September 16, 2022
Fine Needle Acupuncture P.C. v State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co. (2022 NY Slip Op 50873(U))
https://www.beynensonlaw.com/case-law/fine-needle-acupuncture-p-c-v-state-farm-mut-auto-ins-co-2022-ny-slip-op50873u/
- Judge
- Wendy Changyong Li, J.
- Decided
- September 16, 2022
- Citation
- 2022 NY Slip Op 50873(U)
- Posture
- Summary judgment
- Outcome
- Insurer prevailed
Posture, outcome, issues and treatment by other decisions are Beynenson Law’s classification. Treatment labels are assigned by a language model reading the citing decision; negative and appeal-history labels are checked by a second reader.
Summary
Editorial summary by Beynenson Law, not part of the court’s decision.
Reported in New York Official Reports at Fine Needle Acupuncture P.C. v State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co. (2022 NY Slip Op 50873(U))
Fine Needle
Acupuncture P.C. as Assignee of Martinez, Plaintiff(s),
against State Farm Mutual Automobile Ins. Co., Defendant(s). |
Index No.: CV-700046-20/QU
Plaintiff’s counsel: Law Offices of Gabriel & Shapiro LLC, 3361 Park Avenue Suite 1000, Wantagh, NY 11793
Defendant’s counsel: Rivkin Radler LLP, 926 RexCorp Plaza, Uniondale, NY 11556
Wendy Changyong Li, J.I. Papers
The following papers were read on Defendant’s motion for summary judgment dismissing Plaintiff’s complaint:
Papers Numbered
Defendant’s Notice of Motion and Affirmation dated January 25, 2021 (“Motion”) and electronically filed with the court on the same date. 1
Plaintiff’s opposition N/A
II. Background
In a summons and complaint filed July 12, 2018, Defendant commenced an action in Supreme Court, Nassau County (“Supreme Court Action“) against Plaintiff seeking a judgment declaring that Defendant owed no duty to pay Plaintiff’s No-Fault claims because Plaintiff failed to appear for scheduled examinations under oath (“EUO“) (see Motion, Aff. of Pontrello, Ex. 3). In a summons and complaint filed January 2, 2020, Plaintiff sued Defendant insurance company to recover $346.52 in unpaid first party No-Fault benefits for medical services provided to Plaintiff’s assignor Martinez from September 8 to 27, 2017, for injuries sustained in an automobile accident, plus attorneys’ fees and statutory interest (see Motion, Pontrello Aff., Ex. 1). Defendant now moved for summary judgment dismissing Plaintiff’s complaint on the ground that the action is barred by res judicata. Plaintiff did not oppose Defendant’s motion.
III. Discussion
“Under the doctrine of res judicata, a party may not litigate a claim where a judgment on the merits exists from a prior action between the same parties involving the same subject matter” (Matter of Hunter, 4 NY3d 260, 269 [2005], see Simmons v Trans Express Inc., 37 NY3d 107, [*2]111 [2021]; Matter of Josey v Goord, 9 NY3d 386, 389 [2007]; Healthway Med. Care, P.C. v American Tr. Ins. Co., 54 Misc 3d 127[A], 2016 NY Slip Op 51786[U] *1 [App Term 2d Dept 2016]; Infinity Chiropractic Health, P.C. v Republic W. Ins. Co., 53 Misc 3d 144[A], 2016 NY Slip Op 51564[U] *1 [App Term 2d Dept 2016]). “Once a claim is brought to a final conclusion, all other claims arising out of the same transaction or series of transactions are barred, even if based upon different theories or if seeking a different remedy” (Simmons v Trans Express Inc., 37 NY3d at 111; O’Brien v City of Syracuse, 54 NY2d 353, 357 [1981], see Matter of Josey v Goord, 9 NY3d at 390; Tracey v Deutsche Bank Natl. Trust Co., 187 AD3d 815, 817 [2d Dept 2020]). Here, Defendant relied on an order dated October 4, 2019 (“Supreme Court Order“) in the Supreme Court Action, in which Supreme Court denied Plaintiff’s motion to compel arbitration, finding that Plaintiff “failed to satisfy the requirement of insurance coverage by appearing for the examination under an oath as noticed by” Defendants (State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co. v Fine Needle Acupuncture, PC, Sup. Ct. Nassau County, October 4, 2019, Brandveen, J., Index No. 609282/18; Motion, Pontrello Aff., Ex. 4). Since the Supreme Court Order was not an order granting Defendant a default judgment, as Defendant erroneously contended, here, Defendant failed to demonstrate that res judicata bars the present action.
