February 22, 2012
Total Equip. LLC v State Farm Fire & Cas. Co. (2012 NY Slip Op 22038)
https://www.beynensonlaw.com/case-law/total-equip-llc-v-state-farm-fire-cas-co-2012-ny-slip-op-22038/
- Judge
- Ciaffa, J.
- Decided
- February 22, 2012
- Citation
- 2012 NY Slip Op 22038 · 35 Misc 3d 472
- Posture
- Summary judgment
- Outcome
- Insurer prevailed
- Legal questions
- Lack of medical necessity · Proof of mailing (see the maps)
Posture, outcome, issues and treatment by other decisions are Beynenson Law’s classification. Treatment labels are assigned by a language model reading the citing decision; negative and appeal-history labels are checked by a second reader.
Summary
Editorial summary by Beynenson Law, not part of the court’s decision.
Reported in New York Official Reports at Total Equip. LLC v State Farm Fire & Cas. Co. (2012 NY Slip Op 22038)
| Total Equip. LLC v State Farm Fire & Cas. Co. |
| 2012 NY Slip Op 22038 [35 Misc 3d 472] |
| February 22, 2012 |
| Ciaffa, J. |
| District Court Of Nassau County, First District |
| Published by New York State Law Reporting Bureau pursuant to Judiciary Law § 431. |
| As corrected through Wednesday, May 30, 2012 |
[*1]
| Total Equipment LLC, as Assignee of Gordon T. Springs, Plaintiff, v State Farm Fire and Casualty Co., Defendant. |
District Court of Nassau County, First District, February 22, 2012
APPEARANCES OF COUNSEL
Picciano & Scahill, P.C., Westbury, for defendant. Friedman, Harfenist, Kraut & Perlstein, Lake Success, for plaintiff.
Michael A. Ciaffa, J.
{**35 Misc 3d at 473}Defendant renews its motion for summary judgment dismissing plaintiff’s no-fault action, based upon a defense of lack of medical necessity. The motion is supported by an affirmed peer review report of Kevin S. Portnoy, D.C. Plaintiff opposes the motion. Its opposition includes a rebuttal peer review report from a nontreating doctor, Lloyd Kupferman, D.C.
Defendant’s prior motion was denied without prejudice to renewal following production of the medical records that Dr. Portnoy reviewed (see decision and order dated May 31, 2011). Defendant avers that it made such production as part of its June 22, 2011 response to plaintiff’s first set of interrogatories. Plaintiff does not contest the sufficiency of defendant’s response to interrogatories in its papers opposing defendant’s motion.
Defendant’s moving papers include adequate proof of defendant’s timely denial of plaintiff’s claim for no-fault benefits. Through affidavits from a claims representative and a claims support services supervisor, defendant established prima facie that the denial was timely mailed in accordance with defendant’s standard office practices and procedures. ([*2]See St. Vincent’s Hosp. of Richmond v Government Empls. Ins. Co., 50 AD3d 1123 [2d Dept 2008].) Plaintiff’s opposition fails to raise a triable issue respecting the timely mailing of the denial.
In addition, the affirmed peer review report of Dr. Portnoy sets forth a facially sufficient factual basis and medical rationale for his opinion challenging the medical necessity of the durable medical equipment that is the subject of the denial. Although defendant’s proof, once again, fails to annex the underlying medical records reviewed by its peer doctor, the Appellate Term’s current decisions hold that submission of such medical records is “not part of defendant’s prima facie showing.” (See Active Imaging, P.C. v Progressive Northeastern Ins. Co., 29 Misc 3d 130[A], 2010 NY Slip Op 51842[U], *2 [App Term, 2d Dept 2010].) On the other hand, plaintiff acted within its rights, in opposing defendant’s prior motion, by seeking an opportunity to obtain production of the underlying medical records in order to mount meaningful opposition to defendant’s motion. (See East 75th St. Diagnostic Imaging v Clarendon Natl. Ins. Co., 33 Misc 3d 573 [Nassau Dist Ct 2011].) By allowing such discovery in this matter, the court reasoned that it “might ‘lead to relevant evidence’ ” that could justify opposition to defendant’s motion (see decision and order dated May 31, 2011 at 1).
Inexplicably, plaintiff’s opposition to the instant motion neither submits the underlying medical records reviewed by Dr.{**35 Misc 3d at 474} Portnoy, nor explains their absence. While such a failure to submit the underlying records is not necessarily fatal to plaintiff’s argument, it underscores the weakness of plaintiff’s opposition. In other cases, no-fault plaintiffs have frequently defeated insurer motions by utilizing the underlying medical records to undermine the stated factual basis and/or medical rationale for the peer doctor’s opinion. Plaintiff, here, has made no attempt to do so.
Moreover, upon close examination of the plaintiff’s rebuttal proof, the absence of the underlying medical records weighs heavily against plaintiff’s argument. According to Dr. Kupferman’s rebuttal report, he takes issue with Dr. Portnoy’s opinion based principally on his “review of this patient’s medical records.” Although Dr. Kupferman’s “independent review” of the medical records supposedly supports his contention that Dr. Portnoy’s “clinical reasoning” is “flawed,” the court is essentially being asked to determine, from this equally “naked” rebuttal peer review report, that triable issues exist. The court declines to do so upon the instant record.
