Arbitrator Data
Calendar of Awards Submitted by the Arbitrator
The calendar below shows the dates and numbers of awards submitted by the Arbitrator. This may be an indicator of whether the awards are generally submitted in bulk or on a rolling basis.
Number of Awards Over Time
This graph shows the weekly numbers of awards submitted by the Arbitrator. This gives a picture of relative caseload trends for this Arbitrator.
Percentage of Awards in Favor of Applicant
This graph shows the monthly rate of awards in favor of the Applicant vs. Respondent. The blue line shows the percentage of awards rendered by this Arbitrator in favor of the Applicant. The red line shows only considers the awards in cases by the given Respondent.
Average Time to Award
The blue line shows the average number of days between the actual hearing and the Arbitrator making the hearing closed. This may be an indicator of the Arbitrator’s willingness to accept post-hearing submissions or to continue hearings. The red line shows the average number of days between the hearing being closed and the award being submitted. This is useful to set expectations of when an award may be rendered.
Awards
The table below shows the awards written by the Arbitrator starting with the most recent.
id | Arbitrator | Case No. | Provider | Insurance Co | Award Date | Hearing Date | Hearing Closed Date | Applicant Attorney | Applicant Appearance By | Respondent Attorney | Respondent Appearance By | Holding | Original Claim Amount | Amended Claim Amount | Total Awarded | Interest Start Date | Interest (approx) | Attorney Fee (approx) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1,139,547 | Anne Malone | 17-24-1356-6143 | FIFTH AVENUE SURGERY CENTER LLC | Nationwide General Insurance Company | 07/26/2025 | 07/07/2025 | 07/07/2025 | The Tadchiev Law Firm, P.C. | Sabine Sciarotto, Esq | Law Offices of Brian Rayhill | Gina Spitieri, Esq. | AWARDED | 11,567.57 | 5,677.77 | 07/16/2024 | 1,419.44 | 1,360.00 | |
1,139,545 | Anne Malone | 17-24-1355-4400 | FIFTH AVENUE SURGERY CENTER LLC | Hereford Insurance Company | 07/26/2025 | 07/07/2025 | 07/07/2025 | The Tadchiev Law Firm, P.C. | Sabine Sciarotto, Esq | Hereford Insurance Company | Elina Amiryan | AWARDED | 10,554.50 | 10,504.50 | 02/10/2022 | 8,837.79 | 1,360.00 | |
1,139,542 | Anne Malone | 17-24-1363-6052 | PRECISE MEDICAL SOLUTIONS LLC | State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company | 07/26/2025 | 07/07/2025 | 07/07/2025 | The Tadchiev Law Firm, P.C. | Sabine Sciarotto, Esq | Rossillo & Licata LLP | Joseph Licata, Esq. | AWARDED | 898.06 | 898.06 | 25.84 | 09/03/2024 | 5.62 | 6.29 |
1,139,541 | Anne Malone | 17-24-1355-4452 | MARK L. RITCH D.O. P.A. | State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company | 07/26/2025 | 07/07/2025 | 07/07/2025 | The Tadchiev Law Firm, P.C. | Sabine Sciarotto, Esq | Abrams, Cohen & Associates, PC | Shelly Heffez, Esq. | DENIED | 3,290.18 | |||||