Nevertheless, the related concept of collateral estoppel bars Plaintiff’s action. Collateral estoppel or issue preclusion prevents re-litigation of a factual or legal issue actually raised and resolved in a prior court determination (Paramount Pictures Corp. v Allianz Risk Transfer AG, 31 NY3d 64, 72 [2018]; Buechel v Bain, 97 NY2d 295, 303 [2001]; Matter of B.Z. Chiropractic, P.C. v Allstate Ins. Co., 197 AD3d 144, 152 [2d Dept 2021]; Coleman v J.P. Morgan Chase Bank N.A., 190 AD3d 931, 931-32 [2d Dept 2021]). In order to apply collateral estoppel, “there must be an identity of issue which has necessarily been decided in the prior action and is decisive of the present action, and there must have been a full and fair opportunity to contest the decision now said to be controlling” (Buechel v Bain, 97 NY2d at 303-04; Coleman v J.P. Morgan Chase Bank N.A., 190 AD3d at 932). In our instant case, both factors have been established. In the Supreme Court Action, Supreme Court found that Plaintiff failed to appear for the scheduled EUOs and did not challenge that Defendant requested the EUOs and had a valid reason for requesting them. It is well settled that noncompliance with an insurance policy provision requiring disclosure through an EUO is a failure of a condition precedent to an insurer’s duty to indemnify (IDS Prop. Cas. Ins. Co. v Stracar Med. Servs., P.C., 116 AD3d 1005, 1007 [2d Dept 2014]; National Med. & Surgical Supply, Inc. v ELRAC, Inc., 54 Misc 3d 131[A], 2017 NY Slip Op 50028[U] *1 [App Term 2d Dept 2017]) and is a material policy breach precluding recovery of proceeds under the insurance policy (Nationwide Affinity Ins. Co. of Am. v George, 183 AD3d 755, 756 [2d Dept 2020]; Interboro Ins. Co. v Clennon, 113 AD3d 596, 597 [2d Dept 2014]). Since Plaintiff is collaterally estopped from raising the issue of its non-attendance of the EUOs in the instant matter and Defendant presented evidence that it had timely denied Plaintiff’s claim based on Plaintiff’s failure to attend the EUOs (see Motion, Pontrello Aff., Ex. A), Defendant here is entitled to dismissal of Plaintiff’s complaint.
IV. Order
Accordingly, it is
ORDERED that Defendant’s motion for summary judgment is granted without opposition and Plaintiff’s complaint is dismissed; and it is further
ORDERED that the part clerk is directed to dispose the index number for all purposes.
This constitutes the Decision and Order of the court.
Dated: September 16, 2022
Queens County Civil Court
Honorable Wendy Changyong Li, J.C.C.
Legal questions (3)
Questions of no-fault law this decision rules on, from our Legal Questions pages. Bars count the decisions on the question by year and court, coloured by category; circles are this decision and the decisions on the question it cites or that cite it. Point at a bar or circle for details. The categories and summaries are Beynenson Law’s classification, made by a language model and checked by a second reading.
Does an insurer’s no-coverage declaratory judgment, or pending declaratory action, bar or stay a no-fault claimant’s action?