Critically, under Appellate Term precedent (1) submission of the underlying medical records is not part of the defendant’s prima facie burden (see Active Imaging, P.C. v Progressive Northeastern Ins. Co., supra), and (2) opposing expert proof will not be sufficient to defeat the defendant’s motion unless it “meaningfully” refers to, and rebuts, the opinion of defendant’s peer review doctor. (See e.g. Bath Med. Supply, Inc. v New York Cent. Mut. Fire Ins. Co., 30 Misc 3d 137[A], 2011 NY Slip Op 50189[U], *2 [App Term, 2d Dept 2011]; Vinings Spinal Diagnostic, P.C. v GEICO Gen. Ins. Co., 29 Misc 3d 132[A], 2010 NY Slip Op 51897[U] [App Term, 2d Dept 2010]; Pan Chiropractic, P.C. v Mercury Ins. Co., 24 Misc 3d 136[A], 2009 NY Slip Op 51495[U] [App Term, 2d Dept 2009].)
In this court’s opinion, any “meaningful” rebuttal opinion from a nontreating [*3]doctor must ordinarily include copies of relevant medical records that provide a factual basis and/or medical rationale for rebutting the otherwise adequate evidence from defendant’s peer review expert. While defendant could have submitted the medical records as part of its motion, the Appellate Term holds that it need not do so to shift the burden to the plaintiff. At least where, as here, the plaintiff’s rebuttal proof rests principally upon a medical records review by a nontreating doctor, plaintiff must submit those records to the court in order to raise a legitimate triable issue of medical necessity. In their{**35 Misc 3d at 475} absence, submission of a naked, conclusory rebuttal report, by itself, is insufficient to raise a triable issue of medical necessity.
For all these reasons, the court concludes that defendant’s moving papers met its burden establishing entitlement to judgment as a matter of law, and that plaintiff’s opposition fails to raise a triable issue of medical necessity. Accordingly, defendant’s motion is granted and the action is dismissed.
Legal questions (2)
Questions of no-fault law this decision rules on, from our Legal Questions pages. Bars count the decisions on the question by year and court, coloured by category; circles are this decision and the decisions on the question it cites or that cite it. Point at a bar or circle for details. The categories and summaries are Beynenson Law’s classification, made by a language model and checked by a second reading.
Did the insurer’s proof establish lack of medical necessity, and did the provider’s evidence rebut it?
This decision: Insurer's proof established lack of medical necessity and the provider failed to rebut it
Held the affirmed peer review set forth a sufficient factual basis and medical rationale, and a nontreating doctor's rebuttal relying on records not submitted was conclusory and raised no triable issue.
Of the 617 decisions on this question in the Second Department courts and the Court of Appeals, 315 (this one included) are in the same category.
Did a party’s evidence establish that it mailed a no-fault claim, denial, verification request or examination notice?
This decision: The insurer's (or its agent's) proof established mailing of its denial, verification request or IME/EUO notice (rules on the question, but another ground decided the case)
Held the affidavits of a claims representative and claims support supervisor established timely mailing of the denial under standard office practices, and the provider raised no triable issue on mailing.
Of the 1,400 decisions on this question in the Second Department courts and the Court of Appeals, 809 (this one included) are in the same category.
Cited in this decision
A label shows how this decision treated the case it cites.
- St. Vincent’s Hosp. of Richmond v Government Empls. Ins. Co. (2008 NY Slip Op 04072) FollowedThe insurer raised factual issues concerning a proper timely denial and its entitlement to deny the hospital's claim.
- Active Imaging, P.C. v Progressive Northeastern Ins. Co. (2010 NY Slip Op 51842(U)) FollowedAn insurer need not annex the third-party records reviewed by its peer reviewer as part of its prima facie summary judgment showing.
- East 75th St. Diagnostic Imaging v Clarendon Natl. Ins. Co. (2011 NY Slip Op 21315) FollowedThe diagnostic provider showed that records underlying the insurer's peer reviews were needed to oppose summary judgment.
- Bath Med. Supply, Inc. v New York Cent. Mut. Fire Ins. Co. (2011 NY Slip Op 50189(U))The insurer's peer reviews established lack of medical necessity, and the provider failed to offer a meaningful rebuttal.
- Vinings Spinal Diagnostic, P.C. v Geico Gen. Ins. Co. (2010 NY Slip Op 51897(U))The insurer's peer review and the provider's rebuttal created a triable issue of medical necessity, precluding provider summary judgment.
- Pan Chiropractic, P.C. v Mercury Ins. Co. (2009 NY Slip Op 51495(U))The provider's conclusory disagreement with the insurer's supported peer review failed to raise a medical-necessity issue of fact.
Similar decisions
- Velen Med. Supply Inc. v Travelers Ins. Co. (2008 NY Slip Op 28252)A provider may not challenge the reliability of its own medical records relied on by an insurer's peer reviewer.
- Park Slope Med. & Surgical Supply, Inc. v Travelers Ins. Co. (2012 NY Slip Op 22200)Medical records supporting a peer review are admissible to show information conveyed to the insurer rather than the truth of their contents.
- MSSA Corp. v Redland Ins. Co. (2011 NY Slip Op 51606(U))The insurer's unrebutted peer review established a factual basis and medical rationale for denying the supplies as medically unnecessary.
- A.M. Med. Servs., P.C. v Deerbrook Ins. Co. (2008 NY Slip Op 50368(U))An insurer need not seek further verification when its medical experts have sufficient information to assess medical necessity.
- Ortho-Med Surgical Supply, Inc. v Progressive Cas. Ins. Co. (2012 NY Slip Op 50149(U))An insurer need not attach the records reviewed by its peer reviewer to establish lack of medical necessity on summary judgment.