September 4, 2019
ACH Chiropractic P.C. v Geico Ins. Co. (2019 NY Slip Op 51439(U))
https://www.beynensonlaw.com/case-law/ach-chiropractic-p-c-v-geico-ins-co-2019-ny-slip-op-51439u/
- Judge
- Consuelo Mallafre-Melendez, J.
- Decided
- September 4, 2019
- Citation
- 2019 NY Slip Op 51439(U)
- Posture
- Summary judgment
- Outcome
- Insurer prevailed
- Legal questions
- No covered accident (founded belief) (see the maps)
Posture, outcome, issues and treatment by other decisions are Beynenson Law’s classification. Treatment labels are assigned by a language model reading the citing decision; negative and appeal-history labels are checked by a second reader.
Summary
Editorial summary by Beynenson Law, not part of the court’s decision.
Reported in New York Official Reports at ACH Chiropractic P.C. v Geico Ins. Co. (2019 NY Slip Op 51439(U))
ACH Chiropractic
P.C., a/a/o CENEVIL, DAVID, Plaintiff,
against Geico Ins. Co., Defendant. |
744329/16
Attorney for Plaintiff
Oleg Rybak, Esq.
The Rybak Firm, PLLC
1810 Voorhies Ave., 3rd Floor, Ste. 7
Brooklyn, NY 11235
(718) 975-2035
Attorney for Defendant
Katherine A. Hazelton, Esq.
Law Office of Goldstein
& Flecker
2 Huntington Quadrangle, Ste. 2N01
Melville, NY 11747
(516)
714-7927
Consuelo Mallafre-Melendez, J.
The court’s Decision and Order is based upon consideration of the following papers:
CPLR 2219(a) RecitationNOTICE OF MOTION & AFFIDAVITS ANNEXED 1
OPPOSITION/CROSS-MOTION 2
REPLY/OPPOSITION TO CROSS-MOTION 3
SUR REPLY
This is an action by Plaintiff medical provider to recover assigned first-party no-fault benefits for treatment provided to its assignor, David Cenevil (Injured Party). Plaintiff argues that it met its prima facie burden and requests that summary judgment be granted in its favor pursuant to CPLR 3212. Defendant opposes Plaintiff’s motion and cross moves for dismissal on grounds that the injuries were the result of an intentional assault when the insured, Bernard Foy (Insured), used his vehicle as a weapon to deliberately strike the Injured Party. Accordingly, Defendant asserts that the Injured Party’s injuries were not the result of an accident, but an intentional act which is not a covered loss under 11 N.Y.C.R.R. § 65-2.2(a). This court agrees.
In New York, an insurer must provide no-fault insurance benefits for injuries resulting from an accident. 11 N.Y.C.R.R. § 65-2.2(a), requires coverage for “personal injuries caused by an accident arising out of the use or operation of a motor vehicle” (emphasis added). In order for an insurer to be relieved of its obligation to cover a loss, it must come forward with evidence to demonstrate that the injuries were a result of an intentional or deliberate action (State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co. v. Langan, 16 NY3d 349 [2011]; Liberty Mut. Ins. Co. v. Goddard, 29 AD3d 698 [2d Dept. 2006]). An insurer must establish its “founded belief” that the incident was an intentional act by a preponderance of the evidence (A.B. Med. Services PLLC v. Eagle Ins. Co., 3 Misc 3d 8, 9 [2d Dept. 2003]; V.S. Med. Servs., P.C. v. Allstate Ins. Co., 25 Misc 3d 39 [2d Dept. 2009]), and can meet its burden with circumstantial evidence (State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co., v. Laguerre, 305 AD2d 490 [2d Dept. 2003]).
Here, Defendant has met its burden through substantial documentary evidence including a police accident report, a criminal complaint an arrest report and an affidavit from Defendant’s Special Investigation Unit (SIU) investigator Doug Pfleging. These documents consistently support a clear finding that the incident which lead to the Injured Party’s injuries was a result of an intentional act. According to the police accident report, the Insured deliberately hit the Injured Party with his vehicle: “At TPO witness stated that deft had a verbal dispute with his step son [sic]. Witness stated that deft (step father) used his vehicle to hit c/v and fled the accident scene” (Deft. Exh. B). Pursuant to the arrest report, the Insured was subsequently arrested on several charges including felony assault with intent to cause serious physical injury and felony assault for using his vehicle as a weapon (Deft. Exh. C).