This decision: The DJ is given preclusive effect and bars every claim in the action that the court considered
Rejected res judicata because the Supreme Court order was not a default judgment, but held the provider collaterally estopped by that court's finding that it failed to appear for EUOs, and dismissed the action.
Of the 164 decisions on this question in the Second Department courts and the Court of Appeals, 101 (this one included) are in the same category.
Is an IME/EUO no-show defense precluded if the insurer did not timely deny the claim on that ground?
This decision: Timely denial required as part of the no-show defense, and the insurer showed it (rules on the question, but another ground decided the case)
Required, in addition to the estopped nonappearance issue, that the insurer show it timely denied the claim on the EUO no-show ground, and found it did.
Of the 508 decisions on this question in the Second Department courts and the Court of Appeals, 338 (this one included) are in the same category.
Did the insurer prove its IME/EUO no-show defense: mailed, compliant scheduling requests and the claimant’s nonappearance?
This decision: Insurer proved mailed, compliant requests and the nonappearance; claimant's answers rejected (rules on the question, but another ground decided the case)
Held the provider's nonappearance at the EUOs established by collateral estoppel from the Supreme Court's finding in the insurer's declaratory action, where the request and its justification were not challenged.
Of the 858 decisions on this question in the Second Department courts and the Court of Appeals, 527 (this one included) are in the same category.
Cited in this decision
- Healthway Med. Care, P.C. v American Tr. Ins. Co. (2016 NY Slip Op 51786(U))The provider's claims were barred by res judicata because a prior declaration resolved coverage for the same accident between the same parties.
- Infinity Chiropractic Health, P.C. v Republic W. Ins. Co. (2016 NY Slip Op 51564(U))A default declaratory judgment against a provider bars its assigned claims even without service on or a declaration against the assignor.
- Matter of B.Z. Chiropractic, P.C. v Allstate Ins. Co. (2021 NY Slip Op 04484)Dicta do not have preclusive effect under res judicata, collateral estoppel or law of the case.
- IDS Prop. Cas. Ins. Co. v Stracar Med. Servs., P.C. (2014 NY Slip Op 02902)The providers' unexcused EUO nonappearances materially breached a condition precedent to indemnity and warranted summary judgment for the insurer.
- National Med. & Surgical Supply, Inc. v ELRAC, Inc. (2017 NY Slip Op 50028(U))An assignor's appearance at a duly requested EUO is a condition precedent to coverage, whether requested before or after claim submission.
- Nationwide Affinity Ins. Co. of Am. v George (2020 NY Slip Op 02801)The insurer proved timely EUO notices, two nonappearances by each assignor, and timely denials; the providers raised no factual issue.
- Interboro Ins. Co. v Clennon (2014 NY Slip Op 00092)The assignor's two EUO nonappearances supported a declaration that the providers were not entitled to no-fault benefits.
Similar decisions
- Dos Manos Chiropractic, P.C. v State Farm Ins. Co. (2022 NY Slip Op 50995(U))An unvacated default declaratory judgment precludes a provider's benefits action involving the same parties and accident under res judicata.
- Columbus Imaging Ctr. v Country Wide Ins. Co. (2021 NY Slip Op 50851(U))The provider's action was barred by an unvacated default declaratory judgment establishing that the insurer owed no no-fault benefits.
- New York Core Chiropractic, P.C. v Ameriprise Ins. Co. (2021 NY Slip Op 50599(U))An EUO request sent after 15 business days but within 30 calendar days tolls the time to pay or deny, with a reduction for lateness.
- Park Ave. Chiropractic & Health Care PC v Maya Assur. Co. (2021 NY Slip Op 50804(U))A provider's EUO objection written after the scheduled examination date is ineffective and does not excuse nonappearance.
- Sloan v Nationwide Mut. Ins. Co. (2022 NY Slip Op 50997(U))The insurer's EUO defense failed because its initial request and its denial following the second nonappearance were untimely.