1,139,513 | Anne Malone | 17-24-1355-4426 | COMFORT CARE SERVICES INC | NYC Office of the Comptroller | 07/26/2025 | 07/07/2025 | 07/07/2025 | The Tadchiev Law Firm, P.C. | Sabine Sciarotto, Esq | NYC Office Of The Comptroller | Diana Rojas | DENIED | 4,202.10 | |||||
1,139,511 | Anne Malone | 17-25-1381-1148 | HUDSON VALLEY CHIROPRACTIC HEALTH SERVICES PC | Repwest Insurance Company | 07/26/2025 | 07/07/2025 | 07/07/2025 | The Law Offices of Hillary Blumenthal P.C. | Usman Nawaz, Esq | Husch Blackwell LLP | Jennifer Jordan, Esq. | DENIED | 114.60 | |||||
1,139,395 | Anne Malone | 17-25-1380-9428 | N. FELDMAN FAMILY HEALTH NP P.C. | Avis Budget Group | 07/25/2025 | 07/07/2025 | 07/07/2025 | The Law Offices of Hillary Blumenthal P.C. | Usman Nawaz, Esq | Hollander Legal Group PC | Brian Kaufman, Esq. | AWARDED | 961.14 | 961.14 | 511.11 | 01/07/2025 | 67.81 | 115.78 |
1,139,382 | Anne Malone | 17-25-1380-5000 | MEDICAL IMAGING OF BRONX, PC | Liberty Mutual Insurance Company | 07/25/2025 | 07/07/2025 | 07/07/2025 | The Law Offices of Hillary Blumenthal P.C. | Usman Nawaz, Esq | Liberty Mutual Insurance Company | Meliane Diedro | DENIED | 1,055.57 | |||||
1,139,380 | Anne Malone | 17-25-1381-2227 | LIBERTY MD | Liberty Mutual Insurance Company | 07/25/2025 | 07/07/2025 | 07/07/2025 | The Law Offices of Hillary Blumenthal P.C. | Usman Nawaz, Esq | Liberty Mutual Insurance Company | Theo Gamble | DENIED | 1,605.08 | |||||
1,134,830 | Anne Malone | 17-24-1379-8664 | SADDLEBROOK ENDOSCOPIC & ORTHOPEDIC SURGERY CENTER | Liberty Mutual Insurance Company | 07/10/2025 | 07/07/2025 | 07/07/2025 | The Law Offices of Hillary Blumenthal P.C. | Usman Nawaz, Esq | Liberty Mutual Insurance Company | Herman Buchanan | DENIED | 21,160.00 | |||||
1,134,829 | Anne Malone | 17-24-1379-3147 | DAILY DOSE RX LLC. | Geico Insurance Company | 07/10/2025 | 07/07/2025 | 07/07/2025 | The Law Offices of John Gallagher, PLLC | Aleksey Selipanov, Esq | Geico Insurance Company | Maria Greenman | DENIED | 455.71 | |||||
1,134,828 | Anne Malone | 17-24-1376-1168 | ALPINE MED | Geico Insurance Company | 07/10/2025 | 07/07/2025 | 07/07/2025 | The Law Offices of John Gallagher, PLLC | Aleksey Selipanov, Esq | Geico Insurance Company | Maria Gruman | DENIED | 2,511.46 | |||||
1,134,808 | Anne Malone | 17-25-1380-2558 | NATURE SB PLUS INC | Repwest Insurance Company | 07/10/2025 | 07/07/2025 | 07/07/2025 | The Law Offices of John Gallagher, PLLC | Aleksey Selipanov, Esq | Husch Blackwell LLP | Matthew Sarles, Esq. | DENIED | 566.16 | |||||
1,134,806 | Anne Malone | 17-24-1378-7438 | NATURE SB PLUS INC | Repwest Insurance Company | 07/10/2025 | 07/07/2025 | 07/07/2025 | The Law Offices of John Gallagher, PLLC | Aleksey Selipanov, Esq | Husch Blackwell LLP | Matthew Sarles, Esq. | DENIED | 4,707.60 | |||||
1,134,408 | Anne Malone | 17-24-1357-2535 | FLOTUS INC. | St. Paul Travelers Insurance Co. | 07/09/2025 | 06/20/2025 | 06/20/2025 | Baker & Narkolayeva Law P.C. | Elyse Ulino, Esq | Law Offices of Tina Newsome-Lee | Anastasiya Nabatova, Esq. | DENIED | 3,623.07 | |||||
