Arbitrator Data
Calendar of Awards Submitted by the Arbitrator
The calendar below shows the dates and numbers of awards submitted by the Arbitrator. This may be an indicator of whether the awards are generally submitted in bulk or on a rolling basis.
Number of Awards Over Time
This graph shows the weekly numbers of awards submitted by the Arbitrator. This gives a picture of relative caseload trends for this Arbitrator.
Percentage of Awards in Favor of Applicant
This graph shows the monthly rate of awards in favor of the Applicant vs. Respondent. The blue line shows the percentage of awards rendered by this Arbitrator in favor of the Applicant. The red line shows only considers the awards in cases by the given Respondent.
Average Time to Award
The blue line shows the average number of days between the actual hearing and the Arbitrator making the hearing closed. This may be an indicator of the Arbitrator’s willingness to accept post-hearing submissions or to continue hearings. The red line shows the average number of days between the hearing being closed and the award being submitted. This is useful to set expectations of when an award may be rendered.
Awards
The table below shows the awards written by the Arbitrator starting with the most recent.
id | Arbitrator | Case No. | Provider | Insurance Co | Award Date | Hearing Date | Hearing Closed Date | Applicant Attorney | Applicant Appearance By | Respondent Attorney | Respondent Appearance By | Holding | Original Claim Amount | Amended Claim Amount | Total Awarded | Interest Start Date | Interest (approx) | Attorney Fee (approx) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1,132,021 | Anne Malone | 17-24-1370-4722 | LENSE SUPPLY INC. | Geico Insurance Company | 07/02/2025 | 06/09/2025 | 06/09/2025 | The Law Offices of John Gallagher, PLLC | John Gallagher, Esq | Geico Insurance Company | Joseph Costa-Cappucci | DENIED | 502.63 | |||||
1,132,019 | Anne Malone | 17-24-1369-5441 | LENSE SUPPLY INC. | Geico Insurance Company | 07/02/2025 | 06/09/2025 | 06/09/2025 | The Law Offices of John Gallagher, PLLC | John Gallagher, Esq | Geico Insurance Company | Joseph Costa-Cappucci | DENIED | 1,332.65 | |||||
1,131,978 | Anne Malone | 17-24-1369-5049 | LENSE SUPPLY INC. | Geico Insurance Company | 07/02/2025 | 06/09/2025 | 06/09/2025 | The Law Offices of John Gallagher, PLLC | John Gallagher, Esq | Geico Insurance Company | Joseph Costa-Cappucci | DENIED | 1,150.00 | |||||
1,131,865 | Anne Malone | 17-24-1367-4355 | LENSE SUPPLY INC. | Geico Insurance Company | 07/01/2025 | 06/09/2025 | 06/09/2025 | The Law Offices of John Gallagher, PLLC | John Gallagher, Esq | Geico Insurance Company | Joseph Costa-Cappucci | AWARDED | 4,347.58 | 4,347.58 | 3,751.30 | 09/30/2024 | 685.24 | 887.31 |
1,131,844 | Anne Malone | 17-24-1362-5497 | GRAINMED INC | Geico Insurance Company | 07/01/2025 | 06/09/2025 | 06/09/2025 | The Law Offices of John Gallagher, PLLC | John Gallagher, Esq | Geico Insurance Company | Joseph Costa-Cappucci | DENIED | 3,461.70 | |||||
