• 347-746-6001
  • contact@beynensonlaw.com
Beynenson Law
Beynenson Law
  • Services
    • Search Case Law & Regulations
    • New Decisions
    • Decisions by Court
    • Legal Questions
    • No-Fault Regulations
    • Claim Process & Deadlines
    • Ask No-Fault AI
    • Arbitrator Scorecard
    • Award Volume
    • Arbitrator / Carrier Data
    • Provider / Carrier Data
    • Provider / Attorney Data
    • Arbitration Pro Extension
  • About Us
  • Contact
  • East Hampton, New York

  • 347-746-6001
  • contact@beynensonlaw.com
  • Services
    • Search Case Law & Regulations
    • New Decisions
    • Decisions by Court
    • Legal Questions
    • No-Fault Regulations
    • Claim Process & Deadlines
    • Ask No-Fault AI
    • Arbitrator Scorecard
    • Award Volume
    • Arbitrator / Carrier Data
    • Provider / Carrier Data
    • Provider / Attorney Data
    • Arbitration Pro Extension
  • About Us
  • Contact
October 30, 2020

J.C. Healing Touch Rehab, P.C. v 21st Century Ins. Co. (2020 NY Slip Op 51296(U))

https://www.beynensonlaw.com/case-law/j-c-healing-touch-rehab-p-c-v-21st-century-ins-co-2020-ny-slip-op51296u/

Court
Appellate Term, Second Department
Decided
October 30, 2020
Citation
2020 NY Slip Op 51296(U)
Posture
Summary judgment
Outcome
Insurer prevailed
Issues
Declaratory judgment, res judicata Discovery and procedure
Legal questions
Effect of insurer's declaratory judgment (see the maps)
Cite as
J.C. Healing Touch Rehab, P.C. v 21st Century Ins. Co., 2020 NY Slip Op 51296(U) (App Term, 2d Dept, 2d, 11th & 13th Jud Dists 2020)

Posture, outcome, issues and treatment by other decisions are Beynenson Law’s classification. Treatment labels are assigned by a language model reading the citing decision; negative and appeal-history labels are checked by a second reader.

Summary

Editorial summary by Beynenson Law, not part of the court’s decision.

The insurer's later summary judgment motion was permissible, and a declaratory judgment barred the provider's claims under res judicata. The Supreme Court, Nassau County, declared that the insurer owed no coverage for the collision or resulting no-fault claims. Because that action and judgment postdated the insurer's answer and first cross motion, omission of preclusion defenses was excusable. The later motion introduced the new judgment and should not have been rejected under the motion schedule or successive-motion rule. Taking judicial notice, the Appellate Term, Second Department, concluded that recovery would impair rights established by the declaratory judgment. It reversed the provider's judgment, vacated the order, denied the provider's motion, and granted the insurer's later motion dismissing the complaint.

Reported in New York Official Reports at J.C. Healing Touch Rehab, P.C. v 21st Century Ins. Co. (2020 NY Slip Op 51296(U))

SUPREME COURT, APPELLATE TERM, SECOND DEPARTMENT, 2d, 11th and 13th JUDICIAL DISTRICTS

J.C. Healing Touch Rehab, P.C., as Assignee of Eusebio Carlos, Respondent,

against

21st Century Insurance Company, Appellant.

Law Offices of Buratti, Rothenberg & Burns (Bryan Rothenberg of counsel), for appellant. The Rybak Firm, PLLC (Damin J. Toell of counsel), for respondent.

Appeal from a judgment of the Civil Court of the City of New York, Kings County (Harriet L. Thompson, J.), entered February 1, 2019. The judgment, entered pursuant to an order of that court entered November 21, 2018 granting plaintiff’s motion for summary judgment, denying a cross motion made by defendant on August 25, 2011 for summary judgment dismissing the complaint, and rejecting a “cross” motion made by defendant on July 27, 2016, awarded plaintiff the principal sum of $1,670.32.

ORDERED that the judgment is reversed, with $30 costs, the order entered November 21, 2018 is vacated, plaintiff’s motion for summary judgment is denied and the “cross” motion made by defendant on July 27, 2016 for summary judgment dismissing the complaint is granted.

