Arbitrator Data
Calendar of Awards Submitted by the Arbitrator
The calendar below shows the dates and numbers of awards submitted by the Arbitrator. This may be an indicator of whether the awards are generally submitted in bulk or on a rolling basis.
Number of Awards Over Time
This graph shows the weekly numbers of awards submitted by the Arbitrator. This gives a picture of relative caseload trends for this Arbitrator.
Percentage of Awards in Favor of Applicant
This graph shows the monthly rate of awards in favor of the Applicant vs. Respondent. The blue line shows the percentage of awards rendered by this Arbitrator in favor of the Applicant. The red line shows only considers the awards in cases by the given Respondent.
Average Time to Award
The blue line shows the average number of days between the actual hearing and the Arbitrator making the hearing closed. This may be an indicator of the Arbitrator’s willingness to accept post-hearing submissions or to continue hearings. The red line shows the average number of days between the hearing being closed and the award being submitted. This is useful to set expectations of when an award may be rendered.
Awards
The table below shows the awards written by the Arbitrator starting with the most recent.
| id | Arbitrator | Case No. | Provider | Insurance Co | Award Date | Hearing Date | Hearing Closed Date | Applicant Attorney | Applicant Appearance By | Respondent Attorney | Respondent Appearance By | Holding | Original Claim Amount | Amended Claim Amount | Total Awarded | Interest Start Date | Interest (approx) | Attorney Fee (approx) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1,202,011 | Anne Malone | 17-24-1380-1834 | AA COMPREHENSIVE MEDICAL PC | American Transit Insurance Company | 03/05/2026 | 02/23/2026 | 02/23/2026 | Law Offices of Andrew J. Costella Jr., Esq. | Melissa Scotti | American Transit Insurance Company | Peter Famuyide | DENIED | 397.35 | |||||
| 1,201,989 | Anne Malone | 17-24-1378-3929 | MAR-AND MEDICAL EQUIPMENT, INC | Allstate Fire & Casualty Insurance Company | 03/05/2026 | 02/23/2026 | 02/23/2026 | Law Offices of Andrew J. Costella Jr., Esq. | Melissa Scotti | Law Offices Of Richard Schoenberg | Maurenika Erinkitola | DENIED | 708.65 | |||||
| 1,201,833 | Anne Malone | 17-24-1378-3939 | PLUS DRUGS INC | State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company | 03/05/2026 | 02/23/2026 | 02/23/2026 | Law Offices of Andrew J. Costella Jr., Esq. | Melissa Scotti | State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company | Dianna Rokitowski | DENIED | 24.50 | |||||
| 1,201,797 | Anne Malone | 17-25-1411-6111 | EZ TRIBORO SERVICES INC | CSAA General Insurance Company | 03/05/2026 | 02/23/2026 | 02/23/2026 | The Sigalov Firm PLLC | Jeffrey Datikashvilli | CSAA General Insurance Company | Kimberly Iuliano | DENIED | 548.08 | |||||
| 1,201,793 | Anne Malone | 17-25-1384-6832 | LANE MEDICAL CARE PC | Selective Insurance Company of New York | 03/05/2026 | 02/23/2026 | 02/23/2026 | Law Offices Of Andrew J Costella Jr., Esq., PC | Melissa Scotti | O'Malley, Padovani & Demler | Christopher Vetro | AWARDED | 1,604.54 | 1,604.54 | 1,604.54 | 04/23/2024 | 728.46 | 466.60 |