In New York, to determine whether an event was accidental “it is customary to look at the casualty from the point of view of the insured, to see whether or not it was unexpected, unusual and unforeseen'” (State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co. v. Langan, 16 NY3d at 355 quoting Miller v. Continental Ins. Co., 40 NY2d 675, 677 [1976]). The view point of the injured party is not considered “[b]ecause an injury is always fortuitous to a non-consenting victim” (State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co. v. Langan, 16 NY3d at 355 quoting Michaels v. City of Buffalo, 85 NY2d [*2]754, 759 [1995]). The same is true when the injured party seeks benefits under the policy’s uninsured motorist endorsement (Castillo v. Motor Vehicle Indemnification Corp., 161 AD3d 937 [2d Dept. 2018]; Utica Mut. Ins. Co. v. Burrous, 121 AD3d 910 [2d Dept. 2014]). Here, both the witness’ statement and the testimony from the Injured Party are consistent with a finding that from the Insured’s perspective, the incident was a deliberate act meant to cause injury (Deft. Exh. D; see generally McCarthy v. Motor Vehicle Indemnification Corp., 12 NY2d 922 [1963]).
Plaintiff’s arguments concerning its prima facie case and timely denial of the claims are irrelevant. Defendant insurer “is not precluded, despite untimely disclaimer, from raising as a defense its denial of liability on the ground that the services rendered to treat the injuries at issue did not arise from a covered accident” (General Hospital v. Chubb Group of Insurance Companies, 90 NY2d 195, 201 [1997]). Furthermore, Defendant’s “strict compliance with the time requirements of both statute and regulations may be obviated and the preclusion remedy rendered unavailable when denial of claims is premised on a lack of coverage” (General Hospital v. Chubb Group of Insurance Companies, 90 NY2d at199).
Based on the foregoing, Plaintiff’s motion for summary judgment is denied. Defendant’s cross motion to dismiss is granted.
This constitutes the decision and order of this court.
September 4, 2019
Brooklyn, NY
ENTER.
__________________________________
CONSUELO MALLAFRE-MELENDEZ
Judge, Civil Court
Legal questions
A question of no-fault law this decision rules on, from our Legal Questions pages. Bars count the decisions on the question by year and court, coloured by category; circles are this decision and the decisions on the question it cites or that cite it. Point at a bar or circle for details. The categories and summaries are Beynenson Law’s classification, made by a language model and checked by a second reading.
Did the insurer show the claimed injuries did not arise from a covered accident (staged, intentional, or unrelated)?
This decision: Insurer proved the injuries did not arise from a covered accident
Held the insurer proved by a preponderance, through police, arrest and investigator records, that the insured deliberately struck the assignor with his vehicle, so the injuries were not caused by an accident and were not covered.
Of the 235 decisions on this question in the Second Department courts and the Court of Appeals, 33 (this one included) are in the same category.
Cited in this decision
A label shows how this decision treated the case it cites.
- State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co. v Langan (2011 NY Slip Op 02437) FollowedAn intentional vehicular assault on an innocent insured is an accident under the insured's own UM, PIP and death benefit endorsements.
- A.B. Med. Servs. v Eagle Ins. Co. (2003 NY Slip Op 23978) FollowedThe insurer's investigator's affidavit failed to raise a triable issue that the collision was staged.
- V.S. Med. Servs., P.C. v Allstate Ins. Co. (2009 NY Slip Op 29310)An insurer may prove that a collision was intentional and outside no-fault coverage by a preponderance of the evidence.
Similar decisions
- A.M Med. v New York Cent. Mut. Ins. Co. (2004 NY Slip Op 50298(U))The insurer's unsworn low-impact report failed to establish a coverage defense or raise a triable issue concerning injury causation.
- CuraHealth Specialty Pharm. Corp v State Farm Ins. Co. (2026 NY Slip Op 50852(U))The insurer established a founded belief that the collision was intentionally caused, and the provider failed to raise a triable issue.
- Pavlova v Allstate Ins. Co. (2019 NY Slip Op 50016(U))The insurer's EUO nonappearance defense was precluded by a denial issued more than 30 days after the last scheduled EUO. The Civil Court, Kings County, denied summary judgment to the insurer and granted summary judgment to the provider.
- Advanced Recovery Equip. & Supplies, LLC v Motor Veh. Indem. Corp. (2019 NY Slip Op 50590(U))MVAIC's failure to timely deny a claim does not excuse failure to file the notice required as a condition precedent to coverage.
- A.B. Med. Servs. PLLC v State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co. (2006 NY Slip Op 51033(U))The insurer's EUO evidence did not establish a founded belief that the claimed injuries arose from a noncovered event.