In this action by a provider to recover assigned first-party no-fault benefits, plaintiff moved for summary judgment. The parties’ attorneys subsequently entered into a stipulation setting forth a motion schedule, which adjourned the return date of the motion to December 22, 2011 and provided, among other things, that all opposition papers and cross motions must be served on or before September 22, 2011. On August 25, 2011, in accordance with the foregoing schedule, defendant 21st Century served a cross motion for summary judgment dismissing the [*2]complaint, arguing that it had timely denied the claims on the ground of material misrepresentation in the procurement of the insurance policy. Plaintiff opposed defendant’s cross motion in the Civil Court.

Before the Civil Court ruled on the motion and cross motion, 21st Century commenced a declaratory judgment action in the Supreme Court, Nassau County, and plaintiff herein appeared in that action. On December 19, 2011, the Supreme Court signed an order to show cause, which, among other things, temporarily stayed pending and future lawsuits by the instant provider and assignor, among others. By order entered May 29, 2012, the Supreme Court continued the stay pending the determination of the declaratory judgment action. By order entered May 6, 2015, the Supreme Court granted 21st Century’s motion for summary judgment. A judgment entered February 4, 2016 in the Supreme Court declared that 21st Century has no duty to provide coverage for specified collisions, including the incident herein, or for any claim for no-fault benefits arising out of those collisions. The judgment and orders with notices of their entry were served on the provider’s attorneys.

On July 22, 2016, based upon the declaratory judgment, defendant served what it denominated as a “cross” motion, with a return date of November 1, 2016, seeking an order in the Civil Court denying plaintiff’s motion for summary judgment, granting defendant’s summary judgment motion dismissing the complaint, granting defendant leave to amend its answer to include the affirmative defenses of collateral estoppel and res judicata and deeming the amended answer served. By order entered November 21, 2018, the Civil Court granted plaintiff’s motion and denied defendant’s August 25, 2011 cross motion on the ground that defendant’s answer had not asserted the affirmative defenses of collateral estoppel and res judicata, and found that the action had been “erroneously stayed.” The Civil Court further stated that it rejected defendant’s “additional cross motion,” served on July 27, 2016, as untimely under the parties’ motion schedule and “improper in violation of the one motion rule.” Defendant appeals from a judgment entered February 1, 2019 pursuant to the November 21, 2018 order, awarding plaintiff the principal sum of $1,670.32.

Contrary to the determination of the Civil Court, defendant’s failure to raise the affirmative defenses of collateral estoppel and res judicata in its answer was understandable and excusable since the declaratory judgment action had not been filed in the Supreme Court at the time defendant answered the instant complaint. Similarly, the order and judgment in the declaratory judgment action were not rendered until after defendant had cross-moved for summary judgment on August 25, 2011. Thus, as defendant argues, it had no reason to raise those affirmative defenses in the answer (see Renelique v State-Wide Ins. Co., 50 Misc 3d 137[A], 2016 NY Slip Op 50096[U] [App Term, 2d Dept, 2d, 11th & 13th Jud Dists 2016]).

Whether defendant’s July 27, 2016 papers be deemed a motion with a return date of November 1, 2016 or a “cross” motion, in either case, its July 27, 2016 papers served as a vehicle to introduce the Supreme Court’s orders and the declaratory judgment entered in favor of 21st Century, of which this court takes judicial notice (see Kingsbrook Jewish Med. Ctr. v Allstate [*3]Ins. Co., 61 AD3d 13 [2009]; Matter of Khatibi v Weill, 8 AD3d 485 [2004]; Renelique, 50 Misc 3d 137[A], 2016 NY Slip Op 50096[U]). “While it is true that multiple motions for summary judgment in the same action . . . are looked upon with disfavor, more than one motion is permissible where[, as here,] the subsequent motion is based upon newly discovered evidence or the moving party can demonstrate other sufficient cause for granting the motion” (Inter-Power of NY v Niagara Mohawk Power Corp., 259 AD2d 932, 933 [1999]). Consequently, under the particular circumstances presented herein, the Civil Court, for judicial economy, should not have rejected defendant’s 2016 “cross” motion and should have taken judicial notice of the declaratory judgment. In light of the declaratory judgment, defendant’s 2016 “cross” motion should have been granted under the doctrine of res judicata, as any judgment in favor of plaintiff in the present action would destroy or impair rights or interests established by the Supreme Court’s judgment (see Schuylkill Fuel Corp. v Nieberg Realty Corp., 250 NY 304, 306-307 [1929]; EBM Med. Health Care, P.C. v Republic W. Ins., 38 Misc 3d 1 [App Term, 2d Dept, 2d, 11th & 13th Jud Dists 2012]).