1,134,286 | Anne Malone | 17-24-1345-6358 | TAPIK MED DISTRIBUTION CORP. | Allstate Fire & Casualty Insurance Company | 07/09/2025 | 06/20/2025 | 06/20/2025 | Baker & Narkolayeva Law P.C. | Elyse Ulino, Esq | Law Offices of John Trop | Donna Strudwick, Esq. | AWARDED | 2,391.93 | 2,384.98 | 2,384.98 | 04/26/2024 | 698.00 | 616.60 |
1,134,252 | Anne Malone | 17-25-1383-3838 | ZWANGER-PESIRI RADIOLOGY GROUP LLP | Hereford Insurance Company | 07/09/2025 | 06/20/2025 | 06/20/2025 | Choudhry & Franzoni, PLLC | Tinamarie Franzoni, Esq | Law Offices of Ruth Nazarian | Cliff Ryan, Esq. | DENIED | 966.54 | |||||
1,134,248 | Anne Malone | 17-24-1373-9751 | CITI MED SUPPLY, INC | Progressive Casualty Insurance Company | 07/09/2025 | 06/23/2025 | 06/23/2025 | Law Offices of Ilya E Parnas P.C. | Robin Grumet, Esq | McCormack, Mattei & Holler | Jake Komar, Esq. | AWARDED | 6,246.83 | 6,246.83 | 2,726.88 | 11/12/2024 | 434.48 | 632.27 |
1,134,029 | Anne Malone | 17-24-1362-2746 | JAMAICA SUPPLIES 1 INC | MVAIC | 07/08/2025 | 06/23/2025 | 06/23/2025 | Law Offices of Ilya E Parnas P.C. | Robin Grumet, Esq | Marshall & Marshall, Esqs. | Jeffrey Kadushin, Esq. | DISMISSED without prejudice | 1,545.96 | |||||
1,134,020 | Anne Malone | 17-24-1377-9605 | FUTURE MEDICAL, PC | State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company | 07/08/2025 | 06/23/2025 | 06/23/2025 | Law Offices of Eitan Dagan (Woodhaven) | Edialaine D'Arce, Esq | Freiberg, Peck and Kang, LLP | Scott Schwaber, Esq. | DENIED | 614.86 | |||||
1,133,974 | Anne Malone | 17-24-1357-5841 | BLVD DME INC. | Geico Insurance Company | 07/08/2025 | 06/23/2025 | 06/23/2025 | Law Offices of Ilya E Parnas P.C. | Robin Grumet, Esq | Geico Insurance Company | Jerry Marino | DENIED | 1,433.10 | |||||
1,133,930 | Anne Malone | 17-24-1333-6807 | SKYLINE BK, INC | Country-Wide Insurance Company | 07/08/2025 | 06/23/2025 | 06/23/2025 | Korsunskiy Legal Group P.C. | Henry Guindi, Esq | Jaffe & Velazquez, LLP | Ellen Maisto, Esq. | 3,300.00 | ||||||
1,132,875 | Anne Malone | 17-24-1365-2427 | MEDEX DIAGNOSTIC & TREATMENT CENTER LLC | MVAIC | 07/05/2025 | 06/20/2025 | 06/20/2025 | Law Offices of Ilya E Parnas P.C. | Usman Nawaz, Esq | Marshall & Marshall, Esqs. | Craig Marshall, Esq. | AWARDED | 1,423.90 | 1,423.90 | 1,423.90 | 09/13/2024 | 280.03 | 340.79 |
1,132,803 | Anne Malone | 17-24-1337-0635 | ORTHO SPORTS SUPPLY INC. | Progressive Casualty Insurance Company | 07/05/2025 | 06/20/2025 | 06/20/2025 | Law Offices of Ilya E Parnas P.C. | Usman Nawaz, Esq | Progressive Casualty Insurance Company | Mary Casapello | DENIED | 5,400.00 | |||||
1,132,801 | Anne Malone | 17-24-1337-0633 | ORTHO SPORTS SUPPLY INC. | Progressive Casualty Insurance Company | 07/05/2025 | 06/20/2025 | 06/20/2025 | Law Offices of Ilya E Parnas P.C. | Usman Nawaz, Esq | Progressive Casualty Insurance Company | Mary Casapello | DENIED | 5,100.00 | |||||
Case No. | Provider | Insurance Co | Applicant Attorney | Applicant Appearance By | Respondent Attorney | Respondent Appearance By | Total Awarded |