| 1,201,705 | Anne Malone | 17-25-1404-6750 | ALL MED RX INC D/B/A LILLY RX | Allstate Fire & Casualty Insurance Company | 03/04/2026 | 02/09/2026 | 02/26/2026 | The Tadchiev Law Firm, P.C. | James DiCarlo | Law Offices Of Richard Schoenberg | Anisah Molic | AWARDED | 4,298.40 | 4,298.40 | 4,298.40 | 11/20/2024 | 1,343.97 | 1,128.47 |
| 1,201,692 | Anne Malone | 17-25-1407-0653 | CROSS BAY ORTHOPEDIC SURGERY PC | Allstate Fire & Casualty Insurance Company | 03/04/2026 | 02/09/2026 | 02/09/2026 | The Tadchiev Law Firm, P.C. | James DiCarlo | Law Offices Of Richard Schoenberg | Anisah Molic | DENIED | 163.00 | |||||
| 1,201,665 | Anne Malone | 17-25-1402-5639 | ORTHO CHOICE INC | American Transit Insurance Company | 03/04/2026 | 02/09/2026 | 02/09/2026 | The Tadchiev Law Firm, P.C. | James DiCarlo | American Transit Insurance Company | Marc Attias | AWARDED | 3,669.48 | 3,669.48 | 3,669.48 | 06/02/2025 | 672.74 | 868.44 |
| 1,201,652 | Anne Malone | 17-25-1413-0475 | COMMUNITY MEDICAL WELLNESS, PC | LM General Insurance Company | 03/04/2026 | 02/09/2026 | 02/09/2026 | Dino R. DiRienzo Esq. | Michael Galeno | LM General Insurance Company | Kathleen Ready | AWARDED | 3,020.21 | 3,020.20 | 3,020.20 | 08/11/2025 | 412.76 | 686.59 |
| 1,201,651 | Anne Malone | 17-25-1408-3162 | COMMUNITY MEDICAL WELLNESS, PC | LM General Insurance Company | 03/04/2026 | 02/09/2026 | 02/09/2026 | Dino R. DiRienzo Esq. | Michael Galeno | LM General Insurance Company | Kathleen Raedy | AWARDED | 5,859.23 | 4,966.68 | 4,966.68 | 07/11/2025 | 781.42 | 1,149.62 |
| 1,201,538 | Anne Malone | 17-25-1397-7264 | ISLAND AMBULATORY SURGERY CENTER LLC | State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company | 03/04/2026 | 02/06/2026 | 02/06/2026 | Drachman Katz, LLP | Sasha Hochman | Siegel & O'Leary LLP | Taylor Grogan | DENIED | 980.10 | |||||
| 1,201,505 | Anne Malone | 17-25-1399-1748 | ISLAND AMBULATORY SURGERY CENTER LLC | State Farm Fire & Casualty Company | 03/04/2026 | 02/06/2026 | 02/06/2026 | Drachman Katz, LLP | Sasha Hochman | Siegel & O'Leary LLP | Taylor Grogan | DENIED | 1,259.33 | |||||
| 1,201,504 | Anne Malone | 17-25-1409-0397 | UPTOWN HEALTHCARE MANAGEMENT INC D/B/A EAST TREMONT MEDICAL CENTER | Hereford Insurance Company | 03/04/2026 | 02/06/2026 | 02/06/2026 | The Law Offices of Hillary Blumenthal P.C. | Rajesh Barua | Law Offices of Ruth Nazarian | Erisa Ahmedi | DENIED | 14,406.41 | |||||
| 1,201,288 | Anne Malone | 17-25-1401-1081 | ATLANTIC MEDICAL & DIAGNOSTIC PC | MVAIC | 03/03/2026 | 02/06/2026 | 02/06/2026 | Israel Purdy, LLP | Scott Fisher | Marshall & Marshall, Esqs | Steven Miranda | AWARDED | 6,004.51 | 4,401.76 | 1,043.10 | 05/21/2025 | 198.88 | 248.40 |
| 1,201,285 | Anne Malone | 17-25-1409-5203 | ATLANTIC MEDICAL & DIAGNOSTIC PC | MVAIC | 03/03/2026 | 02/06/2026 | 02/06/2026 | Israel Purdy, LLP | Scott Fisher | Marshall & Marshall, Esqs | Steven Miranda | AWARDED | 2,964.08 | 2.17 | 491.01 | 07/17/2025 | 74.96 | 113.19 |