Accordingly, the judgment entered February 1, 2019 is reversed, the order entered November 21, 2018 is vacated, plaintiff’s motion for summary judgment is denied and the “cross” motion made by defendant on July 27, 2016 for summary judgment dismissing the complaint is granted.

WESTON, J.P., ELLIOT and SIEGAL, JJ., concur.



ENTER:
Paul Kenny
Chief Clerk

Decision Date: October 30, 2020

Legal questions

A question of no-fault law this decision rules on, from our Legal Questions pages. Bars count the decisions on the question by year and court, coloured by category; circles are this decision and the decisions on the question it cites or that cite it. Point at a bar or circle for details. The categories and summaries are Beynenson Law’s classification, made by a language model and checked by a second reading.

Effect of insurer's declaratory judgment

Open the full map

Does an insurer’s no-coverage declaratory judgment, or pending declaratory action, bar or stay a no-fault claimant’s action?

This decision: The DJ is given preclusive effect and bars every claim in the action that the court considered

Held that the insurer's later motion introducing a Supreme Court judgment declaring no coverage for the collision should have been granted under res judicata, excusing the omission of the defense from the answer because the DJ postdated it.

  • Appellate DivisionApp Div 4
  • Appellate TermApp Term 132
  • Trial courtsTrial 28
2021, Appellate Division: 1 decision (1 Stayed pending DJ)2016, Appellate Division: 1 decision (1 Stayed pending DJ)2015, Appellate Division: 1 decision (1 Stay denied)2025, Appellate Division: 1 decision (1 Barred by DJ)2023, Appellate Term: 7 decisions (5 Barred by DJ, 1 Not bound: parties, 1 DJ does not reach)2022, Appellate Term: 11 decisions (9 Barred by DJ, 1 DJ does not reach, 1 Stay denied)2021, Appellate Term: 11 decisions (8 Barred by DJ, 2 Not bound: parties, 1 DJ does not reach)2020, Appellate Term: 12 decisions (9 Barred by DJ, 1 Not bound: parties, 2 DJ does not reach)2019, Appellate Term: 15 decisions (7 Barred by DJ, 3 Not bound: parties, 1 DJ does not reach, 4 Stay denied)2018, Appellate Term: 11 decisions (7 Barred by DJ, 2 Not bound: parties, 2 DJ does not reach)2017, Appellate Term: 5 decisions (3 Barred by DJ, 2 DJ does not reach)2016, Appellate Term: 15 decisions (13 Barred by DJ, 1 Not bound: parties, 1 DJ does not reach)2015, Appellate Term: 14 decisions (11 Barred by DJ, 1 Not bound: parties, 2 DJ does not reach)2014, Appellate Term: 4 decisions (4 Barred by DJ)2013, Appellate Term: 3 decisions (1 Barred by DJ, 1 DJ does not reach, 1 Stayed pending DJ)2012, Appellate Term: 3 decisions (2 Barred by DJ, 1 Not bound: parties)2011, Appellate Term: 2 decisions (1 Barred by DJ, 1 DJ does not reach)2010, Appellate Term: 2 decisions (1 Not bound: parties, 1 Stayed pending DJ)2009, Appellate Term: 1 decision (1 Barred by DJ)2008, Appellate Term: 1 decision (1 Not bound: parties)2024, Appellate Term: 3 decisions (1 Not bound: parties, 2 DJ does not reach)2025, Appellate Term: 11 decisions (1 Barred by DJ, 1 Barred in part, 1 Not bound: parties, 8 DJ does not reach)2026, Appellate Term: 1 decision (1 Not bound: parties)2023, Trial courts: 1 decision (1 DJ does not reach)2022, Trial courts: 3 decisions (2 Barred by DJ, 1 Not bound: parties)2021, Trial courts: 4 decisions (4 Barred by DJ)2020, Trial courts: 1 decision (1 Barred by DJ)2019, Trial courts: 1 decision (1 Barred by DJ)2018, Trial courts: 1 decision (1 Barred by DJ)2013, Trial courts: 2 decisions (2 Barred by DJ)2011, Trial courts: 2 decisions (1 Barred by DJ, 1 Stayed pending DJ)2009, Trial courts: 1 decision (1 Stayed pending DJ)2008, Trial courts: 1 decision (1 Not bound: parties)2007, Trial courts: 2 decisions (1 Barred by DJ, 1 Stayed pending DJ)2006, Trial courts: 1 decision (1 Not bound: parties)2024, Trial courts: 2 decisions (1 Barred by DJ, 1 DJ does not reach)2026, Trial courts: 5 decisions (4 Barred by DJ, 1 Stay denied)2012, Trial courts: 1 decision (1 Stay denied)This decision
2010201520202025
Barred by DJBarred in partNot bound: partiesDJ does not reachStayed pending DJStay deniedThis decisionCites it or cited by itCited or followed