1,131,822 | Anne Malone | 17-24-1355-8066 | HUDSON PAIN MEDICINE PC | MVAIC | 07/01/2025 | 06/09/2025 | 06/09/2025 | Law Offices of Andrew J. Costella Jr., Esq. | Melissa Scotti, Esq | Marshall & Marshall, Esqs. | Craig Marshall, Esq. | DISMISSED without prejudice | 200.00 | |||||
1,131,821 | Anne Malone | 17-24-1362-9084 | HUDSON PAIN MEDICINE PC | MVAIC | 07/01/2025 | 06/09/2025 | 06/09/2025 | Law Offices of Andrew J. Costella Jr., Esq. | Melissa Scotti, Esq | Marshall & Marshall, Esqs. | Craig Marshall, Esq. | DISMISSED without prejudice | 1,660.00 | |||||
1,131,798 | Anne Malone | 17-24-1362-9088 | A TO Z PHYSICAL THERAPY PC | MVAIC | 07/01/2025 | 06/09/2025 | 06/09/2025 | Law Offices of Andrew J. Costella Jr., Esq. | Melissa Scotti, Esq | Marshall & Marshall, Esqs. | Craig Marshall, Esq. | AWARDED | 1,229.66 | 1,229.66 | 802.22 | 08/29/2024 | 163.65 | 193.17 |
1,131,748 | Anne Malone | 17-24-1355-8049 | A TO Z PHYSICAL THERAPY PC | MVAIC | 07/01/2025 | 06/09/2025 | 06/09/2025 | Law Offices of Andrew J. Costella Jr., Esq. | Melissa Scotti, Esq | Marshall & Marshall, Esqs. | Craig Marshall, Esq. | DENIED | 1,748.29 | |||||
1,131,651 | Anne Malone | 17-24-1356-3801 | SUESSERMAN CHIROPRACTIC PC | MVAIC | 07/01/2025 | 06/09/2025 | 06/09/2025 | Law Offices of Andrew J. Costella Jr., Esq. | Melissa Scotti, Esq | Marshall & Marshall, Esqs. | Craig Marshall, Esq. | DENIED | 1,069.69 | |||||
1,131,509 | Anne Malone | 17-25-1384-3478 | PARK AVENUE ORTHOTICS INC. | Liberty Mutual Insurance Company | 06/30/2025 | 06/30/2025 | 06/30/2025 | The Odierno Law Firm P.C. | Michael Spector, Esq | Liberty Mutual Insurance Company | Maria Bona | DENIED | 130.00 | |||||
1,131,508 | Anne Malone | 17-24-1377-4901 | ROCKAWAY COMPLETE CHIROPRACTIC PC | New York City Transit Authority | 06/30/2025 | 06/30/2025 | 06/30/2025 | The Odierno Law Firm P.C. | Michael Spector, Esq | Foley, Smit, O'Boyle & Weisman | Laura Weiss, Esq. | DENIED | 2,553.73 | |||||
1,131,507 | Anne Malone | 17-24-1375-1076 | A TO Z MEDICAL CARE PC | MVAIC | 06/30/2025 | 06/30/2025 | 06/30/2025 | The Odierno Law Firm P.C. | Michael Spector, Esq | Marshall & Marshall, Esqs. | Craig Marshall, Esq. | DISMISSED without prejudice | 483.88 | |||||
1,131,506 | Anne Malone | 17-24-1375-1079 | A TO Z MEDICAL CARE PC | MVAIC | 06/30/2025 | 06/30/2025 | 06/30/2025 | The Odierno Law Firm P.C. | Michael Spector, Esq | Marshall & Marshall, Esqs. | Craig Marshall, Esq. | DISMISSED without prejudice | 483.88 | |||||
1,131,493 | Anne Malone | 17-24-1377-4551 | PATIENT CHIROPRACTIC PC | American Transit Insurance Company | 06/30/2025 | 06/30/2025 | 06/30/2025 | Law Offices of Rima Nayberg P.C | Rima Nayberg, Esq | American Transit Insurance Company | Luke Rosenberger, Esq. | DISMISSED without prejudice | 2,330.56 | |||||