| 1,201,284 | Anne Malone | 17-25-1407-2112 | ATLANTIC MEDICAL & DIAGNOSTIC PC | MVAIC | 03/03/2026 | 02/06/2026 | 02/06/2026 | Israel Purdy, LLP | Scott Fisher | Marshall & Marshall, Esqs | Steven Miranda | AWARDED | 5,928.16 | 4,340.68 | 982.02 | 07/02/2025 | 159.74 | 228.35 |
| 1,201,257 | Anne Malone | 17-25-1401-1215 | JR MEDICAL PC | MVAIC | 03/03/2026 | 02/06/2026 | 02/06/2026 | The Law Offices of Hillary Blumenthal P.C. | Rajesh Barua | Marshall & Marshall, Esqs | Steven Miranda | DENIED | 1,200.58 | |||||
| 1,200,493 | Anne Malone | 17-25-1409-3411 | SEDATION VACATION PERIOPERATIVE MEDICINE PLLC | American Transit Insurance Company | 02/27/2026 | 02/06/2026 | 02/06/2026 | The Law Office of Thomas Tona, PC | Vijay Gupta | American Transit Insurance Company | Peter Famuyide | AWARDED | 653.80 | 653.80 | 653.80 | 07/17/2025 | 98.07 | 150.37 |
| 1,200,492 | Anne Malone | 17-25-1406-6134 | BAY HEALTH PHARMACY, INC. | Affirmative Direct Insurance Company | 02/27/2026 | 02/06/2026 | 02/06/2026 | Leon Kucherovsky Esq. | Steven Palumbo | *Abrams Fensterman, LLP | Gregory Etienne | DENIED | 2,162.26 | |||||
| 1,200,491 | Anne Malone | 17-25-1410-0659 | CJ ALLEN OT UPPER EXTREMITY & HAND THERAPY PLLC | LM General Insurance Company | 02/27/2026 | 02/06/2026 | 02/06/2026 | The Law Office of Thomas Tona, PC | Vijay Gupta | LM General Insurance Company | Seteria Irby | DENIED | 1,088.70 | |||||
| 1,199,701 | Anne Malone | 17-25-1401-9705 | AMERICAN MEDICAL RESPONSE NY | Allstate Insurance Company | 02/24/2026 | 01/22/2026 | 01/22/2026 | Super Associates P.C. | Steven Super | Law Offices Of Richard Schoenberg | Billsy Reyes-Bakke | DISMISSED without prejudice | 2,319.86 | |||||
| 1,199,689 | Anne Malone | 17-25-1409-8635 | THE CENTER FOR ADVANCED SPINE & JOINT SURGERY | State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company | 02/24/2026 | 02/06/2026 | 02/06/2026 | The Law Office of Thomas Tona, PC | Vijay Gupta | Abrams, Cohen & Associates, PC | Ziqi Guan | DENIED | 2,440.95 | |||||
| 1,199,661 | Anne Malone | 17-25-1409-8662 | SEDATION VACATION PERIOPERATIVE MEDICINE PLLC | Allstate Fire & Casualty Insurance Company | 02/24/2026 | 02/06/2026 | 02/06/2026 | The Law Office of Thomas Tona, PC | Vijay Gupta | Law Offices Of Richard Schoenberg | Esther Meyrov | DENIED | 207.97 | |||||
| 1,199,660 | Anne Malone | 17-25-1409-5535 | VILLAGE MEDICAL PC DBA BRANCH ORTHOPAEDICS | Allstate Fire & Casualty Insurance Company | 02/24/2026 | 02/06/2026 | 02/06/2026 | The Law Office of Thomas Tona, PC | Vijay Gupta | Law Offices Of Richard Schoenberg | Esther Meyrov | DENIED | 87.80 | |||||
| 1,199,614 | Anne Malone | 17-25-1398-9141 | SEDATION VACATION PERIOPERATIVE MEDICINE PLLC | MVAIC | 02/24/2026 | 02/06/2026 | 02/06/2026 | The Law Office of Thomas Tona, PC | Vijay Gupta | Marshall & Marshall, Esqs | Steven Miranda | DENIED | 171.32 | |||||
| Case No. | Provider | Insurance Co | Applicant Attorney | Applicant Appearance By | Respondent Attorney | Respondent Appearance By | Total Awarded |