Of the 164 decisions on this question in the Second Department courts and the Court of Appeals, 101 (this one included) are in the same category.

Cited in this decision

A label shows how this decision treated the case it cites.

  • Renelique v State-Wide Ins. Co. (2016 NY Slip Op 50096(U)) FollowedAn unpleaded res judicata defense may support summary judgment absent surprise or prejudice to the opposing party.
  • Kingsbrook Jewish Med. Ctr. v Allstate Ins. Co. (2009 NY Slip Op 00351) FollowedJudicially noticed diagnosis codes alone do not establish that treatment was wholly unrelated to an insured automobile accident.
  • EBM Med. Health Care, P.C. v Republic W. Ins. (2012 NY Slip Op 22300) FollowedAn unvacated default declaratory judgment has res judicata effect in a provider's pending no-fault action.

Similar decisions

  • SS Med. Care, P.C. v 21st Century Ins. Co. (2019 NY Slip Op 52057(U))The provider's premature judgment was vacated, but its summary judgment order survived because the insurer lacked a reasonable default excuse.
  • ZG Chiropractic Care, P.C. v 21st Century Ins. Co. (2021 NY Slip Op 50079(U))The insurer justified vacating its default through an existing stay and obtained dismissal based on a preclusive declaratory judgment.
  • St. Mark’s Med. Health Care, PLLC v 21st Century Ins. Co. (2020 NY Slip Op 50851(U))An unvacated default declaratory judgment can bar a provider's later no-fault action under res judicata.
  • Freedom Chiropractic, P.C. v 21st Century Ins. Co. (2020 NY Slip Op 50686(U))The provider's default judgment was vacated because its mailed motion gave the insurer less than the required 13 days' notice.
  • Allay Med. Servs., P.C. v Nationwide Ins. (2021 NY Slip Op 50086(U))The provider's action was barred by res judicata because the prior declaratory judgment covered the same claim and accident.
Beynenson Law

Tech-driven New York no-fault collections for healthcare providers.

About the firm

Contact

  • East Hampton, New York

  • 347-746-6001
  • contact@beynensonlaw.com
  • Contact form

Research

  • Search Case Law & Regulations
  • New Decisions
  • Decisions by Court
  • Legal Questions
  • No-Fault Regulations
  • Claim Process & Deadlines
  • Ask No-Fault AI

Arbitration Data

  • Arbitrator Scorecard
  • Award Volume
  • Arbitrator / Carrier Data
  • Provider / Carrier Data
  • Provider / Attorney Data
  • Arbitration Pro Extension

©2026 The Beynenson Law Group, PC. Terms of Use Privacy Policy

Site by khrystev.dev

Attorney Advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. This website provides general information, not legal advice, and using it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Do not send confidential information through this site.