1,131,492 | Anne Malone | 17-24-1378-7584 | SEDATION VACATION PERIOPERATIVE MEDICINE PLLC | Country-Wide Insurance Company | 06/30/2025 | 06/30/2025 | 06/30/2025 | The Law Office of Thomas Tona, PC | Vijay Gupta, Esq | Jaffe & Velazquez, LLP | Ellen Maisto, Esq. | DENIED | 148.55 | |||||
1,131,319 | Anne Malone | 17-24-1378-4286 | LENOX HILL RADIOLOGY & MEDICAL IMAGING ASSOCIATES PC | LM General Insurance Company | 06/30/2025 | 06/02/2025 | 06/02/2025 | Choudhry & Franzoni, PLLC | Tinamarie Franzoni, Esq | LM General Insurance Company | Colleen Foster | DENIED | 1,450.97 | |||||
1,131,269 | Anne Malone | 17-24-1378-4213 | ZWANGER-PESIRI RADIOLOGY GROUP LLP | Palisades Insurance Company | 06/30/2025 | 06/02/2025 | 06/02/2025 | Choudhry & Franzoni, PLLC | Tinamarie Franzoni, Esq | Law Office of William J. Fitzula | Noel Lastre, Esq. | DENIED | 1,643.29 | |||||
1,131,100 | Anne Malone | 17-24-1378-3811 | LENOX HILL HOSPITAL (NSUH) | Allstate Insurance Company | 06/29/2025 | 06/02/2025 | 06/02/2025 | Horn Wright, LLP | Alexander Mun, Esq | Law Offices of John Trop | Dana Nelson, Esq. | DENIED | 1,944.00 | |||||
1,131,099 | Anne Malone | 17-24-1378-3731 | LENOX HILL HOSPITAL (NSUH) | Allstate Insurance Company | 06/29/2025 | 06/02/2025 | 06/02/2025 | Horn Wright, LLP | Alexander Mun, Esq | Law Offices of John Trop | Dana Nolan, Esq. | DENIED | 1,944.00 | |||||
1,131,091 | Anne Malone | 17-24-1355-4485 | HEALTH WELLNESS MEDICAL SERVICES PLLC | Liberty Mutual Fire Insurance Company | 06/29/2025 | 06/02/2025 | 06/02/2025 | The Tadchiev Law Firm, P.C. | Sabine Sciarotto, Esq | Callinan & Smith LLP | Elvira Messina, Esq. | DENIED | 1,260.78 | |||||
1,130,706 | Anne Malone | 17-24-1376-2785 | ATLANTIS SURGERY CENTER, LLC | Allstate Indemnity Company | 06/27/2025 | 06/02/2025 | 06/02/2025 | Horn Wright, LLP | Alexander Mun, Esq | Law Offices of John Trop | Dana Nolan, Esq. | AWARDED | 1,952.76 | 1,952.76 | 1,952.76 | 11/28/2024 | 274.69 | 445.49 |
1,130,680 | Anne Malone | 17-24-1365-6568 | LEORA BARZI, PA,JASODA DHUPAN | Allstate Insurance Company | 06/27/2025 | 06/02/2025 | 06/02/2025 | Leon Kucherovsky Esq. | Steven Palumbo, Esq | Law Offices of John Trop | Dana Nelson, Esq. | AWARDED | 2,382.52 | 2,382.52 | 104.81 | 09/17/2024 | 19.77 | 24.92 |
1,130,563 | Anne Malone | 17-24-1350-5656 | AXION MED INC. | Hereford Insurance Company | 06/27/2025 | 06/02/2025 | 06/02/2025 | The Tadchiev Law Firm, P.C. | Sabine Sciarotto, Esq | Law Offices of Ruth Nazarian | Cliff Ryan, Esq. | AWARDED | 2,325.00 | 2,250.00 | 2,250.00 | 06/04/2024 | 582.00 | 566.40 |
1,130,261 | Anne Malone | 17-24-1354-9645 | RIGHT CHOICE SUPPLY, INC. | State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company | 06/26/2025 | 06/23/2025 | 06/23/2025 | Law Offices of Ilya E Parnas P.C. | Robin Grumet, Esq | Rossillo & Licata LLP | Joseph Licata, Esq. | DENIED | 111.07 | |||||
Case No. | Provider | Insurance Co | Applicant Attorney | Applicant Appearance By | Respondent Attorney | Respondent Appearance By | Total Awarded |