary judgment dismissing the complaint on the ground, among others, that the accident was a staged, intentional act for which there was no insurance coverage. By order dated June 21, 2022, the Civil Court denied plaintiff’s motion and granted defendant’s cross-motion.[FN1]
A review of the record indicates that plaintiff was not entitled to summary judgment since it failed to demonstrate, prima facie, that defendant had either failed to timely deny the claims [*2](see Viviane Etienne Med. Care, P.C. v Country-Wide Ins. Co., 25 NY3d 498 [2015]) or that the denial of claim forms were conclusory, vague or without merit as a matter of law (see Westchester Med. Ctr. v Nationwide Mut. Ins. Co., 78 AD3d 1168 [2010]; Ave T MPC Corp. v Auto One Ins. Co., 32 Misc 3d 128[A], 2011 NY Slip Op 51292[U] [App Term, 2d Dept, 2d, 11th & 13th Jud Dists 2011]). Consequently, the Civil Court properly denied plaintiff’s motion for summary judgment.
It is well settled that “an intentional and staged collision caused in the furtherance of an insurance fraud scheme is not a covered accident under a policy of insurance” (Matter of Liberty Mut. Ins. Co. v Goddard, 29 AD3d 698, 699 [2006]; see Central Gen. Hosp. v Chubb Group of Ins. Cos.,90 NY2d 195 [1997]; Nationwide Gen. Ins. Co. v Bates, 130 AD3d 795 [2015]). In support of this defense, defendant submitted numerous documents and photographs, including the affidavit of its senior investigator who concluded, based upon his review of a Department of Motor Vehicles abstract, police reports, and ISO claim search records, as well as transcripts of examinations under oath of people involved in the incident, that the collision in which plaintiff’s assignor was allegedly injured was “a staged/caused event for which there was no coverage.” Although defendant demonstrated that it possessed a “founded belief that the alleged injur[ies] do[] not arise out of an insured incident” (Central Gen. Hosp., 90 NY2d at 199), defendant failed to submit sufficient evidence in admissible form to establish that conclusion as a matter of law, so as to warrant dismissal of the complaint (see Lexington Acupuncture, P.C. v GEICO Ins. Co., 19 Misc 3d 128[A], 2008 NY Slip Op 50519[U] [App Term, 2d Dept, 2d & 11th Jud Dists 2008]). We note that, contrary to plaintiff’s contention, defendant did not cross-move for dismissal on the ground that there was a material misrepresentation in the procurement of the insurance policy and, as a result, we do not pass upon that issue.
Accordingly, the order is modified by providing that defendant’s cross-motion for summary judgment dismissing the complaint is denied.
TOUSSAINT, P.J., BUGGS and OTTLEY, JJ., concur.
ENTER:Paul Kenny
Chief Clerk
Decision Date: September 22, 2023
Footnote 1:We note that the Civil Court erroneously referred to defendant’s “motion” and plaintiff’s “cross-motion.”
Legal questions (2)
Questions of no-fault law this decision rules on, from our Legal Questions pages. Bars count the decisions on the question by year and court, coloured by category; circles are this decision and the decisions on the question it cites or that cite it. Point at a bar or circle for details. The categories and summaries are Beynenson Law’s classification, made by a language model and checked by a second reading.
On summary judgment or another pretrial motion, what must a no-fault claimant show to establish its prima facie case?
This decision: Insufficient: claimant did not prove the claim was overdue (not paid or timely denied)
Held the provider failed to show that the claims were not timely denied or that the denials were conclusory, vague or without merit, so its summary judgment motion was properly denied.
Of the 1,065 decisions on this question in the Second Department courts and the Court of Appeals, 247 (this one included) are in the same category.
Did the insurer show the claimed injuries did not arise from a covered accident (staged, intentional, or unrelated)?
This decision: Founded belief shown; the question must be tried
Held the investigator's affidavit and records showed a founded belief that the collision was staged, but lacked sufficient admissible evidence to establish that as a matter of law, so the insurer's dismissal motion was denied.
Of the 235 decisions on this question in the Second Department courts and the Court of Appeals, 102 (this one included) are in the same category.
Cited in this decision
A label shows how this decision treated the case it cites.
- Viviane Etienne Med. Care, P.C. v Country-Wide Ins. Co. (2015 NY Slip Op 04787) FollowedA provider establishes entitlement to summary judgment on overdue no-fault claims with admissible proof of mailing and receipt of statutory claim forms.
- Westchester Med. Ctr. v Nationwide Mut. Ins. Co. (2010 NY Slip Op 08933) FollowedThe provider failed to establish entitlement to summary judgment because the insurer partially paid and denied the claim within 30 days.
- Ave T MPC Corp. v Auto One Ins. Co. (2011 NY Slip Op 51292(U)) FollowedThe provider failed to establish summary judgment entitlement because nonpayment alone did not show an absent or legally insufficient denial.
- Nationwide Gen. Ins. Co. v Bates (2015 NY Slip Op 06122)The insurer failed to establish through admissible evidence that three collisions were staged to obtain insurance benefits.
- Lexington Acupuncture, P.C. v GEICO Ins. Co. (2008 NY Slip Op 50519(U)) FollowedThe insurer's founded belief that the injuries did not arise from an insured incident defeated the provider's summary judgment motion.
Cited by
A label shows how the later decision treated this one.
- Liberty RX Inc v Liberty Mut. Ins. Co. (2026 NY Slip Op 50992(U)) FollowedThe insurer's EUO inconsistencies raised credibility issues but did not establish a staged collision as a matter of law.
Similar decisions
- Parisien v Allstate Ins. Co. (2019 NY Slip Op 51249(U))The insurer established that the alleged injury did not arise from an insured incident through its insured's EUO testimony and affidavit.
- Parisien v Maya Assur. Co. (2018 NY Slip Op 50766(U))The insurer failed to prove mailing of IME scheduling letters, and the provider failed to establish entitlement to summary judgment.
- Parisien v 21st Century Ins. Co. (2019 NY Slip Op 50275(U))The insurer's late EUO follow-up letter defeated summary judgment on one claim, while disputed receipt defeated summary judgment on another.
- Impulse Imaging, P.C. v State Farm Fire & Cas. Co. (2021 NY Slip Op 51031(U))A staged-accident coverage defense requires no denial and must be considered before granting a provider summary judgment.
- Parisien v Ameriprise Ins. (2020 NY Slip Op 50990(U))The insurer proved the provider's EUO nonappearances, including one at a location changed at the provider's request, and a